3 ms·
I think it's misleading to call Mattermost "open source". Mattermost the for-profit company makes two products, one of which is open source, and a much larger
by sneak 4y ago
I think it's misleading to call Mattermost "open source". Mattermost the for-profit company makes two products, one of which is open source, and a much larger one (which is approximately feature complete wrt modern Slack-likes) which is absolutely not.
The open source product they make does not work like a normal open source project: submitted improvements to it will presumably be denied if they add functionality that exists in the proprietary and closed source second product, also called Mattermost, or if they serve users (like removing the silent and nonconsensual phone-home spyware from segment.io that they embed in the released binaries). It's a normal and expected thing in the open source world for user communities to be able to participate in the software project. That's one of the defined goals of the idea of open source: you can fix and improve it, and share your fixes and improvements.
Mattermost the company is not really an "open source company", as they build and sell proprietary software as their main source of revenue. Their goal is increasing the use of proprietary software, and every user of the open source Mattermost is a target for them to convince to stop using open source and start using proprietary software. This is presumably why they make their open source version phone home to tell them about your usage of it, so that they can try to get you to pay them to start using the proprietary one if you get big/rich enough.
Furthermore, to even contribute to the "open source" project of Mattermost, you are required to sign a CLA, because they want to be able to resell your work commercially under nonfree licenses. You'll note there is no CLA required for most real open source work, because they don't care if you retain copyright - the open source license is all they need. There is no CLA required to contribute to Linux or gcc.
Mattermost the software is not really an "open source project" because you can't meaningfully improve the software as the maintainer has a vested financial interest in keeping basic features (like message expiry/retention periods/SSO) out of it to direct the community to become paid customers of their proprietary software.
Mattermost wants to use the work of contributors to an open source project to further their proprietary software goals, while maintaining their open source bait as a neutered stub.
It's open source in name only. The real Mattermost product is proprietary and the open source version only exists as a fake open source project to serve as an onramp for selling their closed source proprietary one.
- westurner 4y ago> [Open-core Software Firm X] wants to use the work of contributors to an open source project to further their proprietary software goals, while maintaining their open source bait as a neutered stub. Source-available software: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Source-available_software https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Source-available_software Open-core model > Examples: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-core_model#Examples https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-core_model#Examples Who can merge which pull requests to the most-tested and most-maintained branch of a fork? CLAs are advisable regardless of software license. Re: Free and Open Source governance models: https://twitter.com/westurner/status/1308465144863903744 https://twitter.com/westurner/status/1308465144863903744