3 ms·
Not having tag hierarchies doesn't fix the difficulty of classification, it just handwaves it away. There will always need to be (super)tags that are collection
by pessimizer 4y ago
Not having tag hierarchies doesn't fix the difficulty of classification, it just handwaves it away. There will always need to be (super)tags that are collections of other tags, where it is a bug for an item that has a particular tag to not also have another, related tag. The question should be how you're going to handle that, not if you're going to handle it, or you'll end up with a lot of broken tags of dubious usefulness.
Tags are just dumb strings that label data, but tags are also data. If I can't label tag:"red" a tag:"colored" in your system, it's not great. It's not much better if I'm labeling things tag:"colored-red" because if I'm doing that and there's no central validation to add semantics to that relationship, I'm going to end up with tag:"red" things, tag:"colored" things, tag:"colored-red" things, and probably even tag:"color-red" and tag:"red-color" things.
edit: what's so bad about cycles when it comes to a tag being assigned another tag that has been assigned the original tag? It's just a mutual implication. There's nothing wrong to me with adding a single tag and seeing five more added automatically. It means that you're building a knowledge base.
- twobitshifter 4y agoThis is just search with synonym analyzer / partial match. If you make the tag search dynamic, you’ll find the tags you’re looking for quickly.
- kortex 4y ago> It means that you're building a knowledge base. That's precisely the problem. You started with tags and now you are building a knowledge base. You wanted a banana and now you have a gorilla holding a banana and the whole jungle. If you want to build a knowledge base, use links/URIs/ontologies. You'll find out the moment you add cycles the algorithms get way more intense. And then once you have stronger algos, you want more search power. Next thing you know you are bikeshedding about things like "apple" is both "fruit" and "tech company" so you need tags-of-tags etc. Just build a knowledge base if you need a knowledge base. Otherwise tags are just a way to do faceted search. They aren't mutually exclusive, either. OpenTelemetry, for example, has both tags and references.