3 ms·
Take some number of things. Lay them out more or less in a straight line. Somewhere in that line, put a little gap. Count them from left to right. Then coun
by AnimalMuppet 4y ago
Take some number of things. Lay them out more or less in a straight line. Somewhere in that line, put a little gap. Count them from left to right. Then count them from right to left. You get the same number.
That experiment is saying that addition commutes. If an alien ran that experiment, they would get the same answer.
Lay out some things in regular rows in a rectangle. Count the things row by row. Then count the things column by column. You'll get the same answer. So will an alien. That is, multiplication commutes both for us and for the aliens.
Now, as you go further into mathematics, things are true because they follow from the definitions, but the aliens may use different definitions. They may have a different definitions for, say, a commutative ring, and so abstract algebra may be different for them. But with the same definitions, we would arrive at the same conclusions.
- Koshkin 4y ago> If an alien ran that experiment, they would get the same answer. This depends on the world they live in. If, for example, things were hard to control, tended to move, to disappear (and reappear in a different place), to look the same, etc., they would probably discover quantum field theory before arithmetic!
- dagw 4y agothey would probably discover quantum field theory before arithmetic! Sure, but much like we eventually discovered quantum field theory, they'll eventually discover arithmetic. And even if for some weird reason they hadn't, they're probably smart enough to understand it once we demonstrate it to them.
- vecter 4y agoThat's logically impossible for many reasons, the first of which is that arithmetic is a prerequisite for quantum field theory, and that secondly quantum effects like those don't occur at scales at which intelligent organisms live.
- wizofaus 4y agoGood analogy but is it so crazy to think the concept of counting in a particular direction wouldn't make sense to an alien intelligence? That the way their brain processes inputs means that the knowledge of the total number occurs to them either subconsciously or as the result of parallel processing that is beyond what human brains can even imagine being aware of? Even if the input signals being counted are separated by time (e.g. pulses of light or sound), such that their brains must logically store the previous count and increment it as new signals are detected, the concept of ordered addition (i.e. where we can conceive of "x plus y" and "y plus x" as separate concepts, even if they yield the same result) might simply not be necessary or possible in an alien brain. What even qualifies as "addition" at all is somewhat murky - e.g. "addition" of relativistic velocities is non-commutative (*), but is it meaningfully even addition in the same way adding integer counts is? * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velocity-addition_formula#Properties https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velocity-addition_formula#Prop...