3 ms·
> $99. And only after being able to play with the full/complete development tools and simulator for free. If that's what Visual Studio cost, I'd pay it now. Th
by dpark 15y ago
> $99. And only after being able to play with the full/complete development tools and simulator for free. If that's what Visual Studio cost, I'd pay it now.
The "full" tools isn't a fair comparison. Visual Studio is much more feature-rich than Xcode. Apple does not give away the equivalent of Visual Studio for free.
Maybe Microsoft will add some of the "must-have" features to VS Express in the 2011 edition.
> As an non-MS developer that's just now working with Windows 7 and Visual Studio (C++, and the AVR Studio 5 that's built on top of the VS shell), I can state definitively that the full version is necessary to get any real work done.
At the very least, I need VCS integration, a profiler, and an x86-64 compiler.
From what I've read, it's possible to get Express to do amd64 compilation. There seem to be some gymnastics necessary, though. I'm not sure why it doesn't work out of the box.
As for VCS and a profiler, there are other profilers available, and VCS doesn't have to be integrated. These are not necessary features for the IDE.
Having worked on Unix for several years, I find all this "must-have" stuff bizarre. The tools might be necessary, but the idea that they must be integrated is pretty weak. Having a good IDE is very nice, but a text editor and a bunch of command-line tools can get the job done. (With that said, I definitely missed VS.)
- nupark2 15y ago> Having a good IDE is very nice, but a text editor and a bunch of command-line tools can get the job done. (With that said, I definitely missed VS.) When you're trying to attract developers, "get the job done" doesn't cut it. I'm not a big fan of Xcode and Eclipse, but they meet my functional requirements without hoop-jumping.
- dpark 15y agoWhen you're talking about "necessary" features, "get the job done" very much does cut it. Now, if you want to talk about nice-to-haves and how great it is to have integrated source code management and whatever, that's fine. But "necessary to get any real work done" is a rather large overstatement. Also, I'm surprised you're comparing Eclipse to Visual Studio. I've always found Eclipse unpleasant, to the point that I favor a text editor and the command line. I'd much rather use VS Express than Eclipse.
- rbanffy 15y ago> Visual Studio is much more feature-rich than Xcode. Now I am curious. There are many versions of VS available. Can you compare them with Xcode and point out what's missing?
- dpark 15y agoYou can compare the various Visual Studio versions here: http://www.microsoft.com/visualstudio/en-us/products/2010-editions/product-comparison http://www.microsoft.com/visualstudio/en-us/products/2010-ed... Depending on how far up the hierarchy you want to go, the feature set is huge. Everything from static code analysis to virtual environment management. Versus Xcode, the big thing is that Visual Studio has a very strong extension system. A lot of power is afforded here.
- rbanffy 15y agoFrom what I saw, Xcode would be between professional and premium. I suspect the Unix roots of OSX somewhat reduce the need for IDE extensions. But then I am an Emacs guy who doesn't really use IDEs. My opinions should be taken with a grain of salt.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]