4 ms·
Around a decade ago, when Boston University was trying (successfully) to have its campus be the site of a BSL-4 lab, there were protests (articles, even outdoor
by neilv 4y ago
Around a decade ago, when Boston University was trying (successfully) to have its campus be the site of a BSL-4 lab, there were protests (articles, even outdoor demonstrations) -- over the risks of a lab leak of the world's nastiest pathogens, in an dense urban area.
In that dialogue, the public heard a lot about histories of safety incidents at other BSL-4 labs, which generally seemed due to negligence.
Today, given all the presumed awareness of lab leak risks, from the BU BSL-4 protests, and from the subsequent Covid pandemic-- I don't know why anyone at BU would risk modifying Covid without the utmost precautions, including at least using BSL-4 rather than BSL-3.
- giantg2 4y agoIt seems stupid to have these sites in urban areas. If we want to do this sort of stuff, build the facility in the desert, with little population, little wildlife population, and environmental factors inhospitable to long lifetime if there is escape. But I guess safety measures like that are too inconvenient.
- barbazoo 4y agoMight be difficult to get people to work there.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoEndangering billions of people because virologists prefer to be urbanite yuppies. Research so important that such a risk is accepted, but not so important that it would make sense to simply pay virologists 5x more to live somewhere remote. This is madness.
- rhacker 4y ago
- MichaelCollins 4y agoDune has been on my mind recently. In the universe of Dune, AI research brings humanity to the brink of ruin. After the rebellion against this, a commandment against creating AIs is added to the major religions. Those found guilty of creating or possessing thinking machines should be sentenced to immediate death. The demonstrable peril of such research is severe enough to justify that punishment. If virologists create and lose control of something that kills billions of people, wouldn't that justify an ultimate taboo against that kind of research? Maybe that's why virologists all clam up and circle the wagons when something sketchy happens. They say nobody but other virologists are qualified to question virology, but how can they be trusted to regulate themselves?
- giantg2 4y agoThe funny thing is, there are some virologists/scientists questioning if the lab was involved (just a minority though).
- lukeschlather 4y agoOn the other hand, it's easy to imagine that this sort of research is the only path to permanently curing Coronaviruses (and not just Coronaviruses but also Influenza.) As bad as this pandemic was if it was a required step on the road to permanently curing both Coronaviruses and Influenza... that's a no-brainer, it's well worth the pain, it will save billions of lives. Also if delaying this research delays such a hypothetical Influenza cure by 30 years, that will cost more lives than this pandemic did too.
- notahacker 4y agoI'm reasonably confident that there's a more obvious explanation for virologists tending to back other virologists over homeopaths, politicians and contrarians frantically Googling basic virology knowledge in debates about viral transmission and protein structures than fear of Dune-inspired death sentences for every practitioner of their profession. Sure, and programmers all circle the wagons every time someone suggests that if the company recruits twice as many people to the team it'll get the project done at least twice as quickly. Maybe it's because they're scared of the employment implications of senior management knowing best :D Back in reality, half the evidence presented in favour of the 'lab leak' hypothesis is in fact the long list of actual lab leaks virologists have identified and blamed virologists for...
- JPLeRouzic 4y agoCan't a lot of things automated and operated at distance? After all we can do lab experiences on Mars, why not at 200 miles (300km) ?
- hallway_monitor 4y agoSo pay them a little more - enough that you can ask them to live there for 6 months at a time to reduce risk of pathogen escape as much as possible. If this type of dangerous research is actually valuable enough to keep doing, then it is valuable enough to implement protocols like this.
- buscoquadnary 4y agoIt's really not and is quite common. You keep the site out a ways have workers show up and then bus them out to the site. You only have to keep the site where you are doing the work way out there and so people can do their regular non lab related work closer to home. It's a really common practice. I live near a national nuclear research lab and they do that. I also grew up near an ICBM building and designing facility and when they needed to run tests they drive several hours out to the west desert to do things just to be safe. It's not that uncommon or inconvenient, and makes a hell of a lot more sense then just slapping it in the middle of a major metro area. Seriously we've got tons of land out west that is about a million miles from everything let's use some of that.
- giantg2 4y agoOne difference is the bussing may need to be combined with a quarantine period which wouldn't be necessary with nuclear or chemical research.
- buscoquadnary 4y agoWould it though? I mean, I am assuming there aren't quarantine procedures right now. You'd just have to make sure you have appropriate disinfectant/decontamination guidelines. Heck just require decontamination as you leave the lab and as you get off the bus, two times makes it more safe, and I'd imagine a 40 minute bus ride through the sweltering west desert heat in direct isn't an environment that microorganisms my flourish in. Plus that's easy to do to if there is a quarantine period, out people on shifts of 5-7 days on site, one week off. That's what they do for the oil rigs, plenty of people live like that, it isn't easy, or cheap for the company but a global pandemic that locked down countries shattered supply chains and wreaked havoc with the global economy was a hell of a lot more expensive.
- giantg2 4y ago"Plus that's easy to do to if there is a quarantine period, out people on shifts of 5-7 days on site, one week off." Exactly. "have appropriate disinfectant/decontamination guidelines." Yeah... it seems there have been some issues with people consistently following them. At least with the quarantine you have some defense in depth in case the procedures in the lab failed. (I think a woman in Fance died doing prion research. Why? Because she violated multiple protocols. I want to say she didn't even report it at first, but I could be wrong. And this isnt even a true infectious disease)
- giantg2 4y agoSomehow they make this sort of model work for various classified work in places like NM (although population centers have grown around them due to their size and support requirements). I don't see why something similar can't be done for this. Plenty of Government land in those desert areas out west too.
- godelski 4y agoA significant number of military bases operate like this. Edwards and China Lake are great examples. Los Alamos. Even Fermi. Cities developed around these areas over time, but they once were only military/gov projects.
- kosievdmerwe 4y agoYeah frankly I can't think of a more dangerous thing humanity could be doing than biological research on infectious diseases in population centers. Even doing chemical processing in cities is safer since you're only risking the immediate area.
- jbandela1 4y agoWhen I was in medical school, I heard mentioned that Galveston, TX was chosen for a BSL4 laboratory in part because it was an island, and if something bad happened the US could blow up the bridges and quarantine the island.
- ccrush 4y ago
- scrumbledober 4y agoseems unnecessary to insult the intelligence of an entire state
- stonemetal12 4y agoNo worries about Hurricane induced lab leak?
- baja_blast 4y agoWorse yet, before the pandemic there was more political pressure to regulate and discuss the risks of such research. Now it feels like politicians are afraid to even discuss it. Places like NYT used to occasionally post articles like https://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/04/opinion/sunday/the-truth-about-the-doomsday-virus.html https://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/04/opinion/sunday/the-truth-... and https://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/22/health/h5n1-bird-flu-research-that-stoked-fears-is-published.html https://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/22/health/h5n1-bird-flu-rese... but now you will never seem anything like this published. It is as if the concerns over lab accidents has all but disappeared!
- neilv 4y agoFor one itemization of a lot of the concerns at the time, here's a Massachusetts Nurses Association statement, dated 2005, from their perspective: https://web.archive.org/web/20101125034813/https://www.massnurses.org/nursing-resources/position-statements/bu-lab https://web.archive.org/web/20101125034813/https://www.massn...
- VyseofArcadia 4y ago> I don't know why anyone at BU would risk modifying Covid without the utmost precautions My wife was a laboratory inspector for a while. She'd come home with the craziest stories about how such-and-such lab tried to get away with this or that. I'd have the same question every time. "Why?!" Protocols only work if they're followed. We have such a long history of disasters, major or minor, because of negligence[0]. Cutting corners, operating outside the envelope, etc. She'd always just shrug and say, "familiarity breeds contempt".[1] [0] My favorite is Chernobyl. [1] Also, a lot of scientists have this, "I know what I'm doing" attitude and see safety precautions as holding them back. It doesn't help that most of them see grad students as expendable.
- thrown_22 4y ago>[0] My favorite is Chernobyl. Biology is different to physics or chemistry. The worst nuclear accident can kill a few million people. The worst chemistry accident can kill a few hundreds of thousands of people. The worst biology accident can kill _everyone_.
- klabb3 4y agoI'm not sure I agree on the numbers, I have a hard time seeing a nuclear power accident leading to millions of dead. That said, the sentiment rings true. If we get the right mix of incubation time, reproduction numer and CFR in a novel virus, we are catastrophically and civilization level screwed. It's unbelievable how eg nuclear fission research has ground to a halt whereas GoF research on Covid(!) in a damn BSL-3 lab can be approved after what we just went through.
- VyseofArcadia 4y agoI didn't say it was worse. I said it was my favorite.
- brippalcharrid 4y agoYes, but if we can't attract the world's foremost virologists to programs that we have some degree of control over in the middle of international cities where they can engage in serial passaging of airborne HIV in the morning, and then get lunch at places that are trending, authentic and cutting-edge, then they'll just go to a program in another country that doesn't have these restrictions. No-one wants to live in an underground facility for weeks or months at a time when they could be making the most of living in a major city, not even virologists working on pathogens that are being modified to see what would happen if there was a pathogen whose evolution was guided in a particularly interesting direction and compressed from decades to weeks or even days. Anyway, if we were to ask the world's foremost experts in the virological community whether we should restrict such research to carefully-controlled remote locations subject to stringent controls, long quarantines and strict oversight, then we might find that the answer was similar to when we asked "is if likely or even within the realm of possibility that SARS-CoV-2 originated from a lab in Wuhan as result of Gain-of-Function research". And they might insist that we listen to them because they were the experts, and they would probably find a lot of support in the government and the media.