3 ms·
Everyone in this thread complaining about colorways has got to be a meta-commentary on bikeshedding. This feature isn't for you. But anyway, I'm sad that HTTPS
by Spivak 4y ago
Everyone in this thread complaining about colorways has got to be a meta-commentary on bikeshedding. This feature isn't for you.
But anyway, I'm sad that HTTPS default and isolated cookies are turned on only for Private Browsing (sorry, "Guest Session" from that other silly HN thread, "private" apparently implies you have a rank in the military while using) when both these features aren't super disruptive for general browsing.
- jrootabega 4y agoBut Mozilla deceived us by indicating they had privacy improvements for us! This particular incident is a minor annoyance, but it's an indicator of how those in charge view those of us who care about actual privacy and functionality.
- Spivak 4y agoMozilla really can't win on HN, a feature that basically only exists to save one click (efficiency!) for the kind of people who consume PB regularly is very power user and aligns with their brand as being privacy focused when private mode is the thing that is always visible in the bar. Nobody on HN seems to know at all how to market tech to a general audience and play the game of "staying relevant" so they always have something to post to social/newswires.
- jrootabega 4y agoI, and probably many others, feel that the quality of this as an HN submission is related, but not synonymous with, the quality of it as a Mozilla communication. But it was submitted to HN, and so it will be judged as an HN submission. But many of us also believe that, though it's POSSIBLE Mozilla is acting how you describe ("We are committed to privacy at our core but we have to publish this kind of press release to survive!"), they are actually corrupt at their core to the point where they only see privacy-conscious users as customercattle to be milked. I believe we critics have good enough intuition to see this kind of behavior from Mozilla as a canary indicating their true nature. This is kind of an aftershock of the Mr. Robot incident. I think it's unlikely that that kind of bad judgment was not chronic and systemic.
- soundnote 4y agoBrave and Vivaldi manage to focus on privacy and not write sickening marketing copy. It's a Mozilla problem.
- Karunamon 4y agoHow much do you want to bet the "general audience" does not care one bit about this and will not meaningfully move the (declining) DAU numbers? Mozilla's problems are in its fundamentals, not its marketing.
- Spivak 4y agoMozilla's problem is they have been grasping for an answer to "why should you use Firefox over Chrome?" that actually resonates with people for over a decade. The product is fine, Firefox is a perfectly capable browser. Convincing people to use it is a soft-skills problem because the only reason to use Firefox is because you like Mozilla more than you like Google which is entirely driven by Mozilla having good-feels activism mindshare and getting in being in the news cycle.
- Karunamon 4y ago…Made less and less capable over time. Firefox today is objectively less useful than Firefox many years ago. The continuing decline in user numbers would tell anyone in leadership that is actually paying attention that this approach is not working. And the idea that the answer to attracting normal people is renaming and pushing themes is, to put it mildly, brain-damaged. It is like nobody at that company has ever actually met a computer user before.
- soundnote 4y agoTheir marketing copy is actively repellent to me at least, and judging by friends and comments in this thread, I'm not alone.
- stoplying1 4y agoI think you should re-read the complaints with slightly more empathy for both sides. I love my purple Firefox (apparently via Colorways). Meanwhile, the "Colorways" feature UX and messaging is stupid and confusing. I'm not exaggerating, me and others are quite confused about what it is/isn't and if it's going away. All for freaking what? My mom sees that shit? She's gonna go "uh I don't know what Colorways is, why's it gonna go away, I'll just stick with Edge where it showed me 12 colored icons under the Theme heading and I just clicked one." Because that's exactly what I did until the slight annoyed-curiosity-purple-enthusiast got the better of me. I feel like the scene in Zoolander when the character is befuddled and exasperatedly asks "am I taking crazy pills".
- Spivak 4y ago> All for freaking what? Because they wanted something to talk about social media that was fun and limited time. They were following the Nike playbook with shoe drops including the terminology. Look at the screenshot in the blog post about colorways the art is even a shoe with a basketball. They were trying something new. Limited time cosmetic drops for browsers that get people hyped in every other context. It confused white people because of how they executed it. Live and learn I guess ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. Every non-chrome browser has to answer the question "why use me instead of Chrome" and for Firefox it's the activism. you might not like that but it's what Mozilla's got. At least it's not some crypto nonsense.
- stoplying1 4y agoSo Mozilla is chasing Nike shoe trends to advocate for their browser via colorschemes. I'm not even saying you're wrong, and I guess I'm not even sure that's an absolutely bad idea but Christ if that's "our" play for the future of browsers and privacy, I need to start building that shed ASAP!
- Spivak 4y agoI get you dude, Firefox got popular because IE stagnated and Mozilla capitalized on it, Chrome ate the world because Google made a significant technical improvement at just the right time neither of which can be replicated again so long as Google keeps up their frankly ridiculous development pace. Safari only lives because a popular platform requires it. Mozilla angling for a cultural victory in the browser war is weird but it's the only thing they and every other alternative browser has. I actually thought the colorway thing was fun when it popped up, browser did actually look fresh and new but yeah probably not gonna move the needle.
- llimos 4y ago> "private" apparently implies you have a rank in the military Are you thinking of the "Private Browsing reporting for duty" clip? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G5VEftRH12Y&t=42 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G5VEftRH12Y&t=42
- xg15 4y agoI think what annoys me is that Mozilla (like many other companies) has co-opted the "social movement/political activist" aesthetic without actually engaging in any activism. Private browsing mode is a prime example of that. The current improvement is absolutely miniscule for the amount of bravado they perform around it - but even if you accept it's useful for some, you could ask why private browsing mode exist at all? If that mode had superior privacy protections, why not add those to the normal browsing mode? I think by making tracking the default and having a special mode for when you really need privacy, they are sort of doing the opposite: Normalising that privacy is an exception.
- Spivak 4y ago> The current improvement is absolutely miniscule for the amount of bravado they perform around it. Welcome to marketing. This icon is a more visible change than 1000 closed PRs in the browser internals. It's Twitter fodder, and to get tech journalists to talk about Firefox.
- none_to_remain 4y agoThe main feature I expect from private browsing is that the browser history will not be saved, but in normal browsing I do want it saved
- kevin_thibedeau 4y ago> If that mode had superior privacy protections, why not add those to the normal browsing mode? That would make their master mad. Everything that makes them mad gets taken away.
- sfink 4y ago> not add those to the normal browsing mode? Because it breaks a lot of web sites, and removes functionality that most people want for most of their usage? I want my browser remembering where I've been so it can suggest it to me when I want to get back to it. I especially prefer my browser remembering it rather than some server knowing it, or having to re-do searches which is less convenient and means I'm telling the search server what I'm up to.
- sfink 4y ago> I'm sad that HTTPS default and isolated cookies are turned on only for Private Browsing You might want HTTPS-only mode (bottom section of about:preferences#privacy ). I kind of thought isolated cookies were already the default, as per https://blog.mozilla.org/en/products/firefox/firefox-rolls-out-total-cookie-protection-by-default-to-all-users-worldwide/ https://blog.mozilla.org/en/products/firefox/firefox-rolls-o... but maybe I'm missing a nuance?