4 ms·
I have been using both FreeBSD and Linux for many decades. Until around 2003 to 2005, FreeBSD had much better performance and reliability than Linux. That cha
by adrian_b 4y ago
I have been using both FreeBSD and Linux for many decades.
Until around 2003 to 2005, FreeBSD had much better performance and reliability than Linux.
That changed after Intel introduced Pentium 4 with multiple threads in 2003 and AMD introduced CPUs with multiple cores in 2005. Before that, multiple hardware threads were available only in very expensive computers, which were inaccessible for most people.
Linux was adapted very quickly to work on multi-core or multi-thread CPUs, while FreeBSD required many years for that transition.
At that time, Linux got a great advance in performance over FreeBSD, which was difficult to recover later.
Nowadays, FreeBSD has device driver support for a much less number of devices than Linux, so you must be more careful when choosing hardware for it.
Nevertheless, even if I use Linux in laptops, desktops and computational servers, I have continued to use FreeBSD in networking servers until today.
The main reason is that the administration of a FreeBSD server requires much less time than the administration of a Linux server (which requires much less time than the administration of a Windows server).
With FreeBSD, I may not do anything manually for years, if I have configured it to make certain automatic updates.
With Linux, at least with the distributions that I like for other reasons, I have to always supervise the updates, because the updates frequently break things. (I assume that this might not happen with something like Debian stable, but whenever I have looked to a Linux distribution like that, it was too antiquated for my needs.)
One of the main culprits is always Python, because there are a huge number of packages that insist that they are compatible only with a certain Python version, and they conflict between themselves even when I have all the possible Python versions installed. I could understand that passing from Python 2 to 3 has broken things, but why some packages like Python 3.9 and dislike 3.10 is beyond me. Also the compatibility with various Qt versions frequently causes update problems.
On FreeBSD all the system is more consistent, so I need to spend no more than a couple of hours for a server after several years of 24/7 functioning, when I make some hardware update and when I might replace the major FreeBSD version at the same time.
- capableweb 4y agoI have just about zero experience running any kind of BSD systems, but I just wanted to know a bit more about this: > With Linux, at least with the distributions that I like for other reasons, I have to always supervise the updates, because the updates frequently break things What distributions have you run into these issues with and how often is "frequently" for you? I'm running Arch Linux on my desktop and bunch of servers, for more than five years each one and can count the number of breakages on one hand. On the other hand, I run Ubuntu on my laptop and stopped counting the amount of issues I've had with upgrades. But I'd consider that amount of breakage from my Arch installs very infrequent, but maybe I'm comparing it to the wrong thing, as as I said before, I don't have any experience with BSD systems, maybe breakage there is even more uncommon?
- CoolCold 4y agothe secret sauce here is that "ports collection/packages collection" aka anything useful beyond service NAT gateway/network router is not a system! from the docs: > FreeBSD is bundled with a rich collection of system tools as part of the base system. In addition, FreeBSD provides two complementary technologies for installing third-party software: the FreeBSD Ports Collection, for installing from source, and packages, for installing from pre-built binaries. Thus, when FreeBSD guys say "my system is solid" - means he can use ping/top/csh. But if update breaks say Firefox - it's not part of the system and haha, system is stable!
- anthk 4y agoFreeBSD users with issues will just recompile Firefox from the ports. Also, I am an OpenBSD user (not FreeBSD), and I can say packages are much better maintained than in the 99% of the distros.
- CoolCold 4y agoI was trying to produce good example on differences in reading "stable system" on FreeBSD vs Linux worlds, when definition on what is "system" differs. No anything specific I have to put against Firefox or any other application here.
- adrian_b 4y agoI never use csh, the first step when I install FreeBSD is to install bash. Most of the programs that I use on FreeBSD come from ports, not from the base system (they are various networking applications like squid or samba or nginx), even if I use some functions from the base system, e.g. firewall/NAT/routing, some times the NFS server. Nevertheless, I did not have problems with inconsistencies in the ports collection, and that includes Firefox (which I use some times together with vncserver, so I can use it remotely even if I do not normally install the X11 server on FreeBSD). It is true however that on FreeBSD I have used only seldom programs with GUI interfaces, Firefox being an exception to that, and those are usually among the programs more likely to be broken by updates on Linux systems.