15 ms·
China will invade Taiwan when the cost to do so is low enough and/or they are desperate. In other words, the probability of success is considerably higher tod
by bryanlarsen 4y ago
China will invade Taiwan when the cost to do so is low enough and/or they are desperate. In other words, the probability of success is considerably higher today than it will be in the future (even if the probability of success today isn't great).
Russia is a declining state relative to Ukraine & Europe, so Putin's odds of success in 2022 were considerably higher than they would be 10 years later. So if invading Ukraine was necessary at some point, 2022 was the best time to do it.
China's regime believes that invading Taiwan is necessary, but OTOH the Chinese military is getting stronger very quickly and they believe they'll be in a much better position to invade in a decade then they are now. So there is no way they're going to invade any time soon.
Avoiding a war completely is highly unlikely given Xi & China's policies. But delaying a war is highly likely. And a war indefinitely delayed is a war avoided.
- breckenedge 4y agoTreating political and military leaders as rational entities is dangerous.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoLikewise, treating everyone you disagree with as completely insane; devoid of any reasonable motivations is a lazy hand-wavy viewpoint. It’ll also make you prone to suck up any and all propaganda that aligns with your biases.
- whimsicalism 4y ago> you prone to suck up any and all propaganda that aligns with your biases. A phenomena that is very clear in threads about China.
- des1nderlase 4y agoYup, general public needs to read The Art of War to understand these conflicts at a deeper level.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoXi is one of the most rational actors on the world stage. Machiavellian rational, but rational. I recommend the Economist's podcast series on him.
- Gunnerhead 4y agoFor anyone interested, the podcast is “The Prince” by The Economist.
- consumer451 4y agoI would mostly agree, but is "saving face"[0] considered rational behavior? How big a factor is that in this thread's context? Honest questions here. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Face_(sociological_concept)#Chinese https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Face_(sociological_concept)#Ch...
- MockObject 4y agoIt's quite rational because of the crucial importance of reputation internationally, and the image of competence domestically.
- Slartie 4y agoIf by "internationally" you mean Western countries: Xi Jinping doing dumb things to save his "face" is very detrimental to his reputation there. No one outside of China thinks his stubborn refusal to abandon the failed Zero Covid policy is in any way a good idea. Everyone sees it as a stupid and irrational face-saving action.
- glitchc 4y agoXi is not rational. His isolationist policies and "return to Mao-style communism" have killed China's economy. The current zero-COVID policy is the icing on the cake: It runs completely counter to scientific thought and is impossible to achieve for 1.2 billion people. He's painted himself into a corner and is unwilling to budge (how can the Premier be wrong?), and is doing tremendous damage to China in the process.
- tanseydavid 4y ago>> Treating political and military leaders as rational entities is dangerous. I would think the opposite to be true. How do you attempt to apply to game theory to a situation where the other party is completely irrational? It seems impossible to me.
- throwawaylinux 4y ago> And a war indefinitely delayed is a war avoided. You spend the rest of the comment before this talking about how war will happen when they are stronger and probably can't be avoided, so I don't know how this last sentence follows. If you know for sure that someone will wage war on you in future, and that they will get stronger faster than you will, then it could be in your interest to go to war against them sooner rather than later.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoXi's China will wage war. It won't always be Xi's China.
- throwawaylinux 4y agoSo you've reversed your position about the inevitability of war with China then?
- cryptonector 4y agoCheck for fifth columns. They'll probably prefer to have those than to try w/o them.