2 ms·
The narrative here seems to be a David and Goliath story as Microsoft profits by stomping on the defenseless open-source communities. There's two problems with
by nfw2 4y ago
The narrative here seems to be a David and Goliath story as Microsoft profits by stomping on the defenseless open-source communities. There's two problems with this story.
First, the huge majority of open-source projects are at no real risk because Copilot offers something totally different from what they offer. Open-source projects generally take highly-complex domains and expose them as simple interfaces or executable programs. This encapsulation is where the value lies.
In contrast, Copilot just dumps code. Never once doing front-end work have I thought "if only there was a way to dump verbatim React internals directly into my codebase." In general, Copilot only replaces tasks I would have otherwise done myself.
The second problem is the biggest loser if Copilot gets shut down is not Microsoft, who can easily take the loss in stride. The real loser is the community of developers, many of them bootstrapping their own projects or trying to develop open-source in their precious off-hours, for whom every minute counts, and for whom tools like Copilot can be the difference between success and failure.