3 ms·
I'm not convinced of what you wrote. Is it actually true that cases like that are dismissed? Or is it that the infringing party is ordered to stop, but not dama
by kelnos 4y ago
I'm not convinced of what you wrote. Is it actually true that cases like that are dismissed? Or is it that the infringing party is ordered to stop, but not damages are awarded to the rightsholder? You've offered no examples of dismissal to back up your statement.
I absolutely agree with you that copyright is not a boolean, but I don't buy the idea that a judge will just shrug and allow infringement to continue just because there was no commercial harm.
I also think your example is just irrelevant to the case at hand. Sure, someone "performing" someone else's copyrighted words once may not be a big thing. But if Copilot is actually found to be infringing, these infringements will keep happening, over and over and over.
Bottom line is that none of this has been tested in court. I think it's great that someone is working on doing just that. Maybe the end result will be that Microsoft's use is indeed fair use, and that Copilot users have no further obligations. But I'd like to hear a court decide that, not a bunch of armchair non-lawyers (myself included) on a random web forum.
- abigail95 4y agoLouisiana Contractors Licensing Serv., Inc. v. Am. Contractors Exam Servs., Inc., 13 F. Supp. 3d 547, 554 (sorry i wrecked the citation and lost where i found it)
- jfk13 4y agoNot necessarily where you found it, but sounds like https://willamette.edu/law/resources/journals/wlo/ip/2014/04/louisiana-contractors-licensing-service,-inc.-v.-american-contractors-exam-services,-inc.-.html https://willamette.edu/law/resources/journals/wlo/ip/2014/04...
- kelnos 4y agoThis is pretty interesting, and IMO, really disappointing to see that was the ruling in that case.
- shagie 4y agohttps://www.lexisnexis.com/community/casebrief/p/casebrief-newton-v-diamond https://www.lexisnexis.com/community/casebrief/p/casebrief-n... > CONCLUSION: > The court of appeals affirmed the district court's judgment. The court held that the Performers' use of the composition, as distinct from the use of the composer's performance, was de minimis and therefore not actionable. Considering only the compositional elements, the brief and relatively simple segment of the composition used by the Performers was neither quantitatively nor qualitatively significant when viewed in relation to the composition as a whole. Thus, despite the high degree of similarity from the actual use of the recorded composition, the scope of the similarity was not sufficiently substantial to support Newton's infringement claim.
- kelnos 4y agoOk, sure, but that's not what I was asking for. I'm not surprised that there is one (or even two or three or a handful) of examples where this happened. But is it common? Also I'm looking for a case where the judge acknowledged that copyright infringement was occurring, but decided not to do anything about it. From the bit you quoted, it sounds to me like it's implying that the judge believed there was a valid fair-use defense? Or even stronger, that the judge just did not believe the use was infringing at all?