7 ms·
I wonder how they'd react if I started bitching about having to have a car to participate in society.
by hinkley 4y ago
I wonder how they'd react if I started bitching about having to have a car to participate in society.
- AndrewUnmuted 4y ago
- kgermino 4y agoI’d posit it’s quickly getting easier to live without a car than without a smartphone in the US. Plus, even if you live in an area where a car is required you have the option to opt out and move (housing crisis aside), which isn’t an option to avoid smartphone requirements.
- chrsig 4y agowell, you could always move somewhere very rural with poor cellphone reception.
- hinkley 4y agoThe people complaining about smart phones and the people who created the car-obsessed society are substantially the same people.
- cafard 4y agoThere must be few people still alive who created the car-obsessed society.
- hinkley 4y agoI don’t think I could argue with the assertion that it was created for them and not by them, but there are plenty of Boomers around. The Ford Mustang was introduced 18 years after the end of World War 2.
- alephxyz 4y agoIf you think it's only boomers who like car-centric infrastructure, I have bad news for you.
- Spivak 4y agoYeah, this sentiment covers for sure all of Gen X and Elder Millennials. If the back half of Millennials all turn 30 and it’s the same story we can pretty confidently say that it’s not really a generational thing. I would love to ditch my car but it’s impossible in my city and I have no power to change it. I could move I guess but choosing lack of car over my friends and family feels a bit drastic.
- hinkley 4y agoThat doesn’t cover all of GenX. But yes, getting old sucks and walking takes some discipline.
- throwaway4aday 4y ago> walking takes some discipline and it also requires you to fully buy in to the city-centric lifestyle. Whether you like it or not there will always be a lot of people that don't want to live in an urban center or even a small town. For them, personal transportation is non-negotiable. Even people who live within walkable towns or cities will often prefer to have a car so that they can access other locations and services whenever they feel like it without having to rent or limit themselves to places accessible by mass transit. Cars just aren't going away, nor should we wish them to. I'm all for building more walkable and human scale environments, I enjoy them as much as the next person but I also want those places connected by good roads so that I can access, or leave, any of them freely.
- Guthur 4y agoAnd then someone before, the bicycle, and horse and mule, wait i don't think you're point is coherent.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ls15 4y agoSome of the most bicycle-obsessed people that I know are clearly boomers
- LtWorf 4y agoDo you have a source on this made up factoid that just shows you are prone to age discrimination?
- hinkley 4y ago1960's and early 70's car culture (prior to the oil shock), the early 80's identity crisis as (automotive) manufacturing moved overseas.
- Tangurena2 4y agoThe people who created the car-obsessed society died long ago. These people would be my parents' & grand-parents' generations. I'm in my 60s. And before you ask, I hate having to have a smartphone. It is required to VPN into work, or to do so many things. I changed grocery stores rather than let them use my cellphone for the "loyalty" card. I also hate living in a state where public transit is useless. TL;DR - something about "get off my lawn" and "old man yells at cloud".
- JohnClark1337 4y ago
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoIt may sound odd, but you are not bolstering your argument here. The parent is arguing for a way to ensure that participation in society is not bound by one's ability arrange for unrelated physical objects other than cash and ID to participate. And that is before we even get to how much having a car and cell phone governs one's life in US. Not everyone believes it is a good societal structure. Note that I am not arguing one way or another, but outright dismissal is not an appropriate counter argument.
- hinkley 4y agoOh I'm not saying either is good. I'm saying that the shoe is on the other foot now.
- Spivak 4y agoYeah, the minimum you need to participate in US society is SSN, driver’s license number, working cell phone number, credit/debit card, health insurance, car, car insurance, proof of citizenship, permanent address, internet connection and W2 or equivalent. I’ve needed all of these sans the car to interact with just government services in my state.
- fabianhjr 4y agoPublic Transit (from local buses to inter-city trains) should be high quality and frequent. That is reality in a lot of the world including Europe, China, and South America. I agree with the sentiment of not generally needing to have a car and fortunately that is the case in most of the world (except the USA)
- andrepd 4y agoIn part of Europe, China, and South America.
- bombcar 4y agoMore and more public transit is requiring a smartphone or an elaborate and complicated setup with contact cards. It’s getting annoying.
- midasuni 4y agoTouch a piece of plastic when you start, toich again when you end. It’s not exactly complicated. You can buy the plastic for cash, or use the one almost everyone has in their wallet, or use a phone.
- midoridensha 4y agoIt's really not at all. In Japan, you just buy a debit card and swipe that every time you enter or exit a station. When it gets low, you stop at a vending machine and put more cash on it. It doesn't get any simpler, and it's totally anonymous.
- fomine3 4y agoYou underestimate how difficult to buy a correct ticket
- eru 4y agoPublic Transit isn't the (only) alternative to cars. Compact layouts that enable walking or biking are another alternative.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- milsorgen 4y agoI've made it to my late 30s only owning a car for maybe 2 or 3 of those years. I've never felt the desire, my mom always commented it was odd back when I was a teenager... But I digress, it is very possible and it's easier than ever. I grew up on the rural west coast, moved inland to an agricultural area. Never living in a proper city by most metrics. Certainly I've missed some opportunities along the way, c'est la vie, but it is easier than ever and I'm meeting more and more people like me as time goes on. I also don't have a photo ID as a general rule, but that's a whole different can of worms and in some cases much more limiting than living car free. Most people seem to create their own hurdles or embiggen real ones that they do face, certainly I do in my own ways so don't take that as a judgement just an observation. Choosing to go carless is not half the hurdle many people perceive it to be.
- Rediscover 4y ago> I've made it to my late 30s only owning a car for maybe 2 or 3 of those years. Similar. I spent part of my teen years in a children's home in the U.S. -- it turns out that even though the state may go in for a [driving] learning permit (pre-req for a driving license), it won't sign off for the license to drive. So I never got a license until older and dropped it later. I'm definitely healthier for all the walking I still do :)
- dfg4456ds7 4y agoHopefully they'll react as if you were an irrational pedant, because I have been participating in society without a car my entire adult life just fine.
- krolden 4y agoVery few of these people drive.
- Paraesthetic 4y agoYou can walk, you can't verbally authenticate
- DoreenMichele 4y agoSometimes you can. Especially in small towns where people know each other. That used to kinda be the norm.
- Manu40 4y agoI have a personal rule. If I can't walk there within an hour, or the bus itself takes more than an hour to get there; I won't even apply to the job. My method of thinking on this is that people with their own vehicle won't go much further than an hour away anyways, so why would I with a bike, my own two feet; or transit for that matter. It's not like the people they are hiring with vehicles are going to get there much faster if they own a vehicle taking the same amount of time. The only time this won't be true is if they live so close they really should be walking instead to save money.
- Manu40 4y agoTell that to some of my past prospective employers. It's getting so bad, that some insist on being able to drive to work even if you live within 15 minutes walking distance. "But what about bad weather?" They ask. "I'll dress appropriately." I reply. 3 days later: Phone rings. "We're sorry, but we decided to go with someone better suited for the job." The job... was at a restaurant, as a cook. Cooks... don't need to be able to drive to work... usually. (There are maybe some jobs where driving would be ideal, or necessary, but let's be real here. Most don't need to be able to drive.)
- supertrope 4y agoI’m guessing “the bus was late” is a common excuse used by those who are frequently late to work. The issue here is that they mindlessly apply a filter of if you drive to work you pass if you don’t you fail. Employees with attendance issues can still use plenty of dumb excuses. A car itself provides several: car broke down, traffic was bad, snowy roads. Those issues don’t apply to someone who can walk in. Unfortunately not being a driver is not a protected class in the US.
- pvaldes 4y agoA better comparison would be the government refusing to talk with you unless you can prove that own a car from one specific brand that they like.
- midasuni 4y agoI know plenty of people without a car and some without a driving license. Far more than those without a smartphone.
- crooked-v 4y agoThey'd probably agree with you. Having to pay to maintain a car (probably an awful one that has lots of problems) just to get anything done is distinctly bad part of being poor in America.