4 ms·
The fundamental problem with this regressive "discrimination" framework is that it divides people into a dichotomy of "having agency" and "having no agency", an
by mindslight 4y ago
The fundamental problem with this regressive "discrimination" framework is that it divides people into a dichotomy of "having agency" and "having no agency", and then focuses the analysis on those with no agency while ignoring the concerns of those with agency. Essentially it asks the wrong question, stands in for real discussion about societal problems from such things, and allows real issues to be handwaved away as those with agency just needing to choose to "get with the program".
I am 100% dead set against "cashless society", not because I am "unable" to use anything else, but because it is less private, less empowering, and outright less convenient. Sure, I'll sometimes give in to the financial surveillance industry to get money back, or to make returns easier, or to do online purchases, or to avoid trading fomites during Covid. But ideally I want to transact in cash. Make the decision to spend a given amount of money exactly once, and not suffer the same transaction multiple times as I see my agglomerated statements at the end of the month.
With friends, no fucking Paypal, Venmo, Zelle, or whatever fly by night crap is popular this week that undoubtably forces some nonconsentual "terms" at me. Never mind creating yet another insecure account that has to be checked every month lest I end up responsible for a company's negligence. Cash - we settle and then we forget about it. Sometimes it's higher, sometimes it's lower, most of the time it evens out, sometimes it doesn't but we assume it does and move on with our lives.
Like maaaaaybe in the far future if phones are ever personal computing devices that represent individuals, and we have the security properties granted by systems like Monero, and software designed for end users and not surveillance companies, then I'd be happy to settle with digital money. But it's foolish to jump the gun and pretend that any of the junk currently being pushed by surveillance companies represents that sort of idyllic future in any way.
- asdff 4y agoI think another big problem with digital versus paper money is that you can't just transmute money from cash to cashless without you having an institution involved along the way. I can't take a picture of a dollar bill and add it to my venmo account, unless I go buy a venmo gift card from a merchant, or I open an account with a bank and deposit the cash through their physical bank branch or an ATM network they've partnered with. Even with crypto, you are relying on some other institution like the echange or the bitcoin ATM or whatever to turn that dollar bill into a digital currency.
- mindslight 4y agoWell any conversion between different stores of value intrinsically requires a counterparty. Counterparties will tend towards centralization out of convenience - it's not like you're going to stand up in a bar and announce "Does anybody want to trade X for Y?" when you're trying to settle up with a friend. If your sets of preferred payment methods are incompatible, most likely you'll just split the bill and let the venue sort it out on the back end.