4 ms·
A lot of the arguments seem kind of bad. Just in the first paragraph: "Blockchain is the greatest technological fraud" - It's just a hashed data structure. May
by tim333 4y ago
A lot of the arguments seem kind of bad. Just in the first paragraph:
"Blockchain is the greatest technological fraud" - It's just a hashed data structure. Maybe people use it for fraud but that's like saying accounts are a fraud because someone had bad ones once.
"[Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies] are functionally useless as currencies outside the realms of criminal activity and a Ponzi scheme in effect if not name for everyone else." - they are used a fair bit in speculation which is not actually illegal. With bitcoin there is no ponzi schemer, the thing doesn't collapse ponzi like - it just goes up and down.
Not to say they don't have flaws but there is interesting stuff too.
- only_human 4y agoNo, that paragraph is correct. You may be either missing some context or using a different definition of blockchain that doesn't apply to crypto and web3. All the selling points that crypto people have said about blockchains are completely false. It is just a hashed data structure but that's the point -- how is a hashed data structure going to solve inequality, minimize global energy usage, stop wars and feed the hungry? Of course it can't, but you can still see plenty of those outrageous claims floating around on crypto twitter from people who should know better. As far as hashed data structures go, it's not even a good one. It's universally bad at everything for a number of reasons. This is a database system intentionally designed so that writing to the database becomes increasingly and artificially expensive and/or wasteful, for no actual benefit. There's nothing interesting about them. There doesn't need to be a single person collecting the dollars for it to be a ponzi-esque scheme. The reason people call it a ponzi is because there is no actual profit anywhere in the system nor is there any reasonable mechanism for any typical investors to get stable profits. It's all speculation. The only way you can make a profit from "investing" in crypto is by selling to someone else at a higher price. Yes, ponzi schemes can continue indefinitely if people keep dumping money into it and nobody shuts them down.
- tim333 4y agoGold bars sitting there also don't produce anything and investors rely on other investors buying for a profit. Does that mean gold is also a Ponzi scheme?
- only_human 4y agoNo, gold actually has a real demand derived from legitimate commercial uses. If it didn't, and the only reason you were buying it was to try and dump it off on other investors for a profit, then it would have the properties of a Ponzi. Make sense? It isn't exactly the same as Charles Ponzi's scheme, but it is similar enough that the layperson understands what it means when you say Ponzi. There isn't any actual profit in the system, all the "profit" comes from other investors.