3 ms·
I think it depends on if you are a designer or an artist. In my mind a designer works on a specification for a client and produces it, they are interchangeable,
by kjkjadksj 4y ago
I think it depends on if you are a designer or an artist. In my mind a designer works on a specification for a client and produces it, they are interchangeable, they dont put their signatures on the work because its not theirs, its the clients.
Artists however wont have to worry about ai. Ai music already exists but people still support mainly real artists on streaming platforms and go to concerts, because provenance matters for artists and it doesn't for designers. Could an ai make a warhol? Probably not because what made warhols art popular was that he essentially worked outside of the training set and provided something previously unseen. Machine learning is bound to the training set. You can make generic corporate bathroom art for hotels or filling empty picture frames with it, but there will still be real artists and galleries and concerts and museums, because often times people value the provenance of the artist much more than even the work itself.
- jefftk 4y ago> Ai music already exists but people still support mainly real artists on streaming platforms and go to concerts, because provenance matters for artists I don't think that's what's going on. The top pop singers are generally already singing things written by other people against accompaniment written by other people. I think by far the biggest reason few people are listening to AI music is it's just not as good as human music yet?
- kjkjadksj 4y agoThats true, but people are still listening for the artist and not the talent team. Drake is famous for having his writers live in tents in the studio. I bet songwriters desperate enough for work to live in a tent probably are cheaper than making a contract with whoever is trying to sell this stuff to major record labels.
- jononor 4y agoSo if the talent team becomes partly AI-based, no change on public perception. They still listen to "the artist".
- kjkjadksj 4y agoThat would depend on if its cheaper to have an AI team or a real team. For example mcdonalds had all the tech to replace burger flippers by the 1980s if not earlier. Just retool a robot that builds Fords to hold a spatula. The reason they still hire people is because its cheaper than what the maintenance contract on such a robot costs.
- pmoriarty 4y ago"Ai music already exists but people still support mainly real artists on streaming platforms and go to concerts, because provenance matters for artists" I don't listen to my favorite music because of who made it but because I like it. If music that I like started bring made by AI then it's listen to it without hesitation. In fact a lot of music bring made today is already a collaboration between humans and machines and had been so for a long time.
- Firmwarrior 4y agoThat's a good point Just like how "Calculator" used to be a job title for humans who manually performed calculations.