4 ms·
Rob Walling's "Start Small, Stay Small" is pretty good too, and has less gratuitous profanity.
by davidw 15y ago
Rob Walling's "Start Small, Stay Small" is pretty good too, and has less gratuitous profanity.
- mst 15y agoI think I'd argue that the profanity is for effect/emphasis, and to mark the post out as a rant - it's clearly (to me) being used intentionally as a writing technique. Which suggests 'gratuitous' is a harsher adjective than strictly requires, and may simply reflect that you aren't fond of profanity's use at all. I think either dropping the word entirely from your comment or perhaps replacing it with 'prolific', which would not only have been non-judegemental while still conveying the key point, but additionally alliterates nicely too. Or maybe I'm just overthinking this :)
- davidw 15y ago"Gratuitous" is a judgment: profanity loses its shock value if you lace everything you say/write with it. I don't know if the rest of her writing is like that (my recollection is that it isn't), but this piece was too heavy on it. A well placed "fuck" can add a lot, if used judiciously, but it's the kind of thing where you only sit up and take notice of it due to its absence elsewhere.