3 ms·
Just over 57% of US households are already paying zero or negative federal income tax. This scheme amounts to a giveaway of an extra sum to them, rather than an
by sokoloff 4y ago
Just over 57% of US households are already paying zero or negative federal income tax. This scheme amounts to a giveaway of an extra sum to them, rather than an increase in taxes to them (except for the tiny sliver who are between $0 and -$52 per adult per year in federal income taxes).
- hackeraccount 4y agoTrue... up to a point. I'm not a fan of the parent so this isn't a defense of the idea but saying "income taxes" is a bit of a cheat. Taxes are taxes. So, what percent of of households pay taxes? If you look at not just income but sales taxes, sin taxes,payroll taxes and pass-through taxes I'd bet the answer is 100% or close to it. And it's probably more then $1 a week. That said, the idea of adding an optional poll tax lottery seems dopey.
- kibwen 4y agoDopey or not, the question I'm attempting to raise is whether it has desirable properties compared to our current state-run lotteries. In a just world, perhaps this wouldn't be necessary. But I don't know how to make the world a just one, sadly.
- aamoscodes 4y agoCorrect, most of the US does not make enough money to need to pay taxes. This proposal would actually decrease that number, because receiving $300k in one year (if we tax it as income) means you will need to contribute taxes that year...maybe they can even use part of their net earnings to contribute $60 to the fund, so someone else will have enough money to pay taxes the following year.
- sokoloff 4y agoOne positive aspect of this is that, assuming we taxed these payments as income, it would reduce the deficit by around $2.5B/yr, or around 0.1% of the deficit.
- aamoscodes 4y agoPayroll tax currently caps at $147k, if we remove that limit it would reduce that deficit even further. This theoretical giveaway policy is a drop in the bucket compared to many other tax policies that exist right now.
- colinmhayes 4y agoCould make it a payroll tax which everyone with a job pays.