3 ms·
The Big Idea: Do governments really control their economies?
- incomingpain 4y agoYes and no. When Trump or Biden claim success at the economy doing well. It has little to nothing to do with them. It has everything to do with the collected efforts of everyone in the country. They don't control anything, at best they have the ability to make temporary changes that will always rebalance. Bob the french fry line manager contributed his efforts toward the economy far more than anything trump or biden did. Generally speaking the actions taken by them will be a net-loss to the economy. So for example the current crisis and collapse, politicians made stupid decisions to lockdown and shut off the economy. Which means less far taxes and then other politicians decided to print money, mostly digitally, to fake the GDP staying strong. In turn causing inflation that was completely out of their control. To get it under control they raised rates so high that will now recripple the economy. 100% of the problems derive from politicians screwing up. the funny thing about politics and economics, the people who understand economics can NEVER win the election. Better yet, the system is designed around expecting politicians to make stupid decisions. So you can actually bet against the politicians. Which from my experience and knowledge is a 100% win every time.
- h2odragon 4y agoControl? no. Influence, yes. The economy is like a cart horse. Government is sitting on the wagon, holding the reins. Often that's enough to steer the general direction; but can't control where each hoof falls. That's fine 'cuz those who aren't being stepped on don't care about those details, and everybody on the wagon just appreciates the motion without concern over the destination. Now we've got a situation where the governments are tugging on the reins for the first time in a while and they're not getting the reaction they expect. They're ignoring the fact that the horse has been gingered up for the last decade with regular peeled root injections of fresh money. The roller skates of monopoly and over-regulation have grown into a rocket sled. For someone riding on the cart; the experience is a hollow, falling sensation and a bewildering cloud of horse shit blocking the view ahead.