3 ms·
Functional money is built around trust and consensus. A critical weakness of crypto is that the actors involved are *less* trustworthy than government. And th
by jqpabc123 4y ago
Functional money is built around trust and consensus.
A critical weakness of crypto is that the actors involved are *less* trustworthy than government.
And this lack of trust and transparency and oversight; combined with the fact that anyone and his brother can mint their own crypto, makes a general consensus on the value of crypto unlikely.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThe lack of trust means that the only thing left to guarantee (to a normal person) that the system is working is transparency.
- jqpabc123 4y agotransparency Has anyone seen the financial records for Tether?
- bavell 4y agoI'm pro-crytpo but Tether is a scam imo.
- jqpabc123 4y agoAs Tether goes, so goes the entire crypto eco-system. Tether underwrites the entire crypto marketplace. It is involved in more than half of all crypto trades. And it's unlimited supply is totally controlled by crypto market makers with every incentive to use it to manipulate the crypto market. It's like giving NASDAQ and the NYSE control over the Federal Reserve. No possible conflict of interest there, right? https://www.theverge.com/22620464/tether-backing-cryptocurrency-stablecoin https://www.theverge.com/22620464/tether-backing-cryptocurre...
- saurik 4y agoTether is a centralized bank that happens to use a blockchain as a backend. When people say "crypto is transparent" that doesn't mean you can't build things that are not transparent that use crypto. Similarly, one can benefit from a fully-open laptop (with open firmware running Linux or whatever) even if it allows people to still develop closed source software that runs on it, and even if some of that software is merely a front for software that runs on it is just a client for some remote server whose behavior cannot be modeled... because on the locked down device (imagine an iPhone) you can never develop something whose behavior is transparent as you can never discount what the platform is letting the developer hide from you.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoTether is basically a bank with none of the regulations, not actually a blockchain. All transactions done in USDT are public, but the backing money isn't. But trust me, it's all there, and it's totally not in speculative Chinese bonds.
- imdsm 4y ago> A critical weakness of crypto is that the actors involved are less trustworthy than government. If anything, "crypto" is based on the idea that people can't be trusted, and is thus a trustless system, based on an agreed upon protocol with cryptographic controls. It isn't meant as an improvement to an existing system, but as an alternative system, and while we often hear of people who say it is a scam, that it won't work, that it can't work, the unbiased reality is that it is being used for value transactions and has been non-stop for over a decade now. The phrase "a general consensus on the value of crypto" is equal to "a general consensus on the value of money". Crypto (as in cryptocurrencies, cryptoassets, and, in general, blockchain based digital ledgers) is a vast subject. Nothing stops someone from creating their own paper currency or non-blockchain digital currency (Nectar points, air miles). There are for sure questions to be asked here about how unregulated, crowd managed currencies can be integrated into existing societies were money is heavily regulated, but that is another subject.
- AlexandrB 4y ago> If anything, "crypto" is based on the idea that people can't be trusted, and is thus a trustless system, based on an agreed upon protocol with cryptographic controls. Those controls only address problems created by the distributed nature of crypto (double spend), but don't touch the most common types of financial fraud which is why wash trading and rug pulls are so common. Crypto effectively assumes that people can't be trusted to exchange currency fairly, but can (and indeed must) be trusted to do everything else (pricing, disclosure, governance, etc.) fairly.
- imdsm 4y agoThey address more than just double spend attacks, but also ownership and control. Without a private key, in a protocol where every transaction must be signed, no changes can be made to a ledger where balances are associated with corresponding public keys. The human issues that we have from use of the system, fraud, P&D schemes, non-custodial wallets (exchanges) etc, aren't fundamental issues with the technology itself, but with the periphery. Cash can be used to buy drugs, bank accounts can be used for money laundering, financial markets can be manipulated. We must be cognisant of the fact that where there are people, there will be misuse. Crypto is no different. > Crypto effectively assumes that people can't be trusted to exchange currency fairly, but can (and indeed must) be trusted to do everything else (pricing, disclosure, governance, etc.) fairly. Must we assume that pricing is to be trusted? What pricing is this, exchange pricing? If you're using centralised exchanges then the issue is whether you trust the centralised exchange to keep an honest order book, and whether you're able to determine whether the exchange rate reflects the value of the token/asset. Many people have recently begun trading on financial markets, see Gamestop, wallstreetbets etc, without the proper knowledge required to ensure they're making the right decisions. This is no different from buying BTC because your neighbour told you it'll hit $100k by Christmas. These are societal problems from people who want to get rich quick and almost always get hurt trying.