15 ms·
A platform that bans left-wing speech is not a free speech one. Simple as that. Yes I know some work hard in redefining "free speech" to measure "ability of rig
by watwut 4y ago
A platform that bans left-wing speech is not a free speech one. Simple as that. Yes I know some work hard in redefining "free speech" to measure "ability of right wing extremists being unopposed". That does not make it reasonable for HN.
- Veen 4y agoFree speech is the right for everyone to express themselves, including right-wing and left wing extremists. It interesting to see how many of the "privately-owned platforms can do as they please" people suddenly change their mind when the shoe is on the other foot.
- d_e_solomon 4y agoFree speech is the right for penis pill sellers to post incessantly.
- dementiapatent 4y agoYou can find a happy middle ground between unrestricted free speech (of real people) and banning spammers and people who run alt accounts. Making the system invite-only may be a requirement.
- iinnPP 4y agoI would argue the simplest answer is transparent moderation. If needed, split a team of moderators by political association and have each moderator handle the users of the "opposite" side. Otherwise you end up getting shadow banned for reporting an actual call to violence which then took place.
- bediger4000 4y agoEvidence and experience say this isn't true. No platform has ever hit this balance.
- bradreaves2 4y ago"Privately-owned platforms [that] do as they please" but call themselves “free speech” are dishonest. This isn’t partisan hypocrisy — it’s applying an objective standard to a bad-faith argument.
- watwut 4y agoYour comment is completely irrelevant to what I wrote. I did not said it should be illegal to create right wing discussion forum. I said that it is not free speech platform.
- refurb 4y agoWhen they got banned from Twitter and Facebook, everyone said “just start your own platform”. So they did. You should be happy?
- watwut 4y agoMy complaint is about calling it free speech platform. That is a lie right there in the title. Had the title was "Kanye West to acquire right wing platform Parler" I would be fine with the title.
- cloutchaser 4y agoTechnically you are not wrong, but all platforms including Twitter, Facebook, etc basically say "We believe in free speech, but..." It's really just about choosing who moderates your content. 0 moderation is not possible, so if you don't like Twitter, you can use Parler, and if you don't like Reddit, you can use Retalk, etc etc
- TrickardRixx 4y agoNot once have I seen a "Musk to acquire free speech platform Twitter" headline. I wonder why Parler gets that distinction, but other platforms don't.
- hairofadog 4y agoBecause, while in fact neither is a "free-speech" platform, Parler brands itself as one while Twitter does not, and the person who posted this article has an axe to grind (adding "free speech" to the title when it isn't in the headline of the article).
- watwut 4y agoI have never seen the title to say "Free speech platform twitter" or "Free speech platform Facebook". Moreover, this title was not written by Parler. The free speech platform is editorializing by submitter.