3 ms·
I'm not seeing this as a compelling narrative basically. Its disconnected statements each of which are contestable. The point about the ERA seems to be in a dif
by ggm 4y ago
I'm not seeing this as a compelling narrative basically. Its disconnected statements each of which are contestable. The point about the ERA seems to be in a different spectrum. Are you seriously proposing that it should be rolled back, and thats an always-been-true article of faith in right wing politics, or is this the "states should decide" thing, and so America becomes a federation of distinct islands of choice in this matter (choice, maybe the wrong word. somebody in the state decided)
The ERA story is quite complicated. I think you're eliding over some history here. Opposition was tactical, not foundational for Democrat women, the principle of equality was a given. It was backed heavily by Republican women before the 70s as I understand it, the modern states-rights/constitution thing is really just that: a modern hot take on something.
Basically, I can't see how these things actually address the topic.
I'm not an American, so I don't have direct affiliation with D or R.
- pyuser583 4y agoWe both seem confused! > Can you give some each side examples? I am obviously partisan, I want to understand what things done by "my side" are seen as having equivalence to ones done by the other side. > Gerrymander might be an example. I'm pretty sure both major parties exploit it shamelessly. You talk about “both major parties” and imply they both gerrymandering - but then you say you’re not American. Which country are you from that has two major parties and systematic gerrymandering, but isn’t America? I don’t think anyone can give you examples about “your side” without knowing your country and political affiliation.
- ggm 4y agomy side is the left side. I am talking as a non-american about american politics and so I identify with american left politics which means the democrats. The entire article is written about US domestic politics. I am discussing US politics from an outside point of view. My understanding is that both major parties exploit gerrymandering, is an example of a posed equality of abuse of law. The shitlist above appears both to be not about illegality and failure to respect law, and, not really cohesive as a narrative of equality or difference between R and D.