5 ms·
Why are scientists filing lawsuits against their critics? (2017)
- Ballas 4y agoFor those interested, here is the outcome of the case: https://retractionwatch.com/2020/07/09/stanford-prof-ordered-to-pay-legal-fees-after-dropping-10-million-defamation-case-against-another-scientist/ https://retractionwatch.com/2020/07/09/stanford-prof-ordered... TLDR: He dropped the case and said he expected them to settle. They were awarded costs in an anti-SLAPP suit.
- DennisP 4y agoDespite all that, Jacobson's work gets uncritical acclaim in the popular press to this day, even as other scientists keep pointing out problems with it.
- danuker 4y ago
- eru 4y agoThey aren't.
- witrak 4y agoReally? What country do you live in?
- michaelt 4y agoThe media are often a mouthpiece for the highest bidder when we're talking about their billionaire owners, and multinationals spending a lot on advertising, and industry press wanting access to exclusive previews, and industries handing out freebies like 'review samples' and flying people to product launches in exotic locations. However, academic climate scientists are none of these. More likely journalists see "stanford climate scientist" saying something that seems right to them, and they don't look much further than that.
- eru 4y agoSee eg https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/09/18/too-much-dark-money-in-almonds/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/09/18/too-much-dark-money-in...
- dahdum 4y agoLast I can find is that Stanford has been ordered to cover ~$70k of Jacobson’s legal fees by the CA Labor Commissioner. If that holds I wonder if we can expect more spurious lawsuits from CA professors, knowing their employer will be forced to backstop them. https://retractionwatch.com/2022/09/12/stanford-prof-appeals-order-to-pay-428k-in-legal-fees-after-dropping-defamation-suit/ https://retractionwatch.com/2022/09/12/stanford-prof-appeals...
- gadders 4y ago
- Schroedingersat 4y agoAh yes, all that totally legitimate criticism that wasn't bald faced lies by fossil fuel shills of research that turned out to he entirely wrong https://www.nature.com/articles/4411032a https://www.nature.com/articles/4411032a
- Slava_Propanei 4y ago
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoWhat will it take to convince you?
- gadders 4y agoIt's not really a binary question though, is it? There are a bunch of questions you need to unpack: - Is the global climate warming? - Is this due to man-made causes, rather than some other global cycle? - Will the impact of this change be as serious as modelling (and hockey stick graphs) predict? What is your level of certainty? - Is it the biggest risk facing mankind today? Could we save more lives using the money for something else? - Are the proposed solutions worse than what you believe the likely impact of climate change to be?
- simiones 4y agoThe obvious, clear, indisputable answers are: - yes - yes - yes (>99%, at least if we allow that the outcomes may be more serious than the predictions) - yes - no (they can't be: the impact will be civilization-ending) It's really very simple, you have to willfully ignore or misrepresent the data to come to any other conclusion.
- nottorp 4y agoRegardless of what The Verge or the court system says, how can you trust a scientist that needs a lawsuit to defend their hypothesis?
- Kudotap 4y agoTruly beats me. I mean, if you were confident in your hypothesis, then why in Heaven's name would you file a lawsuit (a lawsuit!) against fellow scientists who are poking holes in the theory. Truthfully, these days it's really beginning to seem as though I'm living through the wrong century. I mean it's like something broke in the world, and basic common sense went took a looong vacation.
- SuoDuanDao 4y agoWhile I'm not familiar with the particulars of this case, I could see a scientist suing for misrepresenting his research in a libelous way. The publication in question could have been attacking a strawman with his name attached (not saying it was, just that this isn't a glaring issue with the scientist to me unless I know more).
- marginalia_nu 4y agoNot entirely unheard of for brawls to break out over scholarly disputes in the old days.
- shagie 4y agoHow about the really old days? How Imaginary Numbers Were Invented - https://youtu.be/cUzklzVXJwo?t=300 https://youtu.be/cUzklzVXJwo?t=300 (jumped directly into the math battle part)
- photochemsyn 4y agoThe oddest thing about Stanford's renewable energy program is that it's funded by something called the GCEP (Global Climate and Energy Program) which in turn counts ExxonMobile as a major sponsor. Does ExxonMobil really have any interest in seeing its fossil fuel market destroyed by renewable energy competition? https://gcep.stanford.edu/about/exxonmobil.html https://gcep.stanford.edu/about/exxonmobil.html There are also some interesting provisions about Exxon having some control of intellectual property arising from GCEP work in the details of the agreements. Not really surprising that nothing much has come out of that program.
- maxk42 4y agoIf you file a lawsuit against your critics then you're not a scientist.