5 ms·
It's good that it keeps getting exposed that a single organization without accountability decides what people are or are not allowed to publish on a platform to
by sneak 4y ago
It's good that it keeps getting exposed that a single organization without accountability decides what people are or are not allowed to publish on a platform to the people who explicitly subscribed to their publications.
The fact that moderation is a hard problem is orthogonal. The fact remains that there are different rules for different people, both for flagging and for content. The fact that there is more nuance than "two sets of rules" doesn't really change the fundamental problem that private companies now get to arbitrarily police publication by normal people.
I have the distinct impression that in 100 years the default mode is going to be "if it's legal you can post it, if it's not you can't, and if you have a problem with the boundary, take it up with the lawmaking authority and not us". We will look back at this time at the emergence of any-to-any publishing like the dawn of radio or TV or newspaper where a few rich guys got to decide what could or could not be published.
- CursedUrn 4y agoWhat makes you think something as unique and hard-fought as the First Amendment will be applied to the Internet when all trends point in the other direction, both on and offline?
- wbl 4y agohttps://www.getty.edu/art/collection/object/109FW5 https://www.getty.edu/art/collection/object/109FW5 (NSFW) is a beautiful picture, taken by a major 20th century photographer. It's also depicting a sex act that most people would never even consider. Do you really want pictures like this everywhere on Instagram? So now we have a no sex acts rule. But then an art museum is hosting an exhibition of art, and that art is depicting sex. Maybe even pedophilic sex, like a vase in the Met that has an old man stroking a young teenagers hairless genitals on it. That's very likely child pornography, except that the law can't ban images of artistic value, and the image of the vase has a lot of value, and I doubt anyone would find it erotic. Should the Met not be allowed to use a picture of a bunch of vases to promote its exhibitions? There's lots of reasons why reasonable seeming results are not possible from simple rules, and why it's legal, let's have it is not a great rule. Having a moderation system that addresses e.g. art studios and museums differently from other people is quite sensible.
- sneak 4y agoI don’t think pictures like this would be “everywhere on instagram” if instagram allowed all legal content. Correspondingly, I think your argument is a strawman.
- novok 4y agoThe solution to that is a rule set that users can select what they want and automated tagging. It is essentially opt-in moderation vs. chosen for you moderation. And it could become fairly sophisticated too! We are starting to see it in the form of subscribing to block lists on twitter. Also in practice I think this is covered for %99 of cases people via an NSFW & NSFL tag system. That would be an NSFW art and thats that. The children issue will boil down to parents are the real root user of their children's accounts and parents will have control over the tagging set for moderation until they are of age. IMO I think most people are fine with mandatory labeling of goods, and actually welcome it because it gives more control and informed consent. It's the mandatory censorship that become the issue. Abusive false labelling might become the next hot topic, but that is far smaller of a surface area.
- seattle_spring 4y agoIsn't that basically what happens now? Say I join a local city group. All posts to that group could be tagged with said #city in your world. Well right now anyone who is in one of these groups knows that many people come in and post lots of extremely charged national politics. They inevitably have their content removed as it's off-topic, not from Facebook but just from the city-specific group. The poster cries that their right to freedom of speech is being violated and that the mods are censoring them. So in your world, say the same person posts biased national political opinions and tags it with #city. Unless someone is moderating that tag, the tag becomes absolutely useless. It seems like how things work today, just with extra steps?
- novok 4y agoYou have a choice to filter out #city tagged items or not. And you can debate that a tag is incorrect as a matter of fact, much as you can debate if a food good does have sodium in it or not. And also tags are not singular, you can tag something #city #redteamblueteampolitics #highlyemotional #inflammatory and YOU get to choose if you want to see #highlyemotional content or not, not the platform. You get to choose if you want to follow the #rude #crazy person on Server Y, not your mastodon instance admin. Also a big part of this is matter of scale and choice. I don't think people care that much about a small subreddit and their bullshit most of the time, or petty facebook group politics. It's when the platform itself does the censoring, and when the platform is where %95 of content exists due to network effects and has user counts that are in the billions that it starts having a duty of neutrality. It's much like city roads or housing or similar, the people you filter out from housing and city roads have to be filtered out for dangerous damage to the infrastructure or people itself and that is it, otherwise you get into really bad political and discriminatory territory when you say black people or people of opinion Y can't buy housing here or drive on the roads. In this future system, you can also have alternative tagging systems, credit ratings for moderators, published AI models that tag client side, etc. I think it would be a very interesting marketplace of services!