4 ms·
> In my view, one of the advantages of cryptocurrencies as the foundation of a separate financial system is that systems are, by necessity, subject to adversari
by woodruffw 4y ago
> In my view, one of the advantages of cryptocurrencies as the foundation of a separate financial system is that systems are, by necessity, subject to adversarial hardening. In this interpretation, Avraham’s actions act to strengthen the system in the long run.
The language of "adversarial hardening" is torturous, and amounts to a tacit admission of failure: that cryptocurrency somehow needs to go through a process of making every single mistake that traditional finance has made and corrected for.
The necessity of this repeated rake-to-face process is not elaborated or further justified.
- junofan 4y agoWhy must it be justified? This is a financial system, not a battle of rhetoric. If you don’t want to participate, don’t. Evidently, enough people want to participate.
- woodruffw 4y ago> This is a financial system, not a battle of rhetoric. No, this is a blog post about a well-understood failure mode in traditional finance. If cryptocurrency advocates want to lay claim to the "financial system" label, they should be prepared to explain how their schemes are efficient mechanisms for value transaction, not sandboxes for making sure the rules of financial crime haven't changed.
- adnzzzzZ 4y agoNo one needs to explain anything. I transact in it and it works, therefore it is an efficient mechanism for value transaction. If you don't want to participate then fine, but as the person you replied to said, evidently enough people do.
- woodruffw 4y agoSure. Let me rephrase: being taken seriously requires you to explain &c. This is a public forum; nobody particularly likes it when someone says "this is so" and doesn't offer an intelligible explanation. With enough incentives (including a large pool of greater fools), you can convince otherwise reasonable parties to use your scheme. But that doesn't make it a financial scheme; that makes it a financialized scam.
- betwixthewires 4y agoI take it seriously. You don't. That's the thing about this stuff: it's voluntary. That's the point the above commenters are trying to make. We don't need a consensus of you all to do what we want, and if you don't want to be involved, don't.
- woodruffw 4y agoI take it seriously enough; I have a civic interest in harm reduction in this area. “Voluntary” cuts it when you’re talking amongst yourselves, but again: this is a public forum, not one specially for your interests. I get to voice common sense objections; that’s the point of this place.
- betwixthewires 4y agoSure you get a voice. We can have a discussion. But the point being made above is that we need someone's respect, someone's consensus, someone's approval to do what we are doing. And to that I say if you don't like what we are doing don't get involved.
- woodruffw 4y ago> We can have a discussion. That's all this has ever been! > And to that I say if you don't like what we are doing don't get involved. This, of course, only holds as far as cryptocurrencies remain a non-risk to most "main street" investors. But they're creeping towards that group (as the next biggest free pool of capital), and I have a civic interest in those people not losing their shirts. No man is an island, &c.
- bigbluedots 4y agoYou transact in it, it works, and then sometime later everyone's funds are wiped out by hacking, arbitrage and others.
- kortilla 4y ago> and amounts to a tacit admission of failure: that cryptocurrency somehow needs to go through a process of making every single mistake that traditional finance has made and corrected for These problems are different and the solutions are different. The way traditional finance solved this was to incorporate the big scary people with guns to enforce their rules. It would be an admission of failure if they called for government regulation, but that’s not what’s happening here. They are going back to the drawing board to keep hardening the technology in the face of openly adversarial actors.
- woodruffw 4y ago> These problems are different and the solutions are different. The way traditional finance solved this was to incorporate the big scary people with guns to enforce their rules. Traditional finance did not incorporate the Scary Men with Guns. They were already there, are still here, and will remain regardless of how many layers of decentralization you add. Traditional finance's crowning achievement has been to successfully integrate itself into civil law: we don't send people to the Poor House anymore, and we don't execute bankers (or ordinary citizens) when they fail to finance the King's wars. Among the "kinds of crime" you can conceivably execute on as an individual, traditional financial crimes are among a handful that are regulated by agencies that don't have actual criminal enforcement abilities. There is no "going back to the drawing board," only muddying the waters and hoping that someone won't notice the Scary Men with Guns (who have no intention of leaving) in the reflection.
- lmm 4y ago> we don't send people to the Poor House anymore We let them get into debt they can't repay and then send them to jail instead, but functionally it amounts to the same thing, except for being harder to get out of.
- woodruffw 4y ago> We let them get into debt they can't repay and then send them to jail instead, but functionally it amounts to the same thing, except for being harder to get out of. These do not amount to the same thing: one is debt, and the other is an extension of the carceral system. As best I can tell, cryptocurrencies do not eliminate individual debt. Rather, they provide myriad new ways for ordinary laypeople to leverage themselves into lifetimes of poverty. So it's not clear what this (true!) observation has to do with the conversation.
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoAnd more to the point, there’s no suggestion of this process ever stopping. There will always be bugs—new ones discovered and old ones reintroduced.
- woodruffw 4y agoOn it's own, that would be fine! Nobody expects criminals to stop innovating on crime; it's fundamentally an arms race. The problem is not the unending process itself, but the flawed (and conceited) belief that cryptocurrencies don't have to solve the same problems.
- CPLX 4y agoYes but we do expect to be unaffected by financial crime. I have never been the victim of a financial crime, like an institution trusted to hold my assets just not doing it. Most people I know haven’t either. Granted it’s not like it never happens. But it’s exceedingly rare and people’s standards are incredibly high. We demand and expect that if you put money in a bank you can always get it back and we mostly stick to that plan.
- woodruffw 4y agoWell said. In a perverse way, financial schemes built on top of cryptocurrencies represent the crowning achievement of traditional finance: we've successfully made it so safe, so incredibly boring for ordinary citizens that technologists believe they can derive the same system from first principles.
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoWhen I’m dealing with a bank, I don’t have to care about the arms race. If the bank gets hacked, I haven’t lost my savings.
- betwixthewires 4y agoI don't quite buy this. "There will always be bugs" is a truism, along the lines of "all code bases will have to be maintained forever." But that's just not true, code can be done. I think it's really a problem of tooling. We have formal verification, you can come up with an idea, write a specification for it, and write code that does exactly what is intended. It does require more rigor than we currently have, someone attempting to build something must thoroughly understand what they're trying to accomplish and understand how to properly use the tooling, but it can be done.