3 ms·
> Is it really a shock that an institution designed largely by Stalin (although FDR's idea) isn't fit for purpose? It was an evolution of the league of nations
by epolanski 4y ago
> Is it really a shock that an institution designed largely by Stalin (although FDR's idea) isn't fit for purpose?
It was an evolution of the league of nations actually.
Considering that during the last 77 years none of the 30 biggest economies in the world fought each other (I think there are minor exceptions like Argentina-Britain over Falklands/Malvinas), I think UN isn't that bad.
> Time to hit restart, and perhaps not to include the autocracies and miscreants.
And who gets to decide who those are? Also, what is the purpose of a club that doesn't include all the nations? It's just an alliance.
- Nomentatus 4y agoNo, it was a successor to the League. The League had been an obvious catastrophe; not something you'd want to copy or merely revise. A very big alliance beats a nothing burger - and remember that the United Nations did exclude Germany and Japan in the beginning, for obvious reasons. It was originally the instantiation of an alliance.
- Nomentatus 4y agoRussia and China fought - not a full war, but they fought. Iraq-Iran, very very bloody. And the list goes on and on. The cold war was an exceptionally bloody period with casualties not out of line with the WWII period, there were a **ton of proxy wars.
- Nomentatus 4y agoAdd extensive air combat between Soviet pilots and American pilots in Vietnam, and Korea I believe.
- epolanski 4y agoAs I said there are minor exceptions. Iraq and Iran were not top 30 economies when they fought the war.
- colechristensen 4y agoCasualties absolutely were out of line with WWII. Go find a graph of war deaths divided by world population by year for the last two hundred years and make the comparison yourself.
- twelve40 4y agoThe biggest loss of life during the Cold war occurred in Vietnam and Korea, a couple of million people dead each. The US wasn't very "proxy" about those wars, just bombed the shit out of both directly, civilians and all. So, how do you define a "miscreant" you would like to exclude? Based on number of people killed, or some other, more "democratic" criteria?