3 ms·
What is the actual mechanism that is causing these fires to start? Is it saltwater getting into the battery itself? Is it saltwater in the high voltage wirin
by londons_explore 4y ago
What is the actual mechanism that is causing these fires to start?
Is it saltwater getting into the battery itself? Is it saltwater in the high voltage wiring outside the battery? Is it physical damage to waterproof seals that is simply revealed during a flood, but probably would have let rainwater in if you drove through a ford? Or is it maybe unrelated to the saltwater, and is simply physical damage to the batteries caused by the storm?
- londons_explore 4y agoIf the cause is saltwater in anything, the design fix is easy... Simply have single-use disconnects between groups of battery cells, such that say the ~400v battery gets split into five 80 volt batteries. Then, when there is only 80 volts across a bit of saltwater, not enough current will flow to get hot enough to start a fire. You'll just end up with some warm bleachy water and a lot of corrosion. Hydrogen gas is produced, but inside the battery there won't be sufficient oxygen for it to burn, and outside the battery hydrogen isn't too dangerous because it disperses incredibly fast. The same disconnects could be used for emergency situations - as soon as they have been disconnected, there is no risk of electric shock to any first responders, even if they cut through high voltage wires.
- robocat 4y agoThe design fix is to add regulations requiring vehicles to safely handle salt water immersion. Let the manufacturer choose implementation.
- robocat 4y agoSaw this factoid: The result? Hybrid-powered cars were involved in about 3,475 fires per every 100,000 sold. Gasoline-powered cars, about 1,530. Electric vehicles (EVs) saw just 25 fires per 100,000 sold. I wonder how that will change as the fleet ages: I would like to see a comparison from the same car demographic (pricepoint, end-user, vehicle age cohort, mileage). It is unobvious why hybrids should be so fire prone: perhaps because they are often high mileage taxi vehicles? (Is risk kilometre based, or technology dependency?)