5 ms·
Apple Music and Mercedes-Benz bring immersive Spatial Audio to drivers
- hopfenspergerj 4y agoAlmost nothing in “spatial audio” is actually mastered for spatial audio. The fake surround filter absolutely destroys stereo mixes, it’s really despicable how this is being pushed.
- bfgoodrich 4y ago
- dagmx 4y agoTracks have a clear Dolby Atmos label when a track is mastered for Atmos vs not.
- andy_ppp 4y agoI must be the only person who seems to think Apple's DSP stuff falls into massive uncanny valley (it makes the music feel lifeless and flat and boring). Never mind I don't understand what the point of hearing music from some other point in the digitally manufactured "room" is, it's certainly not what the artist intended.
- crazygringo 4y agoWell it's mastered for 5.1. True there aren't usually Atmos objects, but sometimes there are, but also there don't usually need to be. Are you taking issue with "5.1" being called spatial? I couldn't disagree more about the "fake surround filter" though -- I love surround sound on my AirPods Pro, even when "spatialized" from stereo. It simply makes music and movies/TV so much clearer to listen to. Everything becomes more distinct and intelligible. I understand how people rail against the "purity" of the original stereo mix's "intentions", but the reality is that when you listen to music on speakers, the amount of reflection and absorption in any room is already destroying that "purity". Spatial audio filters aren't "destroying" the audio anymore than speakers in a room already do -- the difference is that they're increasing clarity rather than muddying it all up. I can't ever imagine going back to listening to flat stereo again, where the sound on headphones feels stuck inside of my skull instead of coming from outside. Headphone fatigue is a real thing, coming from the fact that our brains aren't meant to process audio without all of the associated spatial cues. (Sound isn't supposed to feel like it's emanating from inside our skulls.) Modern surround filters do an awfully good job at restoring those cues. No more headphone fatigue.
- Cu3PO42 4y agoNot the parent, but find myself agreeing with both of you, in a way. No matter if it's 5.1 or "proper Atmos", those mixes sound fine - or maybe even good, depending on your preferences - on headphones. I also have a fake surround upmix on an audio interface that I occasionally use. But I almost always detest how these mixes sound on my actual 5.1.2 setup. The surround channels mostly consist of a bit of reverb that adds nothing to the experience in my opinion. In a car where there are physically separate channels, I'm not optimistic for the result.
- anaganisk 4y agoA properly mixed Binaural sound sounds so good even on Stereo channels, lookup virtual barber shop on youtube, it always gives me goosebumps. Also afaik tracks are never mixed for stereo/mono. They start as multi channel, if ogg ever gains I think it has multi channel support. It must bring some spatial audio into masses, with smaller downloads and quality streaming. Also its very good for cinematic audio in videos.
- fredley 4y agoIs a car a good place for this? It sounds distracting.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoI've often thought that a car is the ideal place for multichannel music. Headphones have to fake it because they are attached to your head, and surround systems in the home are usually pointed at a TV. If you look in any other direction the effect is broken. But in a car you are guaranteed to be facing forwards all the time. The "rear" speakers will always be behind you.
- kjkjadksj 4y agoIf you set it up for the drivers side you mess up passenger dynamics though
- londons_explore 4y agoThe car already has seat occupancy sensors - so it can adjust the sound depending on which seats are occupied to give the best overall experience.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoThat effect is much smaller than facing in the wrong direction.
- myself248 4y agoYeah, when I'm parked and enjoying some music, that's great. When I'm driving, I want my ears to alert me to spatial happenings where I can't see them. I force the audio to the front speakers only, specifically to prevent it from sounding too "real". I also hate it when the music has sirens in it. So, this is spiffy, but I hope there's a way to turn it off.
- jcynix 4y agoSame here. When I see these ads (x speakers, Dolby whatever for cars) I always think that's for people without a decent home. I use cars to drive and listen to hifi at home ...
- DisjointedHunt 4y agoAn absolute coup that Apple might be able to pull off is if they're able to replace control electronics for Daimler with their A-Series (Or other custom ASIC) chips. When Sandy Munroe tore down the Tesla Model 3, a remark he made hit hard. That the control electronics in that thing seemed like space age for the car industry. That's not a compliment to Tesla alone, that's a criticism of the state of the art in the car industry where miniaturization has not kept pace with the leading edge phone generations that Apple spits out every year. Imagine that, a common platform that Apple could upsell to ALL vehicle manufacturers with custom enterprise apps written by the companies themselves for vehicle electronics.
- mcintyre1994 4y agoThey recently showed a video of some vaporware where their car software powers every screen in a car, including the speedo and stuff like that. So they might be thinking along the same lines.
- dagmx 4y agoNot exactly vapourware since it’s announced as supporting cars at the end of 2023, though it still runs off of your phone
- sneak 4y agoSo if your phone overheats in the sun, or crashes, your instrument cluster freezes? Note also that CarPlay does not work at all with Siri disabled. This means that if you don’t opt in to a hot mic you can’t use any of it.
- awinder 4y ago1. Reverts to the standard vehicle interface 2. Siri is activated by user input (holding a button / pressing a button in-car) with a side feature for hot mic (hey siri) that’s disabled by default 3. Maybe there’s car implementation solely driven by Siri? Hondas is touch screen and Mazda is button/knob based (and touch screen but only when idle).
- dang 4y agoIs there a different article about this that isn't a corporate press release? https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=corporate%20press%20release%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...
- midislack 4y ago
- parhamn 4y agoHow vertically integrated do you have to be to support spatial audio? Could Spotify just add it? Could whatsapp calls add it?
- dagmx 4y agoSpotify probably could if they could deliver an Atmos stream. But what would you gain from a WhatsApp call? It’s a mono source
- londons_explore 4y agoIt would be pretty nice for a group call to have each voice from a different direction... It would also be nice for a callers voice and other sounds in the call, like for example music or background sound, to be audibly separated - the fact they aren't separated is part of what makes background sounds on voice calls so annoying compared to say background sounds when talking to someone on the street..
- dagmx 4y agoAh yeah FaceTime positions everyone in a spatial way in group calls. Would be nice if other group call setups did the same
- lodovic 4y agoThat is not so useful for in a car though
- dagmx 4y agoWhy not? In a group call audio setting it can still help you separate who’s talking easier
- lodovic 4y agoIn a car I assume all distractions are possible dangers and I don't want to confuse background noise in the call for actual dangers on the road. Also, I do not want to visualise the call, as that will be a major distraction from driving. To be fair, driving and having a group call is a bad idea in itself.
- jonathantf2 4y agoDamn that centre console looks awful, plus the UI looks like something that would have been pushed 10 years ago.
- mrtksn 4y agoIt has Windows 7 Media Player vibes but honestly I'm tired of everything being flat so if the interface structure is designed right, has consistency and is snappy, I won't hate it. That said, I'm skeptical that it's designed well because there's a menu for climate control. These things should have physical buttons that blend with the digital UI.
- seydor 4y agoso now you have virtual honks ?
- robotshmobot 4y agoGood god that UI is such a waste of space with tiny buttons and half the screen used for background mountains. Why are the skip track buttons down next to the home button? What does the plus symbol do? What are the icons on the black bar for? Why does the whole thing look like Windows Vista? The auto industry does not truly understand how to build an interface. Edit: If I spent that much on a car I would be furious to turn it on and find that interface.
- Cu3PO42 4y agoIn my experience, the majority of tracks that are "mastered for spatial audio" sound absolutely terrible when played on actual surround speakers. Most of the sound is on the center and the two front channels, it's probably similar to the stereo mix except with vocals on the center. The other channels get a slight reverb that sounds completely automatically generated. This sounds okay when mixed back down to stereo for headphones; there's a certain airiness that can be pleasing, but that's it. In an expensive Mercedes, I'd expect proper spatial audio with separate speakers for separate channels and it to sound maybe not quite as bad as in a home theater setting, but nearly. Unless these masters get significantly better I'll just stick to the stereo mix duplicated on other channels. The one exception to the rule above that I've experienced was some song by Billie Eilish. I didn't enjoy the music, but the mastering was excellent: they took care to actually move the location of sounds around that didn't interfer with the music.
- retskrad 4y agoWhy is Apple spending hundreds of millions of dollars advertising Apple Music on places like the upcoming Super Bowl when the streaming service is running on such shaky ground? They need to rewrite the entire backend of the service but for some reason, they don't allocate resources to do so. If we compare it to Spotify, everything loads slower and the search fuction is awful.
- w_for_wumbo 4y agoI've had the same complaint about Spotify search, sometimes nothing will be returned from my search, despite me having put in the name of the song I know exists on the platform.