3 ms·
> Objects in higher orbits are slower than objects at lower altitudes You are right. My point still stands. On collision debris might have significantly differ
by scotty79 4y ago
> Objects in higher orbits are slower than objects at lower altitudes
You are right. My point still stands. On collision debris might have significantly different velocities than the original objects thus have different orbits.
> One satellite smashing into another would not add sufficient energy to the debris to alter its speed significantly.
I think that's completely dependant on the mass of the specific particle of debris. The smaller the particle, the larger possible speed change attainable in a messy collision.
I'd really prefer that there was some scientific study simulating possible results of impact between two SpaceX satellites. Because there's non-zero chance of that happening. For example if there are some errors during the deployment of new batch.
- gatonegro 4y agoYes, sorry, my phrasing is somewhat confusing. In terms of energy they are faster, since more speed is required for higher orbits. They appear to be slower in a relative sense when observed from Earth — the Space Station or a Starlink sat will appear to be moving significantly faster than a satellite in medium or high-Earth orbit. It also depends on the geometry of the orbit — an object in a circular orbit will move at a constant speed, while an object in an elliptical orbit will move faster or slower depending on which point of the ellipse it is. I understood the parent comment to be focused on an Earth-centred perspective, since they were talking about Kessler syndrome and Earth-orbiting debris. I was trying to address that point from an Earth-centred perspective too, but I appreciate how that can be confusing.
- scotty79 4y agoNo, no. You were right about the speeds and I was wrong. Higher circular orbits do have lower speeds. Starlink satellites have speeds over 7km/s while satellites on much higher geostationary orbit have little over 3km/s. I haven't built my intuition about why it's true but it is. Orbital speed is proportional to inverse square root of orbit radius.