4 ms·
Sigh, another article focusing on Tesla battery fires when it is a common failure mode to most of not all EVs. In the end, the inconsistency makes the article m
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
Sigh, another article focusing on Tesla battery fires when it is a common failure mode to most of not all EVs. In the end, the inconsistency makes the article more confusing. The quoted officials all talk about EVs in general while the author talks about Teslas, and the reader doesnt know what actually happened.
- lbotos 4y agoIsn't this just "the kleenex effect" where the most prominent brand becomes the "defacto name". Do you see this as some form of "slander" against Tesla?
- furyofantares 4y agoI've never heard someone IRL talking about Teslas when they mean some other EV or EVs in general. So no, it doesn't seem like the kleenex effect at all, it's just much more attention grabbing to talk about Teslas specifically in an article, so it's done even thigh it's misleading. Like, the actual article mostly only mentions EVs but then the headline says Tesla. It's clickbait. IMO the HN title should be edited to "Electric Vehicle fires..."
- bestnameever 4y ago> The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration is aware of multiple fires in Tesla vehicles, the agency said in a letter sent Friday (Oct 14) to a Florida official and obtained by Bloomberg Government. Perhaps due to the popularity of Teslas, it is being seen in them more so than other vehicles
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIs it being seen more in Teslas? It is unclear from this shitty article
- lazide 4y agoIf it bleeds, it leads.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI dont think it is intentional slander, I think they are intentionally confusing the topics to drive clicks. I am curious about Teslas AND EVs, but they way they mix them up I learn nothing about either. Is this a Tesla specific issue... unclear What is happening with other EVs... Unclear The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration makes a statement about Teslas... did they mention other cars? exclude other cars?
- fragmede 4y agoHere's a Bloomberg.com (not .sg) link that says there's been two such fires in the entire state in the wake of hurricane Ian, but doesn't name the brand. Draw your own conclusion as to wether that's a statewide emergency affecting Teslas. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-10-14/tesla-fires-after-hurricane-raise-alarm-for-florida-officials https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-10-14/tesla-fir...
- themitigating 4y agoWere tissues are controversial product when they first came out? On many Tiktoks I see where someone is discussing their Tesla people make a large number of negative remarks unrelated to the video. Because of this when I see an article using "Tesla" for an issue that all EVs face I'm suspicious.
- mschuster91 4y ago> Sigh, another article focusing on Tesla battery fires when it is a common failure mode to most of not all EVs. The question is, why can these fires happen? It's one thing if a pack goes on a thermal runaway after mechanical damage, such as after a collision or when a building collapses on a car. But ordinary water ingress? Why don't battery packs have waterproof seals and high-current transistors that only provide power to the battery pack's port when requested to do so by the car's ECU? In case that these are easy to fix (or at least, cheap to integrate parts) construction deficits, car makers should absolutely be held accountable.
- ajross 4y agoYou don't think there might have been mechanical damage during a hurricane? Batteries burn. They just do. Life with EVs means life with mitigation strategies for minimizing battery fires (which absolutely include waterproof seals and solid state power circuits, FWIW!). I mean, it's true, that this must seem scary in comparison to gasoline fueled cars, which don't involve storing flammable material inside the car, or have a failure mode where they can "catch fire", right?
- falcolas 4y agoNo, batteries don't just burn. There are many different battery formulations, and most of them do not burn when they get too hot. Yes, the most popular battery recipe for EVs today is one that burns, but "Batteries burn. They just do." is a poor generalization.
- ajross 4y agoAll lithium batteries burn. The energy densities are just too high to prevent; there isn't enough thermal conductivity to self-cool in the event of an internal short. It's true that the relative risk changes with chemistry. The nickel/cobalt chemistries popular in consumer electronics and most EVs are indeed some of the more volatile (owing in no small part to their higher energy densities!). LiFePO4 looks like it's going to be a better fit in the long term. It's less of a fire risk and has some other advantages (cheaper raw materials and much higher durability being at the top of the list). But don't buy the snake oil: iron phosphate batteries burn too. There's no free lunch here. You want to push two tons of metal around on the street, you need a bunch of stored energy to do that. And stored energy escapes.
- kevingadd 4y agoEV fires are more difficult to extinguish, aren't they? And EVs are often parked inside personal homes, so there's a higher likelihood that the fire could spread to a house and kill sleeping parents and children instead of only causing property damage. It at least makes sense that people find EV fires scarier than ordinary fires.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- denimnerd42 4y agoour house has a carriage house in the backyard for the garage. i don't really like it setup like that but I guess it could be useful if this issue doesn't resolve.
- kevingadd 4y agoYeah, people also park in the driveway in many cases, which similarly protects you from a fire spreading to your house. At least where I grew up most people used their garages for storage or as a workshop, etc. Maybe climates like Florida's encourage garage use though since weather is going to age your car's paint more quickly? Not sure.
- ajross 4y agoNo sleeping parents or children have been killed by an EV fire in a garage. Bad logic like that (painting a picture instead of citing data) is precisely why people flip out about sub-noise signals like this (four cars burned in the course of a huge regional hurricane that destroyed whole tracts of suburban homes).
- kevingadd 4y agoSo you don't have a refutation to things like "EV fires are harder to extinguish" and you're just attacking a claim I didn't make ("sleeping parents or children were killed by an EV fire")? In the first place, I explicitly said that this is why people are scared, not that it actually makes Teslas unusually dangerous. Situations like this are all about shock value.
- z7 4y agoIf the headline said "EVs" instead of "Teslas" it would get less clicks.
- jdhn 4y ago>Sigh, another article focusing on Tesla battery fires when it is a common failure mode to most of not all EVs. The article uses Tesla as a way to catch the readers eye. The actual article shows that Senator Scott asked not only Tesla, but other manufacturers such as Ford, GM, and Stellantis about what they were doing to mitigate this.
- judge2020 4y ago> a way to catch the readers eye. I guess the term "clickbait" is too harsh these days.
- lesuorac 4y agoI suspect its even worse than that. The body of the article doesn't make any claims about a tesla catching fire. It only uses EV: "a series of electric vehicle (EV) fires tied to Hurricane Ian." So there may be 0 tesla fires. I really feel like the article buried the lede though. I really think the bigger story is that the EV can catch fire for weeks after the water damage with (I assume) no warning/diagnostic errors. "“Lithium-ion vehicle battery fires have been observed both rapidly igniting and igniting several weeks after battery damage occurred,” Jack Danielson, executive director at NHTSA, wrote in the letter to Patronis."
- rad88 4y agohttps://twitter.com/JimmyPatronis/status/1578050503279316992 https://twitter.com/JimmyPatronis/status/1578050503279316992
- lupire 4y agoPlease don't link blindly to Twitter. It's 280 characters or an image link, copy it to here, or link to an accessible site like nitter.net.
- robocat 4y agoI think that if someone only wishes to post a link, then good on them. You can use nitter if that works for you. I agree it would be nice if people took the time to write a more thoughtful post, but I also think that trying to convince the internet to improve its behaviour is antisensible.. Perhaps instead of trying to ask others to do something, you could have added a link to nitter, and a 240 character summary (although in this case the relevant thread is wayyy longer than that and contains relevant images, so good luck!) As always: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Disclaimer: I sometimes find guidelines aggravating.
- guelo 4y agoWho cares? Why are people so protective of Tesla?
- judge2020 4y agoFrom the articles linked throughout this thread there were two EV fires during Ian and none of them reported on the brand of the car that caught fire. Why harp on a company that has 0 implied involvement, besides by being the company that originally brought the technology to market?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Spivak 4y ago
- fortran77 4y ago> 2. Tesla is a stock people who aren’t really into investing own. The #2 and #3 holders of Tesla stock are The Vanguard Total Stock Market Index (VTSAX) and The Vanguard 500 Index Fund (VFIAX) ...so it's safe to say that all sorts of people are interested in Tesla stock.
- natch 4y ago
- curiousgal 4y agoThe title phrasing was a solid omen for what's the come.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cma 4y agoI see one article claiming 10+ EV fires from one department. Were any non-Teslas? All the footage and articles I see so far are of Teslas, but that might be because they are more popular: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V1ge694JwTw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V1ge694JwTw https://twitter.com/JimmyPatronis/status/1578050503279316992 https://twitter.com/JimmyPatronis/status/1578050503279316992 And it is harder to search for all the various other brands (to the Kleenex point).
- quantumwannabe 4y agoMaybe it focuses on Teslas because the quoted official personally witnessed a Tesla burning? https://twitter.com/jimmypatronis/status/1578050503279316992 https://twitter.com/jimmypatronis/status/1578050503279316992 https://twitter.com/jimmypatronis/status/1580963218155270146 https://twitter.com/jimmypatronis/status/1580963218155270146
- reaperducer 4y agoSigh, another article focusing on Tesla battery fires when it is a common failure mode to most of not all EVs. Sigh, another Tesla fanboi blaming the messenger, rather than addressing the issue at hand.
- hericium 4y agoThere's a gap between Tesla and other EVs build quality. Not every producer cuts as much corners as Elon.
- msh 4y agoLike they Toyotas where the wheels fell off...
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI am open to the idea, but have never once seen actual data to support this, just a lot of anecdotes. I been thinking about getting a EV for my next car so the garbage information in the space bothers me
- hericium 4y agoCar detailer Jessica Tran joked[1] that > the job requirements to be a Tesla assembly person were that you're blind with no hands But to be fair, I saw Teslas in Sweden, which had no defects like shown here. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mgjVvetGPak https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mgjVvetGPak
- lupire 4y agoA car detailer is going to see lot more Tesla's than other, less-showy major EVs like Leaf and Bolt
- panick21_ 4y agoThis is just nonsense.The issues that Teslas get dingged for are fit and finish issues. What we are talking about here is the electronics systems (batteries, motors and so on). Every single analysis of those systems shows that in those things Tesla are excellent. In most cases far ahead of the competition.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]