3 ms·
I've seen people saying that things like Starlink are inherently safe because they use very low orbits. But higher orbits are just higher speeds and when two o
by scotty79 4y ago
I've seen people saying that things like Starlink are inherently safe because they use very low orbits.
But higher orbits are just higher speeds and when two objects collide and break apart some smaller fragments might fly off with speeds far greater than those of colliding objects.
So failure at very low orbit might add a lot of debris to higher orbits that might trigger Kessler syndrome.
Am I wrong about this?
- gatonegro 4y ago> But higher orbits are just higher speeds and when two objects collide and break apart some smaller fragments might fly off with speeds far greater than those of colliding objects. Objects in higher orbits are slower[1] than objects at lower altitudes, and debris from a hypothetical collision between two high-orbiting objects would not accelerate to a speed "far greater" than the originating objects, because that increase in speed would require some form of acceleration. One satellite smashing into another would not add sufficient energy to the debris to alter its speed significantly. Any change to the speed of the resulting debris, if it were to occur, would also necessarily alter its orbit. The object's speed and its orbital altitude depend on each other. > So failure at very low orbit might add a lot of debris to higher orbits that might trigger Kessler syndrome. It should be noted that "failure" does not mean "exploding into a thousand pieces", so a malfunctioning satellite by itself is not that much of a problem. Low altitude satellites such as Starlink are actually better from a space junk perspective — their altitude means the effect of atmospheric drag on the spacecraft will eventually (within months, sometimes) cause it to re-enter the atmosphere instead of just hanging around in Earth orbit forever, like dead satellites do at higher orbits. Kessler syndrome would be more likely to occur with satellites in medium and high Earth orbit, since there is no drag to bring the dead spacecraft or debris back down to Earth. Anti-satellite weapons are particularly dangerous here, because they're likely to target high-orbiting satellites and leave debris fields behind. --- [1] As pointed below, in terms of pure kinetic energy this is not correct. I was referring to apparent speed vs an object in low-Earth orbit.
- scotty79 4y ago> Objects in higher orbits are slower than objects at lower altitudes You are right. My point still stands. On collision debris might have significantly different velocities than the original objects thus have different orbits. > One satellite smashing into another would not add sufficient energy to the debris to alter its speed significantly. I think that's completely dependant on the mass of the specific particle of debris. The smaller the particle, the larger possible speed change attainable in a messy collision. I'd really prefer that there was some scientific study simulating possible results of impact between two SpaceX satellites. Because there's non-zero chance of that happening. For example if there are some errors during the deployment of new batch.
- gatonegro 4y agoYes, sorry, my phrasing is somewhat confusing. In terms of energy they are faster, since more speed is required for higher orbits. They appear to be slower in a relative sense when observed from Earth — the Space Station or a Starlink sat will appear to be moving significantly faster than a satellite in medium or high-Earth orbit. It also depends on the geometry of the orbit — an object in a circular orbit will move at a constant speed, while an object in an elliptical orbit will move faster or slower depending on which point of the ellipse it is. I understood the parent comment to be focused on an Earth-centred perspective, since they were talking about Kessler syndrome and Earth-orbiting debris. I was trying to address that point from an Earth-centred perspective too, but I appreciate how that can be confusing.
- scotty79 4y agoNo, no. You were right about the speeds and I was wrong. Higher circular orbits do have lower speeds. Starlink satellites have speeds over 7km/s while satellites on much higher geostationary orbit have little over 3km/s. I haven't built my intuition about why it's true but it is. Orbital speed is proportional to inverse square root of orbit radius.
- toast0 4y agoOne thing you may not have considered is the shape of the orbit of the debris. While the orbit of the aggregated debris pre-disassembly was likely mostly circular, debris that heads upward (or downward) post-disassembly will end up in an eliptic orbit, which will mean it spends some time above the previous orbit and some time below. While the time above raises risk of impacting objects in higher orbit, the time below has increased atmospheric drag and reduces the time in orbit. The higher the apogee, the lower the perogee, but I haven't looked at detailed analysis.
- scotty79 4y agoThose satellites orbits are roughly on the exactly the same sphere, so if two of them collide at an angle debris would shoot out tangentially to this sphere so while apogee would be higher, perogee would be at the same distance as original orbit.
- jurschreuder 4y agoSatellites in low orbit automatically fall back to earth because of air resistance. So the debris does not build up over time. < 500km -> 25 years 800km -> 100-150 years 1200km -> 2000 years