5 ms·
> protects the user's privacy because it is logically impossible for applications to breach the kernel's hardware security protections and the system components
by yjftsjthsd-h 4y ago
> protects the user's privacy because it is logically impossible for applications to breach the kernel's hardware security protections and the system components are verifiably secure.
Notice also that they're doing the traditional Google trick of pretending that it respects the user's privacy because it's secure, while ignoring the fact that most of the users privacy will be destroyed by things they designed the operating system to intentionally do in its security model.
- geofft 4y agoIt protects the user's privacy against attackers other than Google. To be fair, this is an entirely reasonable threat model for a lot of people. For instance, if you're a reporter in an authoritarian country, Google is almost certainly not colluding with the attackers who are literally trying to kill you, and using a Chromebook and Gmail is probably the best option out there. Your threat model is "Don't die," not "Don't be subject to surveillance capitalism." But it's also something we should collectively be pushing back on. The motivating example for these products is "intelligent ambient systems," i.e., things like Nest hubs and doorbells that capture audio/video all the time. These products probably shouldn't exist at all, and to the extent they do, they should process data locally and discard it as soon as they can.
- londons_explore 4y agoGoogle sucks up a lot of data, and is in a position to do a lot of bad stuff with it, but historically they have never told my spouse about my affair, my government about my accounts in the caymans, or leaked my nude pictures to my grandma. (I don't actually have any of these!) I really don't care how much data of mine they have while they limit their evil they use it for to deciding if they should show an ad for baseball or football shirts... And I trust them not to accidentally leak it far more than I trust my government or any smaller/less techy company.
- water-your-self 4y agoUntil governments approach them and demand that data or force Google to leave.
- Mikeb85 4y agoGoogle has refused to cooperate with authoritarian governments and even left China over it. Unlike Apple and MS...
- Shugyousha 4y agoAFAIK they have been back in China for a few years again though ...
- Mikeb85 4y agoNot really... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_China
- gloryjulio 4y agoNot sure what your a talking about. Google/Fb/Twitter etc are all banned in China. The major surviving ones are Microsoft and Apple.
- gloryjulio 4y agoThis. Now iOS is starting to turning to ads business. Apple is officially worse than Google.
- Tagbert 4y agoWhy is Apple worse? Because they have a limited ads business?
- gloryjulio 4y agoBecause of hypocrisy? They pretend to be not in ads business with your data So now everyone is doing the same thing so called value the 'privacy' (aka only they could collect the data for themselves to do personalized ads). So in the end you pick the one who hoard ur data and show the ads. What's the difference again?
- themerone 4y agoI chose Google's mesh routers because I have more trust in their security than any competitor. I would feel pretty safe with PFSense, but my needs are way too simple to bother with that. I know a lot of techies opt for prosumer, small business gear for their home networks, but most of those vendors have crap security trackrecords. Ubiquiti, seems to be the sole standout in this space, but I don't trust them any more than google to produce secure hardware.
- swozey 4y agoUbiq has had horrendous security issues
- themerone 4y agoHave you seen Krebs on Security most recent update. He pretty much disavowed his reporting on the Ubiquity breach. Everybody has security breaches. I'm not out there counting CVEs, but anecdotally, it seems that Netgear, TP-Link, microtik have seem to have much worse reputations. I don't pay attention to the market for high end networking (Cisco, Juniper).
- swozey 4y agoAh I had forgotten about the update to that. Last I remembered they were suing him. I only have Ubiq equipment.
- snotrockets 4y agoSecurity is not privacy though. If I had a piece of information that could kill, I would trust Google with safeguarding it. What I don't trust them, is not to use information they got. Or rather, I expect them to use it (but safeguard it from others, because that's how they make money: by being the only ones allowed access to private information).
- whoopdedo 4y agoNot to mention protecting the privacy of the applications and operating system from the users themselves.
- skybrian 4y agoThis is a research project. There are no users and probably won’t be in this form. If it makes it into a real product, it might not even be done by Google (since they’re open sourcing it.) So nobody is being tricked. It just too early to say what real products will do.
- rodgerd 4y agoGoogle's fundamental definition of security and privacy is to expand your privacy to Google, so yes.