4 ms·
There are a lot of things here that I don't understand: - The issues around semiconductor manufacturing. - How Chinese politics work. - How the big Chinese m
by roenxi 4y ago
There are a lot of things here that I don't understand:
- The issues around semiconductor manufacturing.
- How Chinese politics work.
- How the big Chinese manufacturing hubs like Shenzhen work. The exports are spectacular, so I suspect they're incubating capitalists.
But what I do know is China is ~1 billion people, is moving in to being a country with some savings and is really getting the hang of high technology (eg, Huawei is the cutting edge of telecoms and it is going to shock everyone in a decade that they are at the cutting edge of nuclear tech as their reactor program keeps chugging along).
If they are seriously challenged to a tech war, we are relying on the Chinese government to defeat the Chinese people. It isn't possible to intellectually starve out a country that big, especially not in the age of the internet. They can achieve miracles in 20 years.
- baybal2 4y ago> They can achieve miracles in 20 years. Why they didn't do so already? There hardly been a single regime in history so eager to slaughter hens laying golden eggs. China is extremely anti-business, and anti-development (unless it's real estate development.) I first understood it when I seen block, and blocks of factories being bulldozed to make space for luxury hotels, and hooker parlours. Tells of priorities of people in power.
- throwaway4good 4y ago"China is extremely anti-business, and anti-development". Really? Are you absolutely sure about that?
- Nomentatus 4y agoCertainly Xi doesn't think that he's anti-business, and much that he's done mirrors the EU's actions vs monopolies. But Xi also has no understanding of business, and wants to micromanage everywhere. I think he's already had a large chilling effect without wanting to do that. He could easily, clumsily, kill off most of the geese laying golden eggs for him by instilling more terror of the government than hope of profit. I'm not sure that'll happen, but reading his speeches to this new PRC congress I suspect so.
- geysersam 4y ago> Why didn't they do so already? China's GDP has increased 8x since the year 2000. It has an enormous and well educated population. Thousands of universities. Their research and development output is soaring. It's become a manufacturing hub like nothing the world has ever seen before. There are lots of challenges with respect to the ideology of the government. But the development in China the last couple of decades has been miraculous already.
- XorNot 4y ago> China's GDP has increased 8x since the year 2000. China was a 3rd world nation which experienced an industrial revolution, which like all industrial revolutions beforehand was faster and more prosperous because they could just buy the relevant technology and expertise, which was now even cheaper then it was for the previous industrial revolution. Their GDP growth tells us nothing about whether their government is good at running a modern economy (evidence says no): because you have to pretty much be actively trying to fail to not have "miraculous" GDP growth when industrializing up from subsistence level farming.
- tchaffee 4y ago> China was a 3rd world nation which experienced an industrial revolution Why did that happen? Why isn't it happening so rapidly for other "3rd world" nations? I mean it wasn't luck. Economists will point to specific policies of the Chinese government that made it happen so quickly.
- andrekandre 4y ago> Economists will point to specific policies of the Chinese government that made it happen so quickly. and those policies are not some special secret; they are the same "industrial policies" that japan, south korea, and the u.s (and many other advanced countries) used to develop rapidly and fully...
- tchaffee 4y ago
- ETHisso2017 4y ago"block, and blocks of factories being bulldozed to make space for luxury hotels, and hooker parlours" Where did you see this?
- tchaffee 4y ago> Why didn't they do so already. They did. The Chinese economy has pulled more people out of poverty in the past few decades than any economy in human history. By far. "In 1990 there were more than 750 million people in China living below the international poverty line - about two-thirds of the population. By 2012, that had fallen to fewer than 90 million, and by 2016 - the most recent year for which World Bank figures are available - it had fallen to 7.2 million people" Mistaking the China of today for the China of 50 years ago would be naive and dangerous. Fortunately most world leaders are savvy enough to be taking action to compete. This is not an endorsement of the Chinese government. It's just a factual observation of recent history.
- neither_color 4y agoI never quite understood that line since they pretty much purged themselves in the first place and were "lifting themselves" after sinking themselves in the cultural revolution. They opened up after visiting Asian Tiger economies and realizing they were far behind Singapore, South Korea, et al.
- tchaffee 4y agoIf you want to blame them for the bad you need to give them credit for recent accomplishments. Unless you think it's a line that Americans sunk themselves in The Great Depression and therefore American leaders should get no credit for the following recovery. Leaders change. Economic policy changes. China changed direction and lifted a huge number of people out of poverty. It's as simple as that. > They opened up after visiting Asian Tiger economies and realizing they were far behind Singapore, South Korea, et al. And? What's the point? That they learned by observing? Is that bad?
- neither_color 4y agoThe Great Depression was not a deliberate purge, markets follow boom and bust cycles. >And? What's the point? That they learned by observing? Is that bad? It's a self-serving bias to attribute their economic development to their leadership. They would've developed sooner and are simply taking credit for getting out of their own way. Sure, you can point to specific projects and say "the government bankrolled this therefore it exists" but it's not like in their absence nothing would have developed. Hong Kong, Singapore, Taipei, Seoul, Tokyo et al have pretty skylines and good public transportation too.
- Vt71fcAqt7 4y ago>first understood it when I seen block, and blocks of factories being bulldozed to make space for luxury hotels, and hooker parlours The US did this on a national scale.
- mlindner 4y agoI'd call this post a lot of wishful thinking that doesn't look at where the economy in China is heading nor the attitude of countries around the world to China.
- roenxi 4y agoThere are uncertainties, but it is hardly wishful thinking to theorise that the world's premier manufacturing superpower could figure out how to manufacture something new. If anything it speaks volumes about their 2nd rate governance strategies that the outcome is in question.
- mlindner 4y agoRussia was the premier manufacturing superpower yet rapidly fell behind the west in many areas of manufacturing. Just because you make a lot of widgets doesn't automatically mean you can climb the value chain.
- myth_drannon 4y agoHuawei stole its telecom tech from Nortel. I wouldn't call them innovative, more like great at industrial espionage.
- vasac 4y agoThat has been debunked on a HN a few times already.
- adrian_b 4y agoI do not doubt that Huawei would not have hesitated to steal from Nortel, given an opportunity, but everything that I have read about the alleged theft from Nortel did not seem to indicate that Nortel really had something valuable to be stolen and there is little doubt that Nortel's doom was caused by their management and not by thieves. On the other hand, I know for a fact that Huawei has entered the mobile phone market by buying, and not by stealing, all the required technology and know-how from various companies, e.g. from Siemens. Like other Chinese companies activating in various domains, after being taught well how to duplicate Western designs, Huawei was able to make them both better and cheaper, so the companies which have foolishly sold their smartphone technologies to Huawei have exited the market, while Huawei would have become the dominant producer, had it not been sabotaged by USA in order to prevent that. Those who believe that the only reason that explains the commercial successes of the Chinese is IP theft are delusional. Obviously they have started by copying whenever they could do that, but in recent years the Chinese companies have been much more innovative than most US companies, which are too risk-averse and too much oriented only towards corporate customers or towards very rich customers, to be able to launch any really innovative product.
- Nokinside 4y agoGlobal semiconductor industry has the deepest and widest value chain compared to any other industry. China must replicate very specialized industries spread across the US, Europe, Japan, South Korea. >How the big Chinese manufacturing hubs like Shenzhen work. 99.9% of Shenzhen is relatively low value added on top of core technologies. They bring high value added tooling from South Korea, Japan, Taiwan, buy chips from Taiwan and assemble them into products.
- nyokodo 4y ago> But what I do know is China is ~1 billion people China built its massive manufacturing industry on vast quantities of cheap labor and a massive global consumer base. However, Chinese labor costs have been rising sharply for the past decade for many reasons but one major factor is that the one child policy was very successful and lead to a drastic hollowing out of their younger workforce and consumer base. Meanwhile the older experienced generation are aging out and China is entering a demographic winter which will lead to a 50-60% decline in population by mid to late century depending on whose numbers you trust. There is a similar hollowing out of the consumer base occurring all over the world with few exceptions. So it is highly improbable that China can fill in the most complex high tech supply chains by itself quickly enough to be useful while its workforce dwindles, it’s losing markets to sell to, and while its major trading partners are actively trying to thwart its progress.
- ianai 4y agoVery well said. And it doesn’t have to be this way. America would take a much different stance if the Chinese system were less “malignant”. Live and let live. Like the Japanese, Australia, UK etc.
- nyokodo 4y ago> if the Chinese system were less “malignant” China is a country with so much racial, linguistic, and geographical diversity that it would likely break up if it were less draconian. Historically this has occurred repeatedly. This is likely to happen anyway sometime over the next few decades given the geopolitical and demographic headwinds and in a much more devastating manner than it otherwise would, but it shouldn’t be surprising that the CCP won’t lie down and accept it.
- Throwawayaerlei 4y agoCan't speak for ianai but when he said "malignant" that should certainly include its policies towards its neighbors and the rest of the world. "Wolf Warrior" diplomacy is pretty iconic in representing that, but note how the CCP has managed to get so many of its neighbors to ally with Japan of all nations. After the horrors of occupation by Imperial Japan which are still an issue in South Korea for example. Where Japan's replies including a licencing regime for several classes of specialty chemicals used in IC fabrication. The world also cares very much what happens with Taiwan if that results in one way or another it no longer exporting chips. That island also makes quite a bit of higher end stuff for many nations' and companies' supply chains, as well as finished goods.