3 ms·
I worry this will be socialised as a wonder drug, when it may, like gastric banding wind up a phenomenally useful tool but one with caveats. Banding works. But
by ggm 4y ago
I worry this will be socialised as a wonder drug, when it may, like gastric banding wind up a phenomenally useful tool but one with caveats. Banding works. But it also can be thwarted by behaviour.
20% is huge. I have managed to reduce my longterm weight over a five to ten year period by 10% to 15% at best and have persisting issues in closing out some lingering weight. My partner is on near to starvation diet, concerned about micronutrients and bone loss and cannot shift weight easily on her current metabolism and activity levels, and we're both old and constrained for other reasons in exercise. We're in the overweight camp not obese or morbidly obese camp but would love not to be.
I do not want to be on a drug for weightloss but at a cost of some gastro intestinal discomfort for a window in time, to make a quantum leap down (and 20% is a significant amount) with consequent upsides to metabolic syndrome, fatty liver, hypertension, I would think about it.
- pedalpete 4y agoI agree, what are the implications of a drug like this on how people treat their bodies? Hopefully it's seen as a "one-time" treatment, and paired with improved exercise and eating habits, but I somehow doubt that will be the result.
- phnofive 4y agoI hope it's temporary too - the study was over a year of weekly self-injections, with some patients continuing to three years.
- jjeaff 4y agoI think it would depend on the long term metabolic results. Better diet and exercise almost always can make a difference, but the problem with large amounts of weight loss is the level of changes needed to maintain said weight loss. The long term study on "The Biggest Loser" contestants has some interesting insights into this where contestants who lost lots of weight had slower metabolisms than other people in their same weight classes even years after losing the weight, whether they gained it all back or not. In other words, a 150lbs person who never had to lose a lot of weight actually can eat more and work out less than a 150lbs person that lost 150lbs 5 years ago. Also, the resting burn rate was still lower in the contestants. It's just a recipe for long term failure if your metabolism doesn't adjust and reset after weight loss.