3 ms·
Is there an article with more substance? Like what data is collected, stored, etc in Incognito?
by giantg2 4y ago
Is there an article with more substance? Like what data is collected, stored, etc in Incognito?
- tootie 4y agoI've seen a few articles off this site and they seem to be clickbait and very lacking in substance. I think there's some general misunderstanding about what private browsing can and can't do. It works as expected in that it's a sandbox for cookies and browser history. It's incognito from the POV of a desktop app. It's not a cloak of invisibility.
- gernb 4y agoNone. The issue is websites still collect data. Like the website knows your ip address, your time zone, and the website can fingerprint to some extent. That includes Google.com, not via Chrome when in incognito mode, but via the fact that you access Google's websites. They don't know it's you directly.
- zeven7 4y agoIf that's all it is, then in my opinion the article is misleading. That's exactly how I always assumed incognito mode worked. And although I recognize it might not be how an average consumer understands it, it is what I think most people familiar with web tech would understand. The article makes it sound like they're doing more than that.
- Maursault 4y ago> That's exactly how I always assumed incognito mode worked. All that incognito mode does is delete those session cookies when you close that tab or window.[1] If you want to avoid being tracked, turn off cookies altogether (or use a plugin that blocks trackers), turn off JavaScript (or use a noscript plugin), and use a VPN. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_browsing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_browsing
- insanitybit 4y agoIncognito supports blocking 3rd party cookies, you just toggle a switch on the new tab page.
- aeternum 4y agoThe problem is that the API layer of the browser is now so complex that even without cookies, just your config yields a completely unique signature whether or not you're in incognito. This site gives you the details: https://amiunique.org/fp https://amiunique.org/fp Basically unless you use a completely different computer for incognito browsing, any site you visit can link your logged-in identity to your browser fingerprint and then track you regardless of mode/cookies.
- Spivak 4y agoAnd this isn’t theoretical, your fingerprint is stable between normal and private browsing mode on the same browser.
- npteljes 4y agoMy fingerprint varied from session to session to this website. So it's not easily demonstrable.
- aeternum 4y agoDid you look at the actual fields that diffed compared to what doesn't? It's likely only things like referrer and device groupIDs which are easily excluded if the goal is to track a user across browser modes.
- npteljes 4y agoI didn't, but if it's trivial to ignore those fields, then why isn't the proof of concept doing that? I think because you don't know, in advance, which fields to ignore. Demonstrating tracking like that is the point of the page, and it failed to do so, so my conclusion is that it's not that straightforward after all.
- ryandrake 4y agoThe fact that a web site can query all those things in that site is utterly ridiculous. Web technology is out of control.
- tomComb 4y agoGood question in a way, but I think the answer is that the article misrepresents the issue in order to pander better. The issue is that incognito mode is only for the browser itself - they can’t force the sites/services you use while in incognito mode to change what they do.
- dredmorbius 4y agoThe Bloomberg article sourced and linked at the end of the submitted piece ... has slightly more detail: <https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-10-11/google-s-incognito-inspires-staff-jokes-and-a-big-lawsuit https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-10-11/google-s-...> Paywall / regwall: <https://archive.ph/jJQfq https://archive.ph/jJQfq>