5 ms·
It always has been and always will be the people in power who do the canceling. And they've been canceling people for various reasons before Twitter even existe
by lapcat 4y ago
It always has been and always will be the people in power who do the canceling. And they've been canceling people for various reasons before Twitter even existed.
You can go back to the McCarthy era, where people were blacklisted for allegedly being Communist sympathizers.
A "Twitter mob" has no power to fire someone, cancel contracts, or do anything other than tweet. If the people who are in power cave to pressure from a bunch random people on Twitter, that's on the powerful, not on the otherwise powerless tweeters.
Cowardly people in power would rather throw their colleagues under the bus than experience any bad PR whatsoever. Is that the fault of Twitter? No. Would that problem be solved by shutting down Twitter? No.
> It’s very difficult people to fight alone, or take risks alone, but having the backing of an organization or legal fund can make a big difference.
But they could easily fight it if they had the backing of their own employer, for example, who would be the very organization that's officially doing the "canceling".
- Kamq 4y ago> If the people who are in power cave to pressure from a bunch random people on Twitter, that's on the powerful, not on the otherwise powerless tweeters. I feel like you can't call a group that can get "the people in power to cave" as powerless. That is power.
- lapcat 4y ago> I feel like you can't call a group that can get "the people in power to cave" as powerless. That is power. But it only works if the authorities are fearful, conflict-averse ass coverers. If the authorities ignore Twitter, then Twitter has no power. It's not like the "Twitter mobs" have guns, or even literal pitchforks. If they don't get want they want, all they can do is whine some more on Twitter.
- onos 4y agoI agree, but the situation is that the people leading our institutions are self interested, weak, and not omniscient. And that means the Twitter mobs do have power and they often use this destructively. The question then is: Given that our authorities are weak, and the mob is causing us real problems, what should we do about it?
- tgv 4y ago> But it only works if X is fearful Yeah, that's power. It doesn't matter that you call them "authorities". If they cower in fear, it's because someone else has the power. > all they can do is whine some more on Twitter. And all Putin does is sign decrees and drop a few hints. Perhaps press a button.
- lapcat 4y ago> And all Putin does is sign decrees and drop a few hints. Perhaps press a button. Putin is the President of Russia. You can't seriously compare him to anonymous people on Twitter. If Twitter was so powerful, then Putin would have resigned by now.
- tgv 4y agoTwitter holds very little power over Putin, but imagine the twitterati had been supporting Russia from the start, pumping out the Nazi smear, or repeating the "not our war" mantra. Support in the West might have been weaker. You can see it in Germany, where the chancellor was very slow, for fear of his constituents (and in case you need me to spell it out: many see Twitter as indicative of voting trends). No matter how stupid it is: as long as enough people care about the opinion on twitter, in particular people with power themselves, the twitter crowd has power. Russia understands that too, given their troll army.
- lapcat 4y ago> imagine the twitterati had been supporting I'm not sure what you mean by that. Twitter is a just a bunch of people. (According to Twitter, there are over 200 million mDAU) Anyone with a device that can connect to the internet can sign up for Twitter, if they want. It's not an organized special interest group. So you're imaging that the opinion of a bunch of people had been different. Which, yes, would have made things different, but I'm not sure this thought experiment is very useful. > many see Twitter as indicative of voting trends > No matter how stupid it is But it does matter how stupid it is. I was trying to point out that stupid and cowardly leaders are actually the problem and always have been the problem. You could abolish Twitter, but the problem of stupid and cowardly leaders won't magically go away. We're letting the leaders off the hook by blaming the "Twitter mobs" for their behavior. I believe this is the opposite of what we should be doing. > Russia understands that too, given their troll army. Well, their troll army doesn't seem particularly successful. Even less so than their real army.
- awb 4y agoThey have no power outside that which is given to them is the point. If random people want to cancel waffles, they are powerless to do so. It’s only when someone who actually has the power to cancel waffles decides to cancel them does it happen. The mob can only influence these powers that be.
- RHSeeger 4y agoConsider the case where millions of people are convinced, influenced by a swarm of people on twitter, that someone in your company should be fired. Those millions of people are an impactful portion of your customer base. You can either do what they want you to do or lose a lot of money; perhaps enough to impact the viability/health of your company. At that point, it's not unreasonable to back down and fire the person, regardless of your own opinion on the subject. Sure, you can stand up to it and keep them around; but is it reasonable to risk it? To risk the jobs of the other people are your company? An army isn't powerful because there's one powerful person at the top. An army is powerful because there are many people at the bottom, and they are organized to act as a single force.
- lapcat 4y ago> Consider the case where millions of people are convinced, influenced by a swarm of people on twitter, that someone in your company should be fired. Is this a real case though? It seems like only a counterfactual hypothetical. In most cases, millions of people are not going to feel as strongly about something as the minority of people tweeting. If the people tweeting about it even feel strongly; it's easy to tweet about something, but writing a tweet doesn't necessarily represent a powerful and lasting dedication to a cause. These incidents tend to be fleeting.
- vinyl7 4y agoIs it real? Probably not, but that is how organization perceives it. An angry mob on twitter sure does make it look like you'd lose a lot a business by not capitulating, even though chances are 90% of those people probably never were customers in the first place. It doesn't have to be a real threat for it to be perceived as a real threat.
- dsr_ 4y agoIt's pretty likely that Gandhi's nonviolence strategy would have failed against the Nazis. It almost failed against the British. Convincing people in power that they they should act isn't power itself.
- zozbot234 4y agoThat's power against some random netizen who has made themselves a target somehow, which is really not that much power at all. It's more of a Dark Forest pattern, where the optimal response is to lay low and/or conceal yourself if you're going to do anything remotely controversial.
- mc32 4y agoThe power is in the medium. If the "mobs" didn't have the megaphone, then they would be the tree that fell in a remote forest where no-one was present to hear it. If Twitter et all did not magnify agitators, this would be much less of an issue. It's a power with useful idiots doing the heavy lifting and those in power with a ready excuse to do the will of the people. Yes, on occasion, some of those in who think they are in power have to be thrown under the bus.
- voakbasda 4y agoThe mob may start on Twitter, but it goes offline. They can call your work, boss, friends, and other to harass them. No one “powerful” can stand up to a mob for long. When faced with an unstoppable force, no one will be your immovable object. Everyone you think cares about you will eventually cave in and throw you under the bus.
- klyrs 4y ago> No one “powerful” can stand up to a mob for long. Interesting theory, but how does it match reality? Donald Trump, Joe Rogan, JK Rowling, Dave Chapelle, Louis CK... these are powerful but "cancelled" people. Why aren't they out of the public sphere despite years of "the mob" being against them?
- dahart 4y agoNobody claimed tweets directly fire people, the whole point was that they influence other people. What is “power”? It’s influence over other people. The author wasn’t necessarily talking about jobs either, they were also talking about losing friends and suffering social stigma in local social spheres, which your comment doesn’t even remotely address. Nobody’s confused about how getting fired works or who’s doing the firing, but it’s incorrect to assert that the boss is always caving to pressure, throwing anyone under the bus, or avoiding bad PR. Many of the celebrities recently cancelled admitted to and apologized for sexual harassment, they lost their sponsorships, advertisers, and jobs, because the information spread about them was true. The point your comment is willfully ignoring is that information, rumors, truths, and lies, are what Twitter and other online media spread, and that this information influences others. We can spread true and false information faster than McCarthy’s day or any time in history. We have mountains of evidence that sometimes information goes viral and causes damage to people, sometimes to people in power, sometimes to businesses, and sometimes to democracies. Claiming that Twitter (and by extension other social media) has no power is to be willfully blind to what’s happening.
- lapcat 4y ago> The author wasn’t necessarily talking about jobs either, they were also talking about losing friends and suffering social stigma in local social spheres, which your comment doesn’t even remotely address. I don't address it because "cancellation" is normally understood as losing professional and financial opportunities due to personal opinions and actions, whereas losing friends due to personal opinions and actions is not really worth noting as a phenomenon. Friendship is inherently personal. > Claiming that Twitter (and by extension other social media) has no power is to be willfully blind to what’s happening. Of course Twitter has the power to spread information, and misinformation. But what people do with that information or misinformation is an entirely different matter. It ought to go without saying that one shouldn't uncritically believe everything one reads on Twitter.
- dahart 4y agoFalse. This distinction you’re trying to make between personal and professional does not exist with cancellation (and even if it did, which it doesn’t, you’re ignoring an absolutely massive gray area of ‘work friends’). Your personal definition of cancellation does not match what is “normally” understood nor what is documented https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cancel_culture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cancel_culture I don’t understand why you think saying that people shouldn’t believe everything they read is helpful. Yeah, obviously, and who ever disagreed? That’s a straw man and we still have a reality where social media is a powerful force for both good and harm. We still have rampant lies, bullying, climate misinformation, and Qanon. The evidence we have contradicts the claims made in your comments that social media isn’t powerful or that only people in power are doing the cancelling.