14 ms·
Everyone going to World Cup must have this app, experts are sounding the alarm
- aaronbrethorst 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- edf13 4y agoA fair bit of fear mongering and false news here… almost all of these permissions are not possible on an iPhone / and likely not even possible on modern android!
- soft_dev_person 4y agoAndroid and iOS have almost equal market share in Norway. Worldwide Android is a lot bigger (~70%). This affects most people, just not in the US.
- bnt 4y agoYou can’t grant access on iOS “to view / edit / delete all/any data”, that’s physically not possible, even with the hidden SDKs that only select parties have access to.
- robswc 4y agoAre you talking about secret government back door stuff? Not into phones but that sounds interesting, lol
- bnt 4y agoI’m not aware of any government back door access, but carriers that I worked with had access to all sorts of crazy hidden SDKs within iOS. For transparency, last time I worked on those was 5-6 years ago, so things may have changed.
- robswc 4y agoStill really interesting. Thanks for sharing. I heard of a software called Pegasus but couldn't tell if it was legitimately that powerful.
- soft_dev_person 4y agoGood for the 24% of users, then. It doesn't change the fact that tracking your detailed location and who you are around in combination can be used to determine your affiliations or sexual orientation. If you, with your secure iPhone, are located around numerous people with Grindr installed, they may jump to conclusions. They are capable of targeting gays or political opponents with this, which is the point of the story.
- josephcsible 4y agoDoesn't Apple's MDM allow that?
- kergonath 4y agoSomething close to that, AFAIK. But then, it’s not “go download this app from the store”. More like “we steal your phone, jailbreak it, and now we can see everything”. Not sustainable at scale.
- josephcsible 4y agoYou don't need to jailbreak a phone to set up MDM on it.
- kergonath 4y agoYou do if you don’t want to need the cooperation of the people in question.
- josephcsible 4y agoQatar doesn't mind needing the cooperation of the people in question, since they can put you in jail or deport you if you don't cooperate.
- afiori 4y agoYep lucky us 30% of smartphones holders are safe; nothing to see here.
- zppln 4y agoI doubt this is gonna stop anyone with a ticket from going.
- null_object 4y ago> access to read, delete or change all content on the phone The article is pure fiction, as no app has any possibility of ever being granted those permissions on iOS. No such capability even exists for any app on an iPhone.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- azinman2 4y agoAndroid
- integricho 4y agowhat is with you people thinking like nothing else other than Apple products exist?
- null_object 4y ago> what is with you people thinking like nothing else other than Apple products exist? I was addressing the specific claim that “everyone” had to give these permissions.
- afiori 4y agoCan they ask for read/write permissions on dozens of folders? I have no idea I never got interested in iphones.
- kergonath 4y agoThey can ask for access to their own directory on iCloud, or arbitrary files on the iCloud Drive. They cannot ask for access to other directories than their own on the device, sandboxing is rather strict. It’s still not ideal; mobile platforms are not designed to protect you from state actors.
- bigbacaloa 4y agoA small minority of mobile devices are iphones .... Most of the world uses Android devices manufactured in China.
- wslh 4y ago> Security experts believe Qatar's required mobile app will be like giving the World Cup country's authorities the key to your house. Qatar would be just a small player in this field. Other security agencies and security incumbents are surely having fun with the app. Prepare for a world cup full of advisories.
- bdg 4y agoWith the high churn of devices and increasing privacy intrusion, there's probably a small market for burner phones that will re-emerge just for apps in the next years.
- kuboble 4y agoEven using a burner phone doesn't fix the situation if you're still required to have the said phone with you all the time and it can't be turned off, it tracks your location, other phones you meet with etc.
- quickthrower2 4y agoLinked to your ticket too!
- Ekaros 4y agoWhat lovely world us all software developers have build. Everything online or as digital application on your phone. Maybe we should really have stopped at some point to think should we instead of could we...
- bdg 4y agoI was thinking more about before/after the event to avoid it reaching to more details about your private life outside of that specific timespan, text messages, whatever tictoc harvests these days, etc.
- viksit 4y agothis is going to disproportionately affect people in the global south - there aren't data privacy laws that google and apple need to stick to. suddenly, any group that is not politically favorable in a country is going to be a target. HN can't hide behind the argument that this doesn't affect iOS. thats a very elitist argument. the majority of the world uses android.
- aaronbrethorst 4y agoHN can't hide behind the argument that this doesn't affect iOS. thats a very elitist argument My point was that this is an indictment of the Android ecosystem, not a snooty nod to why everyone should use iPhones.
- tinus_hn 4y agoIt’s perfectly fair to point out that Apples approach, which HackerNews loves to whine about, prevents exactly this kind of spyware.
- fy20 4y agoThis is really no different than what other countries do, e.g. US border officials extensively questioning foreigners or asking for usernames and passwords for social media. As a visitor you have to abide by the law of the country, which may be different from your own country, and whose interpretation may be stretched by border control at the point of entry. The only difference here is that they were able to build an app to do all the tracking in plain sight. I'm sure governments in the US and Europe would love to be able to force all visitors to install a similar app.
- revolutukr 4y ago> The only difference here is that they were able to build an app to do all the tracking in plain sight. I'm sure governments in the US and Europe would love to be able to force all visitors to install a similar app. Yet, we do not because unlike in Qatar, the UAE and other religious dictatorships, we are a democracy and we have the ability to change our government. You can do better than whatbouatism.
- curiousgal 4y ago
- revolutukr 4y agoThere is no way to answer your trolling without a significant amount of sarcasm. Good day to you.
- curiousgal 4y agoThe US is a flawed democracy[0]. You're acting like the US invented democracy and is a champion of freedom and acceptance which is confidently wrong. Try growing up as a gay kid in the bible belt. It won't be so different from doing so in Qatar. 0.https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index
- TekMol 4y agoIs it still not possible to allow an app read/write access to only a single directory on Android? Ony all directories or none? From a quick check on my Android, that seems to be the case. How archaic. Why is it this way?
- josephcsible 4y agoIt is possible, with Scoped Storage. The problem is that apps know when they've been denied permissions, so it will indicate that, and then you'll be either refused entry or thrown in jail.
- happymellon 4y agoWasn't that a feature of Lineage? It never "denied" access, it just claimed that it didn't exist, or there was a fault so apps never actually knew they were blocked.
- fabian2k 4y agoThe permissions mentioned sound like someone that doesn't understand the permissions systems used by Android and iPhone tried to translate them. So this part of the article is almost useless as it is hard to figure out what permissions the app actually has. I don't understand the Android permissions system well enough here, but I would be especially curious about which API version this is targeting as I don't know how far back you can still go currently to avoid some of the stricter file access permissions newer versions added. As far as I can tell the most problematic storage-related permission in modern Android would be "MANAGE_EXTERNAL_STORAGE" meant for apps like file browsers. And if the app actually requests this permission (or intentionally uses an older API level to get equivalent access) that would be a very clear and specific overreach. But I would also not be surprised at all if this kind of app asks for excessive permissions, and then provides a lot of telemetry and analytics and sends them somewhere. And in a country where e.g. homosexuality is illegal this kind of stuff presents additional dangers beyond compromising your privacy.
- curiousgal 4y ago
- fabian2k 4y agoMy point was that in countries that make private, consensual activities against the law there are much more severe consequences possible for events that compromise your privacy.
- curiousgal 4y ago
- jl6 4y agoA more likely scenario which mirrors how discriminatory laws work elsewhere: 1. Get arrested for a minor offence like speeding. 2. Law enforcement checks your app and infers you are gay (maybe wedding photos of you and your spouse?) 3. It was going to be just a fine, but now you are facing prosecution for the much more serious offence of being gay. 4. Law enforcement officer can make the charges disappear for the right fee, or maybe just decides to go ahead with the much more serious prosecution. 5. Let’s hope you’re not gay and Muslim, because you’re then facing the death penalty too.
- robswc 4y agoWhat if you don’t have a smart phone? Or hell, what about one that’s 5+ years old? Are they just SoL?
- dagw 4y agoMost likely you are SoL. By the sounds of it they simply won't let you into the country unless you can show that you've installed their covid tracking app
- bongoman37 4y ago
- robswc 4y agoWow. Just pretty insane we're at that point. I have a smart phone and generally against telling people how to host their events... but requiring smart phones with tracking apps on them to do X or Y for the "pursuit of progress" is pretty dystopian.
- vaylian 4y agowhat is SoL? > What if you don’t have a smart phone? Remember, that you want something from them (entering the country). They can refuse you if they don't like your old-fashioned lifestyle.
- evanb 4y ago"Shit outta luck"
- aaaaaaaaaaaaab 4y agoSol is the star of the Solar system, the home system of the human species. On a more serious note: “Shit/Sorry, Outta Luck!”
- mnw21cam 4y agoSoldier Out of Luck.
- incompatible 4y agoWouldn't an easy work-around be to get a cheap new Android phone? I assume you only have to install the apps on one device, if you take two; otherwise, just take the new one. I doubt that the expense would be an issue for somebody attending the World Cup. It seems like this would be good practice these days for any international travel.
- ryandrake 4y agoI wonder if I can even find one technical sentence in the article that even makes sense. It is a total mess. There are so many “what about” questions here. What about people who don’t own/carry a smartphone? What about just denying all requested permissions? What about installing the apps then deleting them once you are in the stadium? Or as you say have a burner phone that you leave off? So silly.
- rwmj 4y agoWhen I went to China I got a phone to run WeChat, which I erased and reinstalled once I got back. Android phones are cheap now, you can get something which is quite decent for a couple hundred dollars.
- happymellon 4y agoAs long as it runs WeChat, does it need to be decent? Probably being bad is a feature here, because you won't be tempted to use the phone that's infected.
- beAbU 4y agoCut that by a factor of 10. If you need do be connected, but don't care about things like cameras or gaming specks, then I can get you an android phone for the equivalent of about $30. This is cheap enough to throw in the trash as you board for your flight home. Connectivity is a slightly larger problem. In some places you can get a prepaid SIM card for less than a dollar, other places need some form of registration. Really depends on the country and local laws. It's probably possible to go SIM-less and just hop between open hotspots.
- zetaposter 4y ago- Sir, you have to install this application, it's available on both iOS and the Google Play Store. - Do you have a Debian package? - I beg your pardon? - My Pinephone runs a modified version of Debian, the Universal Operating System. - ... What is that? - Oh fine. I'll settle for a Flatpack then. - I'm not sure I follow. -Does Qatar's Law require me to have an Android phone xor an iPhone? - No ... ? - Well your Law specification is incomplete and buggy. you get arrested for obstruction of justice
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoIt is certainly unsettling how laws will blindly introduce a dependency on Google or Apple
- BHSPitMonkey 4y agoThis is the aspect of Qatari law that stands out to you as unsettling?
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoI didn't realize subthreads weren't allowed to isolate subcontexts and discuss them. Are the other 50+ comments not enough to satisfy you?
- hulitu 4y agoQatar is our friend. Qatar is a democracy.
- aaaaaaaaaaaaab 4y agoN…not quite. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics_of_Qatar https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics_of_Qatar
- poorlyknit 4y agoBut they said they're friendly :)
- ghostDancer 4y agoAll the news about slavery and bad treatment of workers to build the infrastructures and silencing or minimizing by western press and now this. No surprise when you organize a thing like the Football World Cup in a dictatorship like Qatar in exchange for money this is you can expect. Just let's hope it does not get used as a backdoor by other with even worse intentions.
- decaffjoe 4y agoJust to emphasize your point, we're talking about a death toll of 6k+ people to build these stadiums. What a stain on fifa, football and worldwide respect for human rights to say the least. https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2021/feb/23/revealed-migrant-worker-deaths-qatar-fifa-world-cup-2022 https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2021/feb/23/r...
- seventhtiger 4y agoThat article itself contradicts its own spin. It reads more like a hit job. "More than 6,500 migrant workers from India, Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka have died in Qatar since it won the right to host the World Cup 10 years ago" "death records are not categorised by occupation or place of work" "There have been 37 deaths among workers directly linked to construction of World Cup stadiums, of which 34 are classified as “non-work related” by the event’s organising committee." "its 2 million-strong migrant workforce" 6500 deaths in a 10 year span, out of a 2 million demographic. Only 37 of those 6000 were workers actually linked to the construction of the stadiums. Only 3 of those are confirmed to be dead on site.
- ghostDancer 4y ago"Classified as “non-work related” by the event’s organizing committee", I guess the same committee that bribed FIFA[1] and from the same government that has not really high values for human rights and much less for the rights of immigrant labor force. And no autopsies allowed to investigate deaths even. And there are much more reports about deaths[2] just search around the web . But We know that money washes everything away . [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_FIFA_corruption_case#Historical_events_leading_to_the_arrests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_FIFA_corruption_case#Hist... [2]https://sports.yahoo.com/news/14-reasons-qatar-world-cup-174400894.html https://sports.yahoo.com/news/14-reasons-qatar-world-cup-174...
- yosito 4y agoIt seems like owning an iPhone is a good way to protect yourself from a lot of this. But if you're an Android user, couldn't you buy a burner phone for these two apps, to avoid installing them on your primary phone? I don't think I would trust a device that ever had these apps installed.
- vgg222 4y agoYou can track location in iPhone too, so that's no different. The only permission that is problematic is the storage access one, but that too has been addressed in later Android versions with scoped storage.
- asah 4y agoEveryone going to the world cup can afford a burner phone.
- aaaaaaaaaaaaab 4y agoYay! More e-waste!
- lucasfcosta 4y agoAt this point I think everyone should probably buy a disposable phone for installing this type of app.
- reactspa 4y agoI wish the "experts" were also sounding alarms about required face-scanning when I am trying to board an airplane in the West?
- lisper 4y agoThis is the reason that when I travel I carry two phones. One is the phone I actually use, and the other is the one I give to authorities when they ask for my phone. It is astonishing to me that not once have I ever been asked if I have a second phone. (It will be an interesting experiment to see if that happens now that I have posted this here.)
- worstestes 4y agoWhere do authorities ask for your phone? Just curious
- nixcraft 4y agoIt happens everywhere, from the developed countries to the far east. You have zero rights when crossing the border at immigration control, especially when your passport is weak or they believe you will not leave the country. They log into your IG and WhatsApp and check everything. Otherwise, they will deny entry. They made it legal. Sometimes a person has nothing to hide but nerves first time traveller and gets sucked into that void too. Do you know the worst part? Once you unlock your phone and give them your passcode, they take it away and tell you to wait. So now have no idea what they are doing with your phone. Would you trust that device? That is why a burner phone is needed, I guess.
- truemotive 4y agoI carry two phones just in case Nobody asks me for my second phone because nobody cares about brief interactions that distract them It happens everywhere from the developed countries to the far east (makes large sweeping gesture representing entire planet) you have zero rights crossing the border at immigration control in these awful countries I am continuing to not mention for some reason. Tell us where this happens.
- nl 4y ago> It happens everywhere, from the developed countries to the far east. It can happen everywhere, but I don't think it is frequent. I travel fairly frequently and I've never had it happen to me, or seen it happen to anyone around me, or personally know anyone it has happened to. It's true it happens, and you do read about it on the internet. But I think in every case I've read the person was already being questioned by immigration at a heightened level when it occurred.
- thread_id 4y agoIn general, when travelling internationally, it is just easier to leave your phone at home and buy a cheap phone with a prepaid plan when you get to country. This avoids all of the potential intrusions that come with passing through security and borders.
- aaaaaaaaaaaaab 4y agoExcept then you can’t take good quality photos of your vacation…
- tommek4077 4y agoIf only there would be a device that lets you take high-quality pictures. Maybe storing it on a SD card. Maybe you could even put a real flash on it, for pictures at night.
- lodovic 4y agoBut when your phone is inspected at the border, and you have only 2 days of chat history, no browser history, no call log, and no saved photos, won't that raise even more questions?
- vaylian 4y agoYou could answer: I just got a new phone 2 days ago, because my old one broke down.
- AnonCoward42 4y agoPermissions from Aurora Store (3rd party to Play Store): Hayya: - control vibration - have full network access - prevent phone from sleeping - run at startup - run foreground service - view Wi-Fi connections - view network connections - access sensor data at a high sampling rate - access approximate location only in the foreground - access precise location only the foreground - listen to C2DM messages Etheraz: - access bluetooth settings - control vibration - disable your screen lock - have full network access - pair with bluetooth devices - prevent phone from sleeping - run at startup - run foreground service - this app can appear on top of other apps - view Wi-Fi connections - view network connections - access approximate location only in the foreground - access precise location only the foreground - directly call phone numbers I don't think these are really that extraordinary, but some are not obvious to me at least. Especially "listen to C2DM" seems odd, possibly a side effect of another permission. Of course with these permissions you can track and trace most of your life, but that is now the norm unfortunately. > In particular, the covid-19 app Ehteraz asks for access to several rights on your mobile., like access to read, delete or change all content on the phone, as well as access to connect to WiFi and Bluetooth, override other apps and prevent the phone from switching off to sleep mode. The statement about delete/change all content on the phone seems false tho. Also it doesn't "override other apps" whatever that should mean, but can draw over other apps. edit:fix formatting
- flutas 4y ago"listen to C2DM" is for push notifications iirc
- AnonCoward42 4y agoC2DM was shutdown in 2015 (https://developers.google.com/android/c2dm/ https://developers.google.com/android/c2dm/)
- SpaghettiX 4y agoThis name (and GCM, google cloud messaging) still lingers inside packages and error messages when only Firebase Cloud Messaging (FCM) now exist.
- roebk 4y agoThis was the same situation for the UEFA Women’s Euros in England this year. For those wondering, the app was simply for storing, transferring, and displaying your tickets. A ticket being a QR code for you to scan at the stadium turnstiles. Was the app required? Absolutely not, there was nothing specific that the mobile app could do that a simple website couldn’t (apart from the screen brightness jumping to 100% when displaying the QR code). I’m sure even a printed QR code would of sufficed. Both UEFA and FIFA should reconsider their approach to ticketing.
- PaulRobinson 4y agoPaper tickets can be resold into the tout/scalper market. Electronic tickets can't. That's a nice feature for FIFA.
- omnimus 4y agoYou would be surprised how well app screenshot in full screen with the qr code works. Seen this many times with covid vaccination passes.
- vidarh 4y agoNo idea about this app, but presumably that's the reason why quite a few apps show animations and a rotating code word alongside the QR codes, so staff can easily spot that kind of thing.
- BoorishBears 4y agoDoesn't work for these tickets since they're generating new underlying values as time passes. Even Costco has self-modifying barcodes now, so covid vaccination passes are behind on the times.
- 8organicbits 4y agoIt seems like it adds a barrier, but wouldn't the scalpers just sell phones with the app and ticket loaded? Old Android phones are quite cheap.
- Ekaros 4y agoEvery country should have rights to control what enters their borders. Be it phones or people. Nothing unreasonable here considering the existing standards of border control around the world. Just next logical step to prevent terrorism and undesirable activities. Don't like it, don't go.
- jimbob45 4y agoYou’re gonna get downvoted but I don’t think you’re altogether wrong. If the World Cup gets hit by extremists, Qatar’s reputation will be hit harder than anything else. Who now blames anyone but Germany and its incompetence for Black September’s actions in the 1972 Munich Olympics?
- Mordisquitos 4y agoI have never heard anyone blame the 1972 Munich Olympics terrorist attack on the Federal Republic of Germany's lack of authoritarian state surveillance powers, their lack of motivation to keep track of the exact location of every foreign person in the country, nor on the fact that they did not require every single visitor to surrender the contents of all their personal documents for potential state scanning.
- EastSmith 4y ago> Don't like it, don't go. I am not going, but I guess players do not have this choice?
- Mordisquitos 4y ago
- polotics 4y agoSince Electronic Arts righteously dumped FIFA like a ton of rotten bricks, why don't they organise a football world cup instead? Less corruption money must mean more leftover for the players and staff involved. Also instead of some nebulous process for the host country selection, get game owners to vote, they're already very securely identified. The time to ride on the complete stink the air conditioned slave-labour edition will produce is now. Get your lawyers to review the contractual structure of leagues and clubs, it can't be that the whole international set of deals is failsafe, players can probably just walk.
- basicoperation 4y agoNo-one plays in the World Cup for the money.
- smcl 4y agoDon't know why you're getting downvoted, this is correct. There's maybe some bonuses and appearance fees for national teams ... but all the big names people care about earn their money playing for their club.
- sofixa 4y ago> Since Electronic Arts righteously dumped FIFA like a ton of rotten bricks It wasn't righteous, it was over money (FIFA asking for too much). > why don't they organise a football world cup instead Because FIFA is the organising body of football, all regional (UEFA, CONCACAF, etc.) and country Football Associations are under FIFA's jurisdiction (and are members of FIFA). Countries couldn't participate in a rival event even if they wanted to, because many of the smaller association basically only exist on FIFA subsidies, and of course there are exclusivity deals. And i doubt many countries and players would prefer the glory of the "EA Cup". The World Cup has never been about money, and the prize pool is already significant.
- polotics 4y agoDoes FIFA own a copyright on the word "football"? no Does shipping 20 players from 50 poorer countries cost a lot? no does FIFA even owns a copyright on the words "Football World Cup"?
- basicplus2 4y agoFree countries should shut down all travel including airlines in and out of Qatar, and issue a travel warning. In fact this should have happened years ago.. https://www.hrw.org/news/2020/10/27/women-reportedly-subjected-forced-gynecological-exams-qatar https://www.hrw.org/news/2020/10/27/women-reportedly-subject... Otherwise, what do we believe in? what do we stand for? Do we truly only car about money?
- Ekaros 4y agoDefine free country? I'm curious what level of protection and freedom qualifies for that designation.
- ThePowerOfFuet 4y agoIt's worth reading in full, but this is the perfect tl;dr: >NRK has submitted the findings about the apps' security holes to FIFA. They tell us that they do not wish to comment on the matter.
- hulitu 4y agoWell it's a little late, isn't it. You still have nothing to hide ?
- Gatsky 4y agoI really would like to know how Qatar got the World Cup… it can’t have been legitimate, it’s just got so many obvious disadvantages… For example, it’s too hot to host it in summer as usual, so it’s in the northern hemisphere winter, which interrupts all the leagues.
- throwaway4736 4y agoI’m sure you already know the answer.
- InCityDreams 4y ago...there's this thing called 'the dollar'.
- sofixa 4y agoBribes, some of which came out and are currently under investigation/prosecution. Other reasons why it's a terrible idea: they have a small population, little football culture (in terms of absolute size), no infrastructure (all the stadia are newly built and some will be demolished afterwards; there aren't enough hotels); they have many laws incompatible with what usually happens at World Cups. There literally isn't a single positive thing to be said about Qatar hosting the World Cup.
- JCharante 4y agoQatar has a pretty good airport with an extremely convenient location (more than 80% of the world population live within a 6 hour flight)
- sofixa 4y agoThat makes it a great airport hub, but it doesn't have the infrastructure to host, feed, transport, place in a stadium the hundreds of thousands of fans that want to watch a World Cup.
- tacker2000 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- raydiatian 4y agoI mean, I get “why”. But nonetheless this is having and eating cake at its best.
- kazinator 4y agoWhen it comes to IT-required mobile crapware: - Install it on a burner phone, not your real device. - Install it on an Android emulator (e.g. Nox Player) on a laptop PC.
- AndyMcConachie 4y agoThey employ slaves to build the stadiums. That's fine. THey make people install an app. OMG the humanity!
- jonplackett 4y agoSurly these permissions aren’t actually possible on iPhone? Apps can’t access other apps even with permission, or disable the lock screen etc.
- lodovic 4y agoI for one can't wait until this app is decompiled, so we can judge it on facts rather than rumours. It'd be interesting to see what techniques they employ and how far reaching their invasion of privacy is.
- kevincox 4y agoIt's also not possible on Android to access other apps' data. (even as a user which is frustrating). But it can ask for access to all common storage which usually contains images, downloads and some other stuff.
- vgg222 4y agoYou can track location in iPhone too, what's different?
- jonplackett 4y agoTracking location isn't what this is saying - it's saying you're giving them access to EVERYTHING on your phone - all the apps, all the data. Yeah, sharing location's not great, but you have to accept that if you're connecting to cell towers they pretty much know where you are all the time anyway.
- psychphysic 4y agoThere is certainly an issue with people being required to install government apps. And this is an interesting case of that but this is wildly overblown. I don't have to go to the world cup, it'll actually be really hard to go. I'd have to be desperate or wildly rich. But I do have to use several government apps on my phone even if just installing them for a brief period. That's the really issue. Installing an app on a luxury holiday in Qatar is such an absurd complaint given indebted servants bordering on our right slavery died organising it.
- truemotive 4y agoI don’t think they’re complaining, which leads me to believe that’s another reason for them to field test this and even just capture info on how many idiotrich leave the country with a rootkit on their phone.
- truemotive 4y agoWelp, great to know I can’t escape false equivalency attempts to dampen COVID as a threat even in an article about an extremely larger threat; I mean not to me, who cares, but Qatar World Cup sounds like you might need to be an important businessperson to be there… that needs their phone… and will forget they installed it. That shit cray.
- _int3_ 4y agoThis is really not about you "giving keys to your house" to Qatar. You already given keys of your house to Google and other parties, now they own your house and they don't like sharing it with Qatar.
- poorlyknit 4y agoWell nobody coerces you to use Google stuff or buy an Alexa etc.
- _int3_ 4y agoIn some cities (in western countries) you can't travel or do internet banking if you don't have the right app. Are you coerced? Yes you are. That is the same thing here. But you don't see "security experts" complaining.
- truemotive 4y agoI think this calls for an outrageous break with smartphone design, someone bold needs to design the voice only flat black slate with no instructions and requiring practice to master. Take that!
- jmyeet 4y agoFirst, this is further proof that the Apple iOS permission model is just better. There's no laundry list of permissions. You get asked for very few things and they're the things users care about (eg app running in background). Less is more. Very few people understand these laundry lists. Second, Qatar is one of those places that you should realize what you're getting into by going. It is a religious monarchy with essentially sharia law. Insulting the ruling family will get you in serious trouble. Drinking will get you in serious trouble. Homosexuality or even out-of-marriage sex will get you in serious trouble. There are lots of rules and the punishments are harsh. Personally I wouldn't go. If you do, you have to accept a bunch of things you wouldn't wherever you're from most likely.
- xani_ 4y agoWe need better app sandboxing on phones yesterday, with system call filtering so it would be possible to just fake the data app requests
- edmcnulty101 4y agoI have two phones, one for my personal shit and one for privacy intrusive shit like my work wants to install or this. Seems to be the best solution.
- mcv 4y agoIif you really need to be there, use a burner phone. Or just don't go. Keep in mind those stadiums were built by slaves. Do you want to support slavery?
- elif 4y agoLuckily my country is already so creepy this qatar thing is a fully non-issue for me. In fact, i wouldn't even have to know about the app before travelling to deal with this. ANY time I go through US airport security, I don't take my phone. I take a burner phone that doesn't have any of my accounts logged in or personal data on it. From my understanding, they can and will dd your whole phone image to some national security database while holding you for 'enhanced screening.'
- grepfru_it 4y ago>From my understanding, they can and will dd your whole phone image to some national security database while holding you for 'enhanced screening.' this is not true, maybe at customs but not when traveling domestically. i had a dog sit down while walking through security and TSA had to swab everything i was traveling with. my phone was swabbed but nothing was ever connected to it.
- elif 4y agoIt's the same TSA. You didn't have the appropriate database flag at the time. Those are explosives dogs, looking for explosives not selfies.
- colinsane 4y ago> This means that if you want to go to the WC, you have no choice. This is a mandatory app, with no options. it’s fashionable to make the case against tech by arguing the privacy angle. i sometimes wish we could raise the discussion one level of abstraction and speak about control more broadly (privacy being the control over which information you make public). you can make this app as private as you want, but i’d still be upset that its mandatory use is contradictory to my desire for agency.
- TheGigaChad 4y ago
- caseysoftware 4y agoAnd the fun thing is that once you grant these permissions, the app has them through all updates. So even if the current version of the app "doesn't do anything" the next version could do whatever it wants within those.
- sfvegandude 4y agoThe uncritical acceptance of Qatar as the next hot business location, like an area of the map unlocking on Civ, is a total catastrophe for the cause of human rights. The entire country should be boycott, not embraced.
- seba_dos1 4y agoA required app? Do they think that everyone uses Android or iOS on their smartphones, or even has a smartphone at all?
- justnotworthit 4y agoArticles/headlines on human rights issues in XYZ country bring out the brattiest comments in all of hackernews.
- greyhair 4y agoWhat if you show up to the games without a phone?