3 ms·
The hydrogen storage facility at Delta Utah has enough space in the salt formation for 100 caverns, each storing 150 GWh of energy. That's about 30 hours worth
by pfdietz 4y ago
The hydrogen storage facility at Delta Utah has enough space in the salt formation for 100 caverns, each storing 150 GWh of energy. That's about 30 hours worth (well, maybe less, if that 150 GWh is before conversion to electrical energy, but still this is just one location.)
- HyperSane 4y ago1) That doesn't actually exist yet. 2) You would need a huge number of generators to actually generate enough electricity to power the entire US.
- pfdietz 4y agoCombined cycle power plants cost about $1/W; simple cycle, about $0.50/W. Combustion turbines are cheap. A nuclear plant, $10/W. We could back up the entire damned grid with these things at a cost small compared to the cost of powering that grid with nuclear power plants. As for "not actually existing yet", that's not anything close to a valid argument. Also, hydrogen storage doesn't require anything new -- all the component technologies exist, they just have to be integrated. This is the easiest and surest kind of innovation. It would be nice if higher demand drive electrolysers down their experience curve some more, I will admit. Cheaper is always nice.
- HyperSane 4y ago"We could back up the entire damned grid with these things at a cost small compared to the cost of powering that grid with nuclear power plants." I really want this to be true, I just don't think it is.
- pfdietz 4y agoHow hard is it to compare the numbers "1" and "10"?
- Godel_unicode 4y agoSurprisingly hard if the confidence intervals are wide enough.
- pfdietz 4y agoThey're not? I mean, combined cycle plants have been built out the wazoo, so there's good data on that (replacing natural gas with hydrogen causes only minor changes, mostly in the combustor, and there are already industrial combustion turbines burning fuel gases that are mostly hydrogen.) Cost data on recent nuclear builds in the west are also widely available. I suppose you may be meaning there's no good upper bound on how bad the expected unexpected cost overruns in nuclear can be.
- HyperSane 4y agoI mean I don't have any confidence your numbers are correct.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pfdietz 4y agoThe cost of combustion turbine power plants is well established since so many have been built. The cost of nuclear plants built recently in the west is also readily available. Given that, it gives me pause that you don't actually know that information, given how eager you are to represent your "knowledge" on this subject.