3 ms·
> And they knew that the single greatest weapon of the war, the atomic bomb excepted, was the German 88-mm flat-trajectory gun, which brought down thousands of
by WalterBright 4y ago
> And they knew that the single greatest weapon of the war, the atomic bomb excepted, was the German 88-mm flat-trajectory gun, which brought down thousands of bombers and tens of thousands of soldiers.
I beg to differ. It was radar-guided anti-aircraft guns, and proximity fuzes for artillery shells. This had the effect of doubling the firepower.
Another was high-octane gasoline, which enabled much more powerful aircraft engines.
The Axis did not have these technologies.
- agumonkey 4y ago> proximity fuzes interesting, it's rarely mentioned indeed. Also I wonder if that was the reason for developping those flares scattered by planes ? or maybe that was only after the invention of guided missiles.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe Germans did use radar to detect, track, and guide forces to the targets. German night fighters had onboard radar for this, too. What the Germans didn't have, however, was connecting the radar directly to the weapon.
- pfdietz 4y agoThe effect of the proximity fuze on non-AA artillery was profound. The Germans certainly noticed when the fuzes were released for general use at the Battle of the Bulge. A similar fuze was also made available for use in bombs, but I don't know if that was used in Europe. It was used in the Pacific against airfields, late in the war.
- softcactus 4y ago> I beg to differ. It was radar-guided anti-aircraft guns The 8.8cm german flak gun WAS a radar-guided AA gun. > and proximity fuzes for artillery shells The axis may not have had proximity fuzes, but the 8.8cm flak was so accurate that during a statistical analysis it was determined that the part of the gun that introduced the most accuracy were the timed fuzes. They switched to shells that detonated on impact and actually ended up scoring more kills than before. The actual piece of equipment that made this thing so accurate was the fire control computer, the Kommandogerat 40. https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1UnrEetRYIuLoUT--ic0irCNXbCC7UcWf?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1UnrEetRYIuLoUT--ic0i... Here is a Google Drive link to some scans I made in college of the book written by the designer. It explains all the calculations that the analog computer is doing.
- WalterBright 4y agoThanks for the reference! It seems that not that many were built: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W%C3%BCrzburg_radar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W%C3%BCrzburg_radar
- softcactus 4y agoSorry I worded my previous response poorly. > The 8.8cm german flak gun WAS a radar-guided AA gun. The Kommandogerat 40 was a rangefinder/computer, not a radar. It had the capability of being radar-guided, but was not necessarily radar-guided by itself. For the Kommandogerat 40 you needed a direct line-of-sight (they were still used in overcast conditions though) but it would compensate for the velocity vector of the incoming targets, altitude, wind, and would relay fire controls to all the flak pieces in the battery. Not as nice as a radar, but it was able to be fielded in mass quantities, and I think it deserves its place as 2nd most devastating weapon of WWII. Especially since towards the end of the war, the Germans were the ones playing defense. It made the strategic bombing campaigns of the allies very painful. The RAF bomber crews had a 44% death rate. That's deaths, not casualties. It also excelled in direct fire roles against ground targets.
- WalterBright 4y agoI read that it took 16,000 88 flak shells to bring down one bomber. I infer the success of the flak was due simply to quantity. I've also read numerous times that the searchlights would find and "pin" a bomber so that the crews could dial in the coordinates for firing. Wouldn't need that with radar guided guns. I well know the death rate for B-17 crews - my father flew 32 missions in 1944 in one. The casualty rate was 80% (killed, wounded, POW). He told me that the way he dealt with it was simply accept that since he was going to die, he'd do the best job he could. I have the letter he wrote his father, dryly saying he'd completed his missions and would be coming home. The Bismarck was well equipped with anti-aircraft batteries, which failed to stop the torpedo attack by slow-moving, obsolete biplanes. The Japanese navy didn't have much success with anti-aircraft batteries, either. Regardless, the 88 was an excellent cannon.