4 ms·
Energy density is important for transport, I don't see how current limitations in that can be important for base-load. Cost, sure, but LiIon is already on par
by ben_w 4y ago
Energy density is important for transport, I don't see how current limitations in that can be important for base-load.
Cost, sure, but LiIon is already on par with nuclear in that regard despite not being the cheapest storage.
- algoatecorn 4y agoEnergy density is important for storage, which transport falls under.
- ben_w 4y agoContext of this thread is nuclear, which isn't useful for most forms of transport.
- algoatecorn 4y agoAren't you the one that brought up transportation? This is the most pedantic, exhausting thread I've ever seen on HN. So many surface level opinions that I feel like I'm on reddit
- ben_w 4y agoThe reason I brought transport up was to say that that transport, and not baseload, is the only situation in which density matters. You wrote: > It seems many in this thread don't appreciate the energy density requirements of modern baseload. Density does not matter for baseload. It is a red herring.
- DisjointedHunt 4y agoIt’s not one dimensional. Energy density can be both important for transportation and also be important for the ability to accelerate energy production without a proportional growth in mining/resource harvesting that harms the planet. A melon sized chunk of uranium powers an Aircraft carrier of the US navy for over 2 decades while it circumnavigates the globe hundreds of times, launching aircraft off its deck and powering remarkable levels of energy demand from on board systems. For comparison, a single trip around the pacific for a conventionally fueled aircraft carrier costs 125 MILLION GALLONS of fuel. It’s incredibly hard to wrap one’s head around what 20 years x 125 Million Gallons x Num_trips per year looks like.
- ben_w 4y ago> important for the ability to accelerate energy production without a proportional growth in mining/resource harvesting that harms the planet. I agree. > A melon sized chunk of uranium powers an Aircraft carrier of the US navy for over 2 decades … a single trip around the pacific for a conventionally fueled aircraft carrier costs 125 MILLION GALLONS of fuel. Are you sure you didn't add a few zeros in there? I think the real energy density difference there is about a million, but you're at least 200 times more than that, depending on Num_trips? (But yes, to the core point, transport is the one thing where energy density matters, and a nuclear powered aircraft carrier, or sub, is totally a thing where atomic power shines. Subs especially. Just that they're not a major part of the problem, and while this is a fun diversion I had been more interested in baseload here).
- Schroedingersat 4y ago> A melon sized chunk of uranium powers an Aircraft carrier of the US navy for over 2 decades while it circumnavigates the globe hundreds of times, launching aircraft off its deck and powering remarkable levels of energy demand from on board systems. And how much does a civilian nuclear reactor weigh? Even compare a solar panel (there are panels on the market that produce 50GJ/kg over their life, and it's almost all sand) to the fuel assembly plus a type A storage cask. Even if we accept your ridiculous premise, solar wins.
- ben_w 4y agoDepends on the details. For land use, as I said in my other comments, the energy density is a red herring — the mass (and the area) aren't what we're limited by anyway. For transport, the limits depend on the nature of the transport. Cars are fine with LiIon; aircraft can be fine with LiIon for a few hundred miles but not thousands; hydrogen from electrolysis can power aircraft or rockets but are a bad choice for submarines; PV in a spacecraft means an ion drive and not a launch, the higher specific impulse doesn't make up for the lower absolute thrust in that scenario; nuclear spacecraft would be great except everyone's terrified of it. But none of this matters either way with the power grid.
- 4y ago