4 ms·
> I don't want my wife, my children, or my neighbors to be burdened with thinking of something so horrible. Interesting. Until very recently, as far as I coul
by gumby 4y ago
> I don't want my wife, my children, or my neighbors to be burdened with thinking of something so horrible.
Interesting. Until very recently, as far as I could know, my mother's life began at 16. She refused to talk about anything from her childhood.
I don't know if, like you, she didn't want to traumatize us or simply didn't want to think about it at all. But now, in her late 80s, she'll sometimes absent-mindedly relate some story from her childhood. They are all kid stories, but the perspective in them can be hair raising. (She was a child in an occupied country during WWII in the pacific; then immediately as the war ended the country became a different war zone, so she only knew living in that kind of environment until she left the country to go to university).
Recently I've been thinking of this because of the Ukraine war. I have seen at close range the impact of a generation of kids (like my mother in law, and others in her village) who grew up in postwar Germany with essentially no adult men around. That whole generation is pretty screwed up, and their kids (my generation) also reflect that impact. While my personal opinion is that Germany is not doing anywhere near enough to help Ukraine, I think they should be preparing a for a huge postwar assistance, not just money for rebuilding, but psychological / therapy based on their experience to try to reduce the effects of wartime trauma on Ukraine.
- hutzlibu 4y ago"I think they should be preparing a for a huge postwar assistance, not just money for rebuilding, but psychological / therapy based on their experience to try to reduce the effects of wartime trauma on Ukraine. " We take lots of refugees. I would argue this is already a very effective way of preventing further traumatizing. But as far as I am aware, those who come do not easily get offered psychatric help, even if they already are traumatized. But the psychatric sector is pretty much operating on its limits anyway.
- gumby 4y agoBeing a refugee is traumatic on its own. But Germany has a lot of lessons (including what not to do) that it could be providing for good.
- usrusr 4y agoI don't think that Germany has many lessons: our hindsight about the first decades after the war time is completely dominated by the the topic of denazification, in all its twists and details, that everything else just happened without anybody really taking note.
- gumby 4y agoI can tell you it’s still a big issue in the Dörfer which were likely less subject to the denazification process. Our parents’ generation (those who were kids in the 30s & 40s) are mostly gone but those born in the 50s-70s are still around and many in therapy which was not common before. That is the pool to learn from. There is sadly no shortage of countries with large populations who suffered in war. But Germany is a large, wealthy country which is a good example of what Ukraine will face in postwar reconstruction. And yes, Germany still owes an old debt to Ukraine (instigation of war) as well as a contemporary one (holding off Russia with limited German assistance).
- Schiendelman 4y agoThe psychiatric sector should be quadrupled. More so in some countries. It’s flabbergasting to me that people don’t see it as - not just a moral imperative - but also an obvious economic one.
- chaostheory 4y agoWho’s going to pay for it? Health insurers are still trying to avoid it. https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2017/11/29/567264925/health-insurers-are-still-skimping-on-mental-health-coverage https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2017/11/29/5672649... https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2019/06/07/730404539/mental-health-parity-is-still-an-elusive-goal-in-u-s-insurance-coverage https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2019/06/07/7304045...
- gumby 4y agoThat’s like saying “who will pay for clean power” or “who will pay for firefighters?” or. “Who can afford to pay for safer building codes?” In the long term we all benefit.
- chaostheory 4y agoYes, but someone has to be willing to pay for it. I'm not wrong.
- dflock 4y agoIn a national/publicly funded national health system, that system (i.e., taxpayers) should fund it, because better mental health in the population will improve the economic performance of the nation, increasing tax receipts etc... That is, if they can get over that calvinist/puritan mental health == weakness/stigma thing, which seems to be slowly happening.
- chaostheory 4y agoI agree that it should be funded. I’m just pointing out that even places like Canada don’t fund it
- lispm 4y ago> While my personal opinion is that Germany is not doing anywhere near enough to help Ukraine, I think they should be preparing a for a huge postwar assistance Germany already hosts around one million refugees from Ukraine. The exact numer is difficult to say, since the EU has provided all Ukrainian refugees visa-free entry. Which is unprecedented. Most of them are women and children. The winter is coming. Providing them psychological help is important, but the sheer number of people from Ukraine (not speaking German) makes this very challenging. The Germans themselves also have the problem of finding psychological help, since the number of people needing it has been rising because of the pandemic, the war, the economic instability, etc.
- guenthert 4y ago> While my personal opinion is that Germany is not doing anywhere near enough to help Ukraine, I think they should be preparing a for a huge postwar assistance, not just money for rebuilding, but psychological / therapy based on their experience to try to reduce the effects of wartime trauma on Ukraine. Well, perhaps they should, but I'm not sure they can. My parents never mentioned any help regarding postwar trauma being available in Germany. Perhaps mental health issues weren't recognized as such then, perhaps they had other priorities. The first few years after the war "were difficult".
- gumby 4y ago> My parents never mentioned any help regarding postwar trauma being available in Germany. Yes, but it is now the 21st century.