4 ms·
This is a terrible take. First of all, the price of space launch is plummeting, making the cost of launching a fleet of sun shades drop like a rock. It may soon
by adastra22 4y ago
This is a terrible take. First of all, the price of space launch is plummeting, making the cost of launching a fleet of sun shades drop like a rock. It may soon be veeery affordable. Like, something Elon would do just for the kicks.
Second, there are distinct advantages to higher CO2 levels in the atmosphere. It makes agriculture grow more quickly, leading to higher food yields. And the greenhouse effect is mostly independent of latitude so places like Siberia and northern Canada become habitable while the tropics do not become so hot as to be unlivable. Raising the global temp by 2 degrees could double the amount of high quality arable land suitable for dense human habitation.
Third, instead of a sunshade we could use a larger translucent film which blocks UV-B light like sunglasses. Imagine a world without skin cancer!
- hoosieree 4y agoI'm not an expert but blocking UV-B may have some negative consequences.
- uoaei 4y agoImagine a world where bees can't see the centers of flowers.
- adastra22 4y agoBees see with UV-A light, not UV-B.
- uoaei 4y agoBees see with both. UV-A (320-350nm) and UV-B (290-320nm) both overlap with bee visual spectrum (300-650nm). Do you have data on which flowers in which geographical areas reflect with UV-A and/or UV-B? Maybe to bolster your argument you will need to prove that this won't affect bees, and pollinators more generally.
- adastra22 4y agoThe harmful UV-B rays are under 300nm, and that’s the cutoff for bee vision for the same basic biological reason. Below that limit is what you’d want to filter out.
- adastra22 4y agoIt does not. UV-B is ionizing radiation and is incapable of being used by biological processes as a source of energy. About the only effect it has on our biome is that it contributes to the production of ozone, and it is possible that filtering out UV-B might reduce (but not eliminate) the ozone layer. However the main/only benefit of the ozone layer is to filter out UV radiation, so... UV-B is like mosquitos, one of those rare things that really only does cause harm and can be safely eliminated if possible.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- standyro 4y agoImagine a world without skin cancer by launching giant space sails is like saying: imagine a world without white people. People have evolutionarily adapted to the sun by producing melanin in their skin, but for some reason aerospace is the only answer? Why the West (and frankly many on HN) seems so content on destroying the natural world for problems that only matter to a subset of rich people somehow still surprises and amazes me. There are distinct advantages to making the internet unlivable, so that insane comments like this don’t have to exist anymore.
- dylan604 4y ago>There are distinct advantages to making the internet unlivable, so that insane comments like this don’t have to exist anymore. I always imagine these kinds of things starting in a conversation of a bunch of stoners munching on Funyuns while chugging Mountain Dew. "Like, dude, it would be so cool, if like, we made a giant sun shade in space. That'd be so rad!" Only someone thought it sounded smart when heard from outside the circle which is the really sad part.
- adastra22 4y agoAt least one of us has worked in the aerospace field and has relevant domain knowledge to evaluate the feasibility of this idea. I'm gonna guess its not you.
- dylan604 4y agoWell that's just kind of dumb logic really, as if it were you, you wouldn't need to guess it was me now would you. Sometimes, smart people can be kind of not smart. Also, at least one of us can get a joke, and I'm guessing it's not you