4 ms·
Isn't this what people want through the world? Control and ban fake news. Defined as what those currently in power think. Also, only three years? Isn't that ve
by Ekaros 4y ago
Isn't this what people want through the world? Control and ban fake news. Defined as what those currently in power think.
Also, only three years? Isn't that very soft thinking how destructive fake news can be?
- wincy 4y ago
- FridayoLeary 4y agoI mean look at the twin fiascos of covid and Trump. People are all in favour of censorship when it suits them.
- pjc50 4y agoLetting your democracy and a large number of lives be taken away by easily disprovable lies isn't great either. I can't see a good way out of this; the libel suit against Alex Jones is just a tiny start at unwinding the problem. It's much more profitable, easier, and an effective route to power to lie.
- rhino369 4y agoBanning political dissent to save democracy is "destroy[ing] the village in order to save it."
- Nevermark 4y agoDissent is not the same as lying. In the worst case, people conflate the two to rationalize tolerance for having no repercussions for promoting damaging lies And there can be wide gray areas where people’s perspectives, literacy of facts, or motives are too different to make a clear judgement between disagreement and reckless or intentional faslehoods. But they are not the same
- rhino369 4y agoSure, but every government--even the generally good ones--accused dissents of lying even when they aren't. Was the Steele Report disinformation? Depends if ask you Donald Trump or the FBI. Was the Hunter biden laptop disinformation? Depends who you ask. Was "vaccines don't prevent covid" disinformation? Depends on when you ask the CDC. You could avoid a slippery slope by drawing the line at intentionally and knowingly telling a mistruth--that's essentially where US defamation laws draw the line. But that is almost never where the line is drawn. Under that definition of lying, Anti-vaxers aren't lying--they are just wrong. And on the slip side, when the government intentionally lies--masks don't work--its not disinformation--its a messaging technique.
- FridayoLeary 4y agoI'm not talking about "easily disprovable lies". I'm talking about simple stuff such as "do masks help" when even the supposed "scientific evidence" did a 180. Experts seem to overreach often beyond their fields of expertise.
- standardUser 4y agoDo you truly, genuinely think that is what people want, or are you constructing a straw man to beat up? Do you care to make a point, or are you just asking leading questions that create the illusion that you're making a point?
- Ekaros 4y agoThey are not on barricades when anyone is kicked out from social media platforms. As thus I'm fully sure that they support all types of censorship or at least those types advancing their own agendas.
- commandlinefan 4y ago> Do you truly, genuinely think that is what people want I can't honestly believe you don't think there are a lot of people who want that. They've been very up front about it.
- zaik 4y agoWho exactly? The most common argument is that platforms should have the right to refuse service to users, not that those users should be jailed.
- SamoyedFurFluff 4y agoI think it genuinely depends on how extreme the speech is. Alex Jones arguably profited by spreading lies knowing it would ruin the lives of specific people who already had tragedy happen to them. I genuinely don’t know how to defend that behavior on principles of free speech and genuinely wished Alex Jones was stopped years earlier. Michelle Carter convinced her boyfriend to commit suicide over text messages and was convicted for it. I don’t know if I disagree that trying to use speech to convince a sick person into suicide shouldn’t be legal. But at the same time I’m generally a free speech proponent and find jailing people for speech abhorrent. But I struggle to believe all speech should be legal if it knowingly ruins lives or causes death.
- potatototoo99 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mc32 4y agoFrom the actions of Twitter, FB, TT, YT, etc., yes, it seems that this is what people want, with the proviso that _they_ are the ones that set the rules for what is allowable and what is censorable. To this day, if you have an opinion that is against mainstream regarding Covid, you risk getting banned. So health and political themes are moderately moderated for deviance. And by moderately I mean lots gets through just because their tools are imperfect not because that's what they want.
- andsoitis 4y ago> if you have an opinion that is against mainstream regarding Covid, you risk getting banned. What is a good example of non-mainstream COVID speech that has gotten someone banned? (Not saying it doesn’t exist, I’m just wondering what’s a good example you have in mind)
- xkcd1963 4y agoAre you a Chinese bot or something?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dang 4y agoPosting like this will get you banned here, regardless of how wrong someone is or you feel they are. If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules, we'd appreciate it.
- xkcd1963 4y agoOkay thank you. Is it a coincidence that your username sounds Chinese? I meant no discrimination. Also, I feel policed around.
- dang 4y agoWhat difference does it make if my username sounds Chinese? "Policed around" doesn't sound like a pleasant feeling but I can at least assure you it's nothing personal. We moderate HN when people break the site guidelines.