6 ms·
An Open-Source HDMI Capture Card
- dismalpedigree 4y agoDoes it work with HDCP signals?
- BlackLotus89 4y agoFrom the README > Integrated pre-programmed HDCP keys for Loop Out So my answer would be. Yes
- gh02t 4y agoOut of curiosity, why would the group that hands out HDCP certifications certify a chip like this? I get that practically speaking they have to issue keys for some capture devices for legitimate uses, but this chip/board seems like something the HDCP folks would want to keep locked down. I think HDCP is silly/evil, but this chip does seem counter to its purpose.
- oplaadpunt 4y agoI believe the HDCP keys for the lower standards were leaked, right? It's 4K you need certification for I think to get the keys.
- gh02t 4y agoSure but you can't legally sell a product using the leaked keys AFAIU. Plus this supports 4K (albeit at 30 Hz). This board is built around what appears to be a fully legit HDMI chip with HDCP compliance best I can tell (MS2130? Github page also mentions a couple other related chips... one of them has to be the HDMI chip), though I'm having trouble finding a datasheet link because Google is dominated by this Hackaday page. Why the HDCP people tolerate such a chip/don't tightly control who can buy it is what I'm asking... I'm guessing maybe this is an "off label" use of a chip that was meant for more mundane HDMI decoding uses. Which kinda illustrates why HDCP is silly and an annoyance for consumers that doesn't really stop the "real" pirates making content rips people are downloading. Though I didn't intend this as a loaded question, I might totally misunderstand what's going on technically speaking and would love for someone who knows about this to explain.
- Nextgrid 4y ago> Sure but you can't legally sell a product using the leaked keys AFAIU. I’m sure Chinese manufacturers care a lot about what the HDCP people want.
- charlieegan3 4y agoI have an Elgato Cam Link 4K and it's a pain to use with my Sony camera and M1 MacBook (webcam scenario). I find that the card needs an entire USB _bus_ (not port) to itself to function without the stream freezing regularly - even on 1080p. This means I can't connect it via my thunderbolt dock (CalDigit Element Hub). Does anyone know if this open implementation would have the same issue?
- GiorgioG 4y agoMust be a Mac only issue (or maybe your dock?) because I have no such problems on my desktop PC (similar setup: camlink4k, Sony a6000).
- Teledhil 4y agoI have no issues with the Elgato Cam Link 4K on my setup: M1 Pro <-> Dell WD19TB <-> Cam Link <-> Sony camera. The dock is also connected to a 1440p@240 monitor and a 1080p@60 monitor, so the capture card is not the only device taking bandwith from the USB bus. EDIT: Now that I remember, sometimes the cam link gets very hot and freezes, not only with my M1 but also with a Dell laptop running linux. Maybe your problem is related to running the capture card at high temperatures.
- scyzoryk_xyz 4y agoI too had issues with the Elgato on a MacBook. But it’s a piece of shit and a pain in the ass on the PC as well for me. Hate that thing with a passion. We also bought several cheaper generic ones and they work/don’t work just as often as the Elgato. That being said, we switch around our setup a lot, and we juggle multi-can streams. ¯\_(ಠ_ಠ)_/¯
- iwillbenice 4y agoMe and two of my friends have been using the Elgato 4K cam link for a year every day for streaming. Not a single issue reported. Perhaps you have a faulty unit.
- veidr 4y agoI've found this to be an issue with Thunderbolt docks generally. I've tried Cam Link 4K with the Caldigit TB3 dock (TS3?) and the OWC Thunderbolt Dock (the big ass one with the power adapter the size of a Volkswagen bus) and some Anker TB3 dock. All of them glitched, compared to plugging it straight into the Mac (albeit via a dongle since it was always MacBook Pro models which lack the regular USB port and only have the Apple fantasy-world ports). This kind of soured me on Thunderbolt docks. The other problematic device was ATEM Mini (which is like a Cam Link except it has 4 HDMI inputs instead of 1) so perhaps it is some kind of HDMI → Thunderbolt → USB fuckery?
- BlackLotus89 4y agowould be interesting to know if it supports surround sound audio capture can't find a datasheet to check
- MayeulC 4y agoIt's a bit annoying that this card doesn't come with an in-situ programmer to update the NOR FLASH. Other than this, I'm pretty excited about it. I can't wait for it to be cheaply be available from Aliexpress or other. Is it compatible with generic v4l drivers?
- formerly_proven 4y agoThe no-name capture cards are all based on the same few fixed-function MacroSilicon chips like the one used here, so the HAD quip about issues with them that you'd avoid with this doesn't really make sense.
- spicyjpeg 4y agoThere actually were a few legitimate issues with the previous generation of USB-2.0-only capture chips from MacroSilicon. The original MS2109 used in all those AliExpress capture dongles was designed for 720p capture; it could do 1080p at 30fps, but it would downscale the input to 720p and rescale it up in the process. 1080p mode was still useful, however, as it made MJPEG quantization artifacts far less prominent [1]. There was also another huge problem with those dongles, but it was not MacroSilicon's fault. At some point most of the sellers started offering a more expensive "USB 3.0" variant reportedly capable of capturing 1080p at 60fps... which of course was a scam, since the MS2109 is 2.0 only (literally the only difference in these cards was the connector being blue, they didn't even have 3.0 pins). Many YouTubers, not knowing about this, kept recommending people to get the 3.0 version, which resulted in these cards getting a negative reputation for being "okay but unreliable". This project is basically what those fake cards should have been. [1] https://www.naut.ca/blog/2020/07/09/cheap-hdmi-capture-card-review/ https://www.naut.ca/blog/2020/07/09/cheap-hdmi-capture-card-...
- OJFord 4y agoDoes anyone have any advice (other than 'just do it, try it, learn as you go, pick a datasheet') for getting into higher-speed designs, in order to play with USBC/HDMI/Ethernet/SATA/etc.? I enjoy Phil's Lab on YouTube which seems a pretty good resource, but I still think it would be naïve of me to jump in and expect to be able to design something that works. E.g. I couldn't find a USB-C SATA adaptor that used PD to power the disk. Even the USB3 ones will do a 2.5" disk, but all of them, even if USBC, require a separate power cable for hungrier disks. I thought that was silly, and ought to be relatively easy to make. Is there a good book for taking (digital) electronics beyond basics (i.e./and that isn't through a lens of Arduino or ESP or whatever) as a hobby? Protocols & design/layout for higher speeds is I suppose where I'm most lacking. My background: EE but professionally only CS. (Even at university ended up choosing more CS-y/information-theoretic-y courses than electronics tbh.) Hobby electronics (off & on I suppose) since as long ago as I can remember, but haven't designed a PCB since high school. Most recently (a year or so ago) breadboarded a USB serial Ethernet bridge for my Prusa Mini.
- rjsw 4y agoMy bridge between professional programming and hobby electronics was FPGAs.
- OJFord 4y agoI did some FPGA stuff at university, I'm more comfortable there for sure, but only on a dev board someone else has made - I'd have the same problem getting started with designing an FPGA board as I described for USB/HDMI/etc. above.
- danhor 4y agoMy experience was that implementing/modifying an existing (basic) fpga ethernet stack is pretty doable, since you quickly get an indication that something works and there are very distinct layers. The colorlight 5a-75b together with Litex is a great way to get started for cheap. If you want something even more basic, https://github.com/kingyoPiyo/Pico-10BASE-T https://github.com/kingyoPiyo/Pico-10BASE-T is very simple. Layout for most consumer standards is pretty lax, almost anything will probably work.
- villgax 4y agoWould kill for open source HDMI passthrough device which outputs gradients for TV/LED strip lighting
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoYou can do it with a raspberry pi and a splitter https://g13g.blog/2021/03/10/open-source-ambilight-leds-on-a-raspberry-pi-for-100/ https://g13g.blog/2021/03/10/open-source-ambilight-leds-on-a... https://github.com/hyperion-project/hyperion.ng https://github.com/hyperion-project/hyperion.ng
- phcreery 4y agoCan this be used with pikvm? https://pikvm.org/ https://pikvm.org/ Passthrough to physical monitor instead of "virtual" monitor would be ideal for my use case. I wish I could mirror in software but I have not found a way to do so.
- samwestdev 4y agoWhere can I buy one of those prebuilt and shipped?
- e-_pusher 4y agoDoes anyone know what is the latency one might expect from an HDMI capture card like this?
- BlackLotus89 4y agohttps://twitter.com/GLGH_/status/1577690713906900992 https://twitter.com/GLGH_/status/1577690713906900992
- e-_pusher 4y agoWow. This looks great, I would need to get my hands on some of these boards …
- throwaway81523 4y agoThis is a PCB wrapped around a black box chip HDMI to USB chip, according to the article. Is that interesting all by itself? I expected that open source HDMI capture would involve an FPGA or similar decoding the HDMI signal.
- jareklupinski 4y agoone step at a time :)