3 ms·
Why not everyone have 1 child, until the world's population is down to a few hundred million people and they can all live lives of extreme wealth? The issue wi
by roenxi 4y ago
Why not everyone have 1 child, until the world's population is down to a few hundred million people and they can all live lives of extreme wealth?
The issue with this sort of thinking - most plans that assume a good outcome, really - is the real question here is how many people will inhabit the world. The default strategy that math (and human instinct) drives towards is just enough people that on average they start starving.
And if people are going to keep going until they starve _anyway_, what is the problem with some living well?
- onikolas7 4y agoIt will put very strong pressure during the transition with a few young people supporting a larger aging population (see Japan). It's also opposed by capitalists as it goes against the infinite growth mantra (see for example Musk's comments on the subject). More importantly, it won't do anything in the short term where we need it urgently.
- roenxi 4y agoI think your comment is pretty reasonable, but I really can't resist making this observation. > It will put very strong pressure during the transition... As opposed to exponential growth? With the number of people we've got wandering around, we're one slightly-worse-than-COVID disaster away from 100s of millions to billions of people starving to death. An outcome like Japan's is significantly better than what is likely to happen in Africa.
- onikolas7 4y agoNo, I agree, it is the sensible thing to be doing, but it looks like we are at a point where radical short term fixes are needed.
- nextaccountic 4y agoThe human population growth is not rising exponentially, the growth is actually declining since the 1960s and by 2100 we may not even grow anymore https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_growth#Population_growth_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_growth#Population_g... https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/06/17/worlds-population-is-projected-to-nearly-stop-growing-by-the-end-of-the-century/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/06/17/worlds-popu...
- Silverback_VII 4y agothe only is to push forward - into space - other no only man but also nature will be stuck here forever.
- hnbad 4y agoIf we all live like billionaires, who does the actual labor affording us this lifestyle? Starvation poverty is not the result of overpopulation. Quite the contrary: people in extreme conditions are more likely to have more children because high child mortality means any individual child is less likely to surive so if you want a heir (and an income provider since child labor likely also exists), you'll need more of them. Studies have shown again and again that raising the standard of living (and access to medical care and family planning) reduces population growth. Studies have also shown that extreme wealth disparity directly leads to social instability (read: crime). Not simply poverty but poverty next to oppulence. If you want a stable society with a stable population size, you need low wealth inequality. If you want to eliminate extreme poverty, you need to eliminate extreme wealth. Changing tax law so billionaires can't exist won't fix poverty but it will seal a constant drain on societal wealth and make it easier to fund public works programmes to empower people to leave poverty and welfare programmes to support those who can't. Of course that's a much less edgy answer than just letting poor people starve because they're just too dumb to make good choices like not being poor or not being born in a country coerced to optimize their economy for the cheap export of unrefined resources and low-value cash crops wealthier nations can refine and use to create luxury goods to sell back to them at a massive premium.
- roenxi 4y ago> If you want to eliminate extreme poverty, you need to eliminate extreme wealth. That is rather off the mark on a couple of levels. Say there is a billionaire and a society of homeless indigents. We set the billionaire's house on fire and wreck all his stuff. This has no impact whatsoever on the people in extreme poverty. That silly example has played out in practice in a couple of ways (communism being the most showy). There is a compelling picture that allowing extremely wealthy individuals to flourish is good for the communities they are in. Once people start adopting policies to curtail or confiscate resources from people who create wealth it is easy to lose control and end up in a bad spot.
- mistermann 4y ago> That is rather off the mark on a couple of levels. Say there is a billionaire and a society of homeless indigents. We set the billionaire's house on fire and wreck all his stuff. This has no impact whatsoever on the people in extreme poverty. Alternatively, you could just set his pool house on fire, and then ask if he would like to ~voluntarily change his tune or find out what happens next. Kinda like this, with appropriate modifications: https://youtu.be/q4PkBCD4mdY https://youtu.be/q4PkBCD4mdY