4 ms·
So who would decide where the shares go, and who gets to runs the company now? Which pension funds get the shares and why? I'm guessing government bureaucrats w
by simonh 4y ago
So who would decide where the shares go, and who gets to runs the company now? Which pension funds get the shares and why? I'm guessing government bureaucrats with no track record of making sound investments or running companies, who I'm sure wouldn't get cushy jobs at the pension funds after they retired. Nationalising industries like this, and yes that's really what this would become, has been tried many times and it just doesn't work.
The way to address wealth inequality is through tax and inheritance reform to shift the incentive system. They way to address political cronyism is political funding reform. Changing the ownership structure of corporations by putting them int eh hands of bureaucrats isn't going to do anything whatever to address either of those issues, in fact it would almost certainly make both of them much worse.
The reason we have billionaires is because these are the people that create tens of thousands of jobs, produce innovative products, provide valuable services. The billionaire owner of a company doesn't have billions of dollars in cash, that wealth is embodied in the value of the jobs and goods and services that make up the companies they control. So if you're going to take that away from them, who do you give it all to? Who gets to decide that?
The fact is capitalism for all it's flaws does work, and compared to the alternative systems that have been tried it's spectacularly successful. Capitalism has raised billions of people worldwide out of poverty, and raised hundreds of millions of people into the middle class. In fact today for the first time in history half the world's population is middle class. These are staggering achievements made possible by unleashing the creative power of individual people exercising straight forward individual economic freedoms. The freedoms that you want to take away.
- Bubble_Pop_22 4y agoA billionaire is just a guy who was piloting the plane during a flight which got a once in a lifetime 200mph tailwind. Now idiots are convinced the pilot is special , wiseguys don’t believe in fairytales and they just look at the weather chart for that flight so that the truth becomes perfectly crystal clear. That is all there is to it. If playing roulette was as popular as business or hustling in general, (being played by 8bn people 24/7/365) you’d have billionaires roulette players too. Doesn’t mean they are special it’s just that with a sample that big somebody is bound to be benefiting from the 200mph tailwind