2 ms·
Why can't economists predict financial crises?
- quantified 4y agoThey're not purely rational actors, and economic theories don't connect sufficiently to the real world. Many economists are politicians with economic sense. If you see things one way, progressive income tax is a jobs-creation program because as soon as you're disincented to earn more due to taxes, you leave opportunity available for someone else to earn something. If you see things another way, it is a grab by the unworthy on your hard-earned wins. (Thank you N Gregory Mankiw for clarifying this a number of years back.) They also live in the same bubbles. The real estate bubble of 2001-2008 was super clear if you didn't spend your time in it. But since they can't or don't look at enough details (fraud in the CDO's, total outstanding credit default swaps, who is exposed to who) and they don't understand or model human factors such as criminality and deviousness, they can't do a very good job.
- simonh 4y agoI came across a Youtube channel about 6 months ago that's been predicting that the "big crash" has already started for well over a year. I just checked and he's still at it. One day he'll be right, and markets are down, but not by the 90%+ this guy has been going on about. In the medium term it's not about the direction, that's relatively easy as markets overall tend to spend most of their time going the same way they have been for the previous months. The problem is predicting the inflections.
- paulpauper 4y agoThe existence of such an indicator would cause it to stop working. Markets adapt to new information.
- jerojero 4y agoAs much as economists hate to say it, economics is a social science. Sure, it's the pretty sister of the social sciences but at the end of the day it can't ignore people's behaviours and with this comes a lot of unpredictability and uncertainty. There are simply too many moving pieces to be able to properly predict things, until you've got certainty that all the right pieces have moved you can't really say much. But of course, part of being a good economist will involve being able to see the major possible lines and adjust your models based on that. In any case, we've had financial crisis over and over again so it's clear they're a feature of the system rather than an exception and I think maybe there could be some dogmatic elements to this; it might be difficult to accept the flaws in the system which might let you view things in a more positive way than what reality really is.