3 ms·
I think you missed the most important group: 4. People that think climate change is real, and investments to mitigate damages should be weighed on a cost/benef
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
I think you missed the most important group:
4. People that think climate change is real, and investments to mitigate damages should be weighed on a cost/benefit basis.
That is to say, for a given change, how much will it hurt people to mitigate it now vs later, given the time value of money and exponential development.
People in #1 and #2 dogmatically believe the answer always falls into act now or act later.
Luckily, most governments end up taking some sort of a middle road between these extremes.
- ncmncm 4y agoMeaning, of course, tragically.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIm not actually sure of your meaning.
- ncmncm 4y agoClimate catastrophe is imminent, and governments dragging their feet are directly responsible. It is very far from clear that civilization collapse will be averted.
- phpisthebest 4y agoSo then you are in group 1.... Clearly. Most people disagree
- ncmncm 4y agoNo, because almost everything that could be done about averting climate catastrophe would be massively good for the economy and global prosperity, immediately. It could be uncomfortable for owners of coal mines and oil supply chain companies. You telegraph your sympathies. Global civilization collapse followed by billions starving and thermonuclear war will not end up good for anybody. But with some luck you could die first, something foot-draggers seem to count on. Why should they risk any hint of (expected) discomfort for benefits they would not anyway live to see? What have their grandchildren ever done for them?
- phpisthebest 4y ago>>because almost everything that could be done about averting climate catastrophe would be massively good for the economy and global prosperity, immediately ROFL.... nothing is further from the truth, the cost of "green" energy is massively regressive for people in "rich" nations like the US. Hell just the cost of replacing gas cars with EV's would be HUGE on most people, and EV can not replace every type of vehicle (see people that have to tow anything) That is not getting into the huge problem for norther climates where sure Heat pumps have come a long way but still are not as good as a NatGas for extreme cold climate There are countless other technological problems that will make daily expenses of people massively more costly than they are with traditional energy.
- ncmncm 4y agoYou seem unaware of the huge tax you pay for continued access to petroleum. To a large degree, most of military expense is to maintain that access. Energy from renewables will be vastly cheaper than humanity has ever experienced since the forests were wiped out, and will fuel a golden age. Provided, of course, that civilization does not collapse first, as you seem to say you would prefer.
- prottog 4y agoYou keep claiming that the GP would prefer civilization to collapse. Nothing in their writing suggests that, and your only proof is that they disagree with your assertion that a climate catastrophe is imminent and can only be averted by radical means. Again, that puts you in their category 1. > Energy from renewables will be vastly cheaper than humanity has ever experienced Handwaving "will be" is not good enough for policy.
- ncmncm 4y agoYou have evidently not seen the cost curves of renewable energy sources. They have declined through many orders of magnitude, with no end in sight, similarly to transistors following Moore's Law. "Will be" is exactly what policy needs to be based on. Policy based on "what was" is policy failure. You are very confused about this "category 1". Literally nobody advocates for any measure that would interfere with economic prosperity. Action preventing climate catastrophe and collapse of civilization would discomfit only those heavily bought into the petroleum economy.