2 ms·
I don't think the scooter battery example is particularly great. It seems like you're saying that perhaps ongoing battery use might be creating some ongoing har
by mindslight 4y ago
I don't think the scooter battery example is particularly great. It seems like you're saying that perhaps ongoing battery use might be creating some ongoing harm where we would be better off prematurely end-of-lifing the existing ones. But either way the battery needs to be disposed of, and round trip storage efficiency is already high enough to make ongoing inefficency not much of a consideration.
I'd also point out that centralization is more likely to make destructive sweeping changes. An individual could keep limping along with their old battery with only 30% capacity, just for short trips and whatnot. Whereas a company would be inclined to scrap old scooters much earlier to keep their fleet uniform and ready for the needs of any user.
A better example is the automobile market, where we've already got the distributed-incentives situation. This seems to be getting handled just fine with EV subsidies and "cash for clunkers" (criticism of that program notwithstanding). Perhaps adoption is slower than we want, but there could also be more direct incentives to upgrade if they were needed, or even just higher gas taxes. Operating on the distributed model where individuals are free to judge their own situation seems better than centralizing things so that they can be changed quicker just in case the need arises.