6 ms·
We hit over 1 million dead after flattening the curve, effective treatments, and a huge swath of the most vulnerable population getting vaccinated before infec
by Retric 4y ago
We hit over 1 million dead after flattening the curve, effective treatments, and a huge swath of the most vulnerable population getting vaccinated before infection.
Models showing 4% IFRs without drastic measures like lockdowns seem fairly accurate to me. Simply letting COVID run rampant may have done less economic damage because it’s vastly less deadly to working age populations, but we would have barbarically sacrificed a significant chunk of the population for little gain.
- junofan 4y ago[flagged]
- spookthesunset 4y ago> Models showing 4% IFRs without drastic measures like lockdowns seem fairly accurate to me. The infection fatality rate is: deaths / anybody who is infected. Everybody is gonna get Covid, mitigations or not, so the denominator is always going to be the same. IFR is independent of mitigations. The only way the IFR might change is if healthcare systems got so overrun that they could no longer give care. This did not happen anywhere in the industrialized world. In fact all of the temporary field hospitals here in the states were closed virtually. The models showing a 4% IFR were pure fantasy. The IFR for a healthy human under like 65 is something less than %0.1. If you are a kid, your risks are lower than dying in a house fire.
- Retric 4y agoYou can’t argue about a zero social distancing world based on data from countries that implemented social distancing. Doing nothing means seeing what IFR rakes look like without a healthcare system. Even with all the existing measures, many areas ran out of ICU beds. All those deferred surgeries had an actual cost in human lives because you can’t simply delay cancer treatment without issue. I will say it again, some people with cancer died because of the COVID pandemic even without getting infected. Anything less than what we did would have further overburdened the healthcare system. Doing absolutely nothing and even less serious cases that responded to such basic measures as IV fluids would have killed people without a functioning healthcare system.
- GeekyBear 4y ago> You can’t argue about a zero social distancing world based on data from countries that implemented social distancing. You can very easily argue that the mitigations we put in place were based on the theory that Covid only had a droplet based spread, like the flu. The problem is that Covid is fully airborne, like measles, so the mitigations we put into place were ineffective. Social distancing is a good example: A person infected with a virus that has a droplet based spread will spray out droplets when they cough or sneeze and those droplets will fall to the ground within six feet of their emission. An airborne virus is emitted by people even when they are just breathing normally, and can stay suspended in the air for hours. An airborne virus will spread throughout an enclosed space. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-00925-7 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-00925-7
- Retric 4y agoYour argument falls apart when you consider closing down movie theaters and schools stops both. The initial version of COVID was airborne but didn’t spread that fast compared to say measles so it didn’t take much to bring transmission below replacement rate in most areas. More recent versions are more easily transmissible but are dealing with higher levels of immunity due to vaccination and prior exposure. When modeling such repeated outbreaks people who where at the highest risk for transmission due to coming into contact with others regularly where also the first to gain immunity from less easily transmissible strains.
- GeekyBear 4y agoYour argument falls apart when you remember that the mitigations we put into place were highly effective against the Flu, which does have a droplet based spread, but were completely ineffective at stopping the spread of Covid, which continued to spread like wildfire. >CDC says seasonal flu cases hit record lows around the world https://www.nbcnews.com/health/cold-and-flu/cdc-says-seasonal-flu-cases-hit-record-lows-around-world-n1240333 https://www.nbcnews.com/health/cold-and-flu/cdc-says-seasona... > COVID may have pushed a leading seasonal flu strain to extinction https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/09/covid-may-have-pushed-a-leading-seasonal-flu-strain-to-extinction/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/09/covid-may-have-pushe...
- PuppyTailWags 4y ago> The only way the IFR might change is if healthcare systems got so overrun that they could no longer give care. This did not happen anywhere in the industrialized world. In fact all of the temporary field hospitals here in the states were closed virtually. Are you sure, especially particularly early & also this late? My understanding is that several crucial treatments were mass-deferred, several places had no beds, the dead were literally stacked on trucks, and the medical system has been utterly destroyed either from staff falling ill or getting so emotionally destroyed that they've quit. Wasn't there a mainstream situation a bit ago where a nurse literally had to call the fire department because of lack of medical staff? My understanding is that hospitals still haven't recovered in terms of staffing.
- mikeyouse 4y agoYes, the person you’re replying to is clueless. Even with all of the lockdowns, distancing, masking, and tons of other interventions - hospitals all over were on the brink of collapse. I have 3 immediate family members who are hospitalists in the US and each of their hospitals was in extremely dire straits. 100% bed occupancy, no non-emergent surgeries, diverting patients to neighboring states.
- nightski 4y agoNot sure where you are getting your information, even in our city of 250k the hospitals were full and turning away care.
- slaw 4y agoHospitals were close to full before covid and are full now. Op is talking about temporary hospitals for covid patients which were empty. https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/health/wa-hospitals-are-far-over-capacity-as-backlogs-and-staff-shortages-add-up/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/health/wa-hospital...
- Retric 4y agoThat’s talking about a recent snapshot not what things where like at the peak of the pandemic. In 2022 hospitals are as it says getting back to patients who’s treatment where deferred during earlier peaks.
- devmor 4y ago> The only way the IFR might change is if healthcare systems got so overrun that they could no longer give care. This did not happen anywhere in the industrialized world. What world do you live in? It certainly isn't mine. One of my co-workers passed away in her home after being turned away from the ER in part due to no hospitals in the area having available ventilators.
- brnaftr361 4y agoMy worry is that we've displaced the casualties to a far less visible causal agent. There's a lot of economic variables that have been pulled at every level, from the individual to the state, to global concerns. And I think these are more pernicious and difficult to track than would be a disease, but I do expect the impact to, overall, be more severe that it otherwise would've been without the (perhaps naive) interventionism. That's just a hypothesis.
- fallingknife 4y agoIf you compare CA vs FL, FL only has a 10% higher age adjusted population mortality rate from covid. This indicates that some the strictest covid measures in the US made little difference vs the laxest. You can point to other countries if you want, and you would be right, but the type of strict measures that China used to stop the virus are not remotely politically possible in the US (and thank god they aren't). source: https://www.bioinformaticscro.com/blog/states-ranked-by-age-adjusted-covid-deaths/ https://www.bioinformaticscro.com/blog/states-ranked-by-age-...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Retric 4y agoThe US healthcare system moved resources around to respond to more critical areas. As such things are less independent than you are suggesting. That said, look at the worst states on that list and you will notice a trend. Mississippi, Oklahoma, Tennessee, Texas, Kentucky, Alabama aren’t the states with extremely high density cities like NYC with the highest natural transmission rates, they are the states that failed.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoIt's definitely a trend that states with higher rates of obesity and hypertension have higher death rates. But since those are known comorbidities, not particularly surprising.
- Retric 4y agoMississippi and WV had obesity rates of 39.5% in 2018, yet Mississippi was 476 where WV was 364 so something else is going on. Especially when you consider Delaware’s 33.5% obesity in 2018 somehow only resulted in 289. Turns out states with stronger responses had better results independent of what population density and demographics would suggest.
- 4y ago
- jimbob45 4y agoSimply letting COVID run rampant may have done less economic damage because it’s vastly less deadly to working age populations, but we would have sacrificed a significant chunk of the population. There are also the forgotten fears of mutation and the unknown of the disease. PPP was envisioned/passed around April 2020. Back then, we knew relatively little of the disease and feared it becoming deadlier and more transmissible if it were able to evolve. Fortunately, it didn't (to the degree we feared) but it very well may have if the US had simply let it run loose.
- landemva 4y agoPrincess Diamond taught the world early into it that some people didn't get sick, even when locked in room with spouse who was sick. There was some natural immunity.
- rayiner 4y ago> Simply letting COVID run rampant may have done less economic damage because it’s vastly less deadly to working age populations, but we would have barbarically sacrificed a significant chunk of the population for little gain Saved Medicare and SS spending.
- themitigating 4y agoThe people most likely to vote republican while taking government handouts use social security and medicare
- xyzzyz 4y agoAfter being forced to pay for SS and Medicare for your entire working life, it is unreasonable to expect people to not use them, even if they believe that SS and Medicare should not exist. This is akin to wealthy professionals, who vote Democrat and support higher taxes, but nevertheless take advantage of all tax deductions available to them. Many such cases. There is nothing hypocritical here: it is pointless to damage yourself by either refusing SS checks or paying more taxes than you’re legally required, even if you are against SS or for higher taxes, because these individual actions will do nothing to bring about the policies you want.
- themitigating 4y ago"This is akin to wealthy professionals, who vote Democrat and support higher taxes, but nevertheless take advantage of all tax deductions available to them" This counter example doesn't work because democrats aren't advocating for these to be changed
- prottog 4y agoNaturally it's risky to assume that all Democrats agree with each other on every single policy position, but if you mean that Democrats aren't asking for more tax deductions, a very recent example of this very thing happening was with trying to roll back the SALT cap imposed by TCJA.
- prottog 4y ago> We hit over 1 million dead The median age of a Covid-associated death in the US, with its hugely obese and unhealthy population, is about the same as the average life expectancy. (You can see here[0] that over half of all "deaths involving Covid" are aged 75 and over, compared against the US life expectancy between 78-79.) You refer to "less economic damage", but that's the least of it. Diseases and deaths of despair like suicides or drug abuse shot up tremendously. Civil liberties were greatly degraded, and precedent has now been set for substantial suspension of normal life by executive fiat -- the old adage of never letting a crisis go to waste rings true. It's incomprehensibly more barbaric the way that we insisted on schools closing for multiple years, with most of the burden of learning loss falling on children whose parents aren't wealthy enough to hire private tutors or even have a separate room in their house for their so-called remote classes. In a country where a fifth of high-school graduates are functionally illiterate, that's a real tragedy. All this for a disease that more often than not kills those who were already going to die very soon, anyway! Of course people think mistakes were made in policy. [0]: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid_weekly/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid_weekly/index.htm
- Retric 4y agoYou just described what happened with mitigating strategies but 1 million dead are the good outcome not what would have happened if we lead the disease run rampant. We didn’t have an option for nobody died and nothing bad happened, just how many deaths where acceptable. As to COVID just taking those near death, looking at just the US deaths from COVID in 2020 estimates suggest on average people would have lived another 14.5 years if they hadn’t been infected. But that understates the impact as the elderly got vaccinated earlier so 2021 and 2022 deaths tended to be younger than 2020 deaths. https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/06/16/americans-lost-more-years-of-life-to-covid-19-in-2020-than-to-all-accidents-combined-in-a-typical-year/ft_2021-06-16_covidyearslost_01/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/06/16/americans-l... In a world without social distancing the extra deaths would have largely come from younger healthier people who couldn’t get access to basic treatments from a healthcare system past the breaking point.
- 4y ago