3 ms·
Another point, discussed in Arthur Koestler's The Sleepwalkers (I'm going from memory, so there may be slight errors), is that the Copernican model was pretty u
by DavidSJ 4y ago
Another point, discussed in Arthur Koestler's The Sleepwalkers (I'm going from memory, so there may be slight errors), is that the Copernican model was pretty ugly:
1. It actually required more epicycles than the Ptolemaic model.
2. It didn't even have the other planets orbit the Sun! Rather, they orbited the center of the Earth's orbit (???).
Kepler's laws fixed all of this, but Galileo ignored all of Kepler's correspondence, except for one time when he found it profitable to use him: He had made claims about the Jovian moons based on observations through his telescope, but he refused to let other astronomers borrow that instrument so they could reproduce his observations. Kepler wrote to Galileo offering to defend him, and Galileo accepted. Then later, after Kepler had already publicly defended him and himself requested access to the telescope to verify the observations, he was ignored, as per all other times Kepler wrote him before and after.
- triknomeister 4y agoWell, both things are wrong, planets do not orbit the sun or the center of earth's orbit, but the center of solar system, which is actually outside the sun.
- cygx 4y agoIt's true that due to the large mass of Jupiter, the barycenter of the solar system lies outside the surface of the sun. However, the barycenter of any sun/planet 2-body system besides Jupiter lies within the sun's surface, so I'm quite comfortable with the claim that at the very least most planets do orbit the sun...