4 ms·
And what, pray tell, happens when workers refuse to work at "market wages"[1]? There is no such thing as an "unrestricted negotiation"; only shuffling the rest
by woodruffw 4y ago
And what, pray tell, happens when workers refuse to work at "market wages"[1]?
There is no such thing as an "unrestricted negotiation"; only shuffling the restriction to disfavor workers rather than their bosses. We're a nation of free people, and that freedom includes our right to band together and compel better treatment (in the form of hours, conditions, and wages) from our employers.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homestead_strike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homestead_strike
- ETH_start 4y ago>>And what, pray tell, happens when workers refuse to work at "market wages" By the very definition of "market wages", those who are willing to work at market wages get the jobs and those who are not do not. >>only shuffling the restriction to disfavor workers rather than their bosses Workers are not restricted at all when they negotiate, except when a union has monopolized the workforce of a company, and they cannot apply for a job at the company because they are not a member of the union. >>freedom includes our right to band together and compel better treatment Compelling someone who doesn't want to associate with you, to associate with you, is not an exercise of freedom. It's explotiation.
- cauefcr 4y ago>Compelling someone who doesn't want to associate with you, to associate with you, is not an exercise of freedom. It's explotiation. Yes, that's exactly why unions are needed, there is no way to live in capitalism without selling your work-force, or living out of rent on other people's work-force, by owning the means of production. If an owner wants to decrease wages of their workers, they may only receive resistance if the workers are unionized, as that is the only (non-revolution) way to sort of even out the playing field. Just a reminder: Unless you're financially independent, you're not a capitalist, you're a worker, lets not fall for the "anyone can become a capitalist" bullshit, as that ignores the material conditions of most of earth. edit: grammar.
- ETH_start 4y ago>>Yes, that's exactly why unions are needed, there is no way to live in capitalism without selling your work-force, or living out of rent on other people's work-force, by owning the means of production No one compels any one to do anything under the capitalist ruleset, which is simply a ruleset that restricts interactions to those that are mutually voluntary. And hiring someone and making a profit by employing them to operate your capital (what you Marxists call "means of production) is not "economic rent". The enterprise/capital that enables the labor to produce more value than is expended to hire it is provided by the business owner, and contributes value to the economy. I strongly recommend you don't base your understanding of Economics on Marxism. Marxism gives no credit to investors for their role in providing capital. Marxism just takes it for granted that capital will emerge, when in reality you need to compensate those who create capital, through the process of saving and investment, in order to incentivize its emergence. Marxism's non-recognition of this fact is not only a massive oversight that makes the theoretical framework utterly pseudoscientific, it is a consequence of the fact that Marxist theories are totally motivated by an anti-rich ideology, as opposed to the pursuit of scientific truth. >>If an owner wants to decrease wages of their workers, they may only receive resistance if the workers are unionized This is totally baseless. Wages for unskilled labor doubled between 1870 and 1900, a period during which unions were extremely weak, and there was a massive influx of poor immigrants to the US pushing up labor supply which would counter-act the economic forces that push up wage rates. There are other forces that push wages up besides the violations of contract freedom that can locally push up wages for unions. Unlike laws that give unions local monopolies on workforces, economic forces like investment don't depress wages economy-wide. They are positive sum, leading to generalized wage growth.
- cauefcr 4y agoI strongly recommend you to actually read some Marx, it might get you out of the Web3 sham, but here's a good economic analysis of cryptocurrencies if you haven't seen it yet (judging from your username you need to see it) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQ_xWvX1n9g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQ_xWvX1n9g .
- 4y ago